7 ms·
macOS’s ancient problems still exist in 2022
- bitigchi 5y agoAuthor does not understand zoom. Zoom is not supposed to fill the entire available screen, it's supposed to only take whatever the content requires to fill. Zoom is not maximise, never has been. Chrome is the offender here.
- jleyank 5y agoWhy should an O/S be different from other software? There's no money in fixing bugs or improving performance unless either are so bad that it's a marketing problem. People want features not fixes. Marketeers want features. Developers like new, neat things rather than fixing (hard) problems. And the industry has all sorts of confusion as to what the desktop/deskside things are for. They're not watches or phones. They're way more capable and thus way more complicated. If they didn't need some place to create applications they'd just toss the things. If's not as if Windows is any better? Haven't they changed the UI paradigm a few times (I'm a mac/linux person)? If so, this is worse than not changing it at all. 50 years on and the damned stuff isn't really easier to use and isn't really any faster unless some thought goes into the development. And it still overtaxes the hardware.
- rekabis 5y ago> Apps Remain Running (and Focused) After Being Closed If you’re complaining about this, you don’t understand Mac OS. Mac is a multi-window system. Unlike Windows or Linux or BSD, a program can have multiple windows open at once, each window potentially doing vastly different things. That is why that red dot doesn’t actually close the program. It only closes the current window, leaving all other windows - and the program itself - still up and running. For a multi-window paradigm, this is logical, rational, and expected.
- SalimoS 5y agoand this exemple show either the writer don’t understand how macOS really work or he just trying to force the Windows way unsuccessfully
- wtallis 5y agoReally, most of the content in the article is horribly contrived complaints. The "Informational Redundancy" screenshot shows at least two UI elements that are hidden by default. The complaint about how quitting the Finder makes desktop icons disappear misleadingly neglects to mention whatever hacks he had to use to get the Quit action to show up in the menu in the first place, because it's not available by default for precisely this reason. This guy is putting real effort into misrepresenting the stuff he's complaining about.
- howinteresting 5y agoPrograms can have many windows open on other OSes too, all doing different things. They can also stay running after the last window has been closed. The question is what the default behavior of applications is, and macOS is just plain inferior to other OSes in that regard.
- hnaccy 5y ago>and macOS is just plain inferior to other OSes in that regard. this just seems like a matter of taste
- retrac 5y agoTrying to exit one of those windowless programs on Windows at least, can be rather hidden functionality, and may involve resorting to the task manager. On mac OS, by default it's in the dock if it's open, it's cycled through with command-tab, and once you bring it to the front, you have the menu bar as a uniform interface for interacting with windowless apps. I don't even use mac OS but on this aspect it does seem more consistent.
- runjake 5y agoMenu Item apps (analogous to Windows task bar apps) usually aren’t in the Dock when they are running. You normally don’t quit then via the menu bar (File Edit). Nor are launchagent processes. So I’m not sure how you are trying to contrast macOS here.
- themadturk 5y agoThis was the first thing I learned when I started using a Mac in 2007. I took some years off and ran Windows from 2012 to 2021 and never forgot this aspect of Mac. I don't know, maybe I'm not enough of a power user (I use my MacBook Air primarily as a laptop, rarely hook it up to an external monitor or use a separate keyboard or mouse), but I just don't encounter of these "problems," or I've gotten used to them.
- wlesieutre 5y agoI have a coworker on Windows who leaves an instance of Word open with a blank document at all times because it will lock up for a minute or two while launching the first instance. One you have the first window open, new windows with additional documents open much faster. It’s like he’s reinvented the Mac application/window paradigm, except worse because his placeholder window is always present in the alt-tab switcher.
- MonaroVXR 5y agoI was thinking about a single window system. Since managing Windows is bad in MacOS, people use spectacle or rectangle
- sam_goody 5y agoI respectfully disagree. The Apple docs suggest to app developers that when closing the last window, the app should be made to close automatically. This is almost certainly what the user wants, unless you have a reason to think otherwise. For example, as per my other comment, if I have restore tabs in my browser, I expect the tabs of the last open window to always be restored. Instead of this being a suggestion, it should be the default, and the developer should have to configure when they want the last window to NOT close the app. (Even Apple's Safari suffers from this!) Also, Win has a dock for "background" apps which are always open, accessible, but not in the toolbar of open apps. Apple has a menubar, that similarly allows docking of those apps that are open without a window. My rule of thumb - if you don't think the app belongs in the menu, you want it to close when the last window closes. And if Apple had a "minimize to menu" that might be useful.
- bitigchi 5y agoWhere is it written? And if so, why do the most Apple applications that use multi-window setup do not behave as such, like Safari, TextEdit, Xcode, and many others? It only makes sense to close the application immediately when the red button is pressed if the application is designed for a single window, or if it's not a document based app. Like the Calculator.app. Keeping the application running when all windows are closed has huge performance benefits, allows opening another window much faster, and arguably one of the best aspects of macOS.
- SllX 5y agoThis is entirely contrary to how the Macintosh has worked for decades which has also shaped user expectations, and closing the app entirely creates a performance penalty for document-oriented apps. Whenever Apple has experimented with doing it a little different, such as when they added sudden app termination to Lion, it has generally degraded the user experience by running contrary to expectations. I also second everything in bitigchi’s reply to you.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- snarkyturtle 5y agoThe Rectangle app has been a great window tiling system for me: https://github.com/rxhanson/Rectangle https://github.com/rxhanson/Rectangle
- sk5t 5y agoRectangle is nice, but it is at best a window-sizing-and-positioning helper, and is nothing like i3/sway.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- helveticabold48 5y agopressing enter to edit a name is exactly how it should be. Enter is for text entry, you type something and press enter to ENTER the text. Why should enter open a program? Reserving Cmd-O for Open is precisely a consistent thing to do, if you're not thinking from Windows' mindset
- russellbeattie 5y agoLOL! I love the arbitrary definitions and usage example you give so passionately as if that settles the argument definitively. Enter could mean, "Begin entering text", sure. But it doesn't. It means "release the block on input", usually passing the text being queued in the input buffer or a pointer to it. Escape has traditionally been the "mode change" button for literally my entire life. It's wonderful to see Mac fan boys still going though!
- helveticabold48 5y agoit's no more arbitrary than the article's arguments, or your own "Enter could mean, "Begin entering text", sure. But it doesn't. " Mac fan boys or not, that's just how a Mac works. Calling it inferior just because it's different and then name calling ppl fan boys is just the way to go. Why did we have to go to Start menu to search for "shutdown" in Windows? To a new user the start menu would be the LAST place she would look for the shutdown command. Start could mean "start the shutdown procedure" sure, but it doesn't.
- turndown 5y agoIdk, having file names be editable like this strikes me as supremely weird, especially coming from a Linux background where we all understand that leaking(well, I suppose implementing here) such functionality isn’t what the user would expect. But again OS X isn’t designed for people like me, so maybe I am just projecting preferences.
- helveticabold48 5y ago
- concinds 5y agoThis is a poor UX critique. Those problems "still exist in 2019". Not in 2022. You're running macOS Catalina. (Actually, they don't "still exist in 2019" either). Yes, files auto-arrange. cmd+J, Sort by: Name, Use as defaults. Informational redundancy? You went out of your way to activate Show All Tabs which shows the Finder tab bar even with just one tab open, and Show Path Bar which is behaving as expected. Somehow merging the window title & path bar would prevent dragging the window around easily, since the path bar gives you proxy icons you can drag around. And seeing the same folder name in the title bar and the sidebar is good UX. Windows 11 File Explorer has the exact same amount of "repetition", except for tabs which it doesn't support. Cut and paste is bad for file managers since it requires the file to "disappears" until you paste it. Copy a piece of text off a web page and you've got data loss. And "option" now shows "Copies as Pathname", which is more useful on a UNIX OS than "Move" when you can just drag and drop. "Open Finder twice" is expected behavior. When an app is open but with no open windows, opening the app again opens a window. This reduces user confusion since it works the exact same as Windows, and is very useful for 3rd party menu-bar-only utilities where you can open their main window (often the settings window) with a half-second Spotlight search. "Enter" is the most natural choice for renaming since it's an extremely common operation (cmd+R would require 2 key presses) and F2 is used for brightness. Note that modern Windows boxes also put brightness controls on F2, so you need to twist your hand awkwardly to press fn+F2 to rename anything. The Green button isn't called maximize for a reason. It's meant to show the full document and no more, and is quite useful for Amethyst-without-Amethyst. Hide the "Format and style" sidebar in Pages, and you end up with a huge border around your document. Double tap empty space in the toolbar and the window shrinks to fit the document. Open a Finder folder with 2 lines of files and double tap, the window shrinks to being tall enough to only show those lines, no more. That's useful and works as expected. Apple's documentation doesn't say Touch ID doesn't put the Mac to sleep. It says it doesn't do so if you press it 1.5 seconds. It does it immediately.
- ihateolives 5y ago> Cut and paste is bad for file managers since it requires the file to "disappears" until you paste it. Copy a piece of text off a web page and you've got data loss. What? Is this what happens in MacOS? Because it's definitely not happening in Windows, the cut file does not disappear, it stays until pasted. I can't even fathom that this scenario would be real in any modern OS. File object and text should be handled as separate class of entities and this situation should not occur even theoretically. > "Enter" is the most natural choice for renaming since it's an extremely common operation (cmd+R would require 2 key presses) and F2 is used for brightness. ??? How often do you rename files vs how often you open them? What is your line of work where file renaming is "extremely common"? > Note that modern Windows boxes also put brightness controls on F2, so you need to twist your hand awkwardly to press fn+F2 to rename anything. No, just no. Powerusers (that I know) simply reverse that behaviour to have F-keys behave as original F-keys, the rest just select Rename from context menu.
- gumby 5y agoThe system has bugs, no question, but few appear in this list. Unlike the author, for instance, I would be annoyed if icons I had arranged a certain way were reordered when I moved them elsewhere. Oh, and he even says it’s possible to get the behavior he wants. The default is less invasive, which makes sense. Probably this is just a joke, like the famous Steve Martin quip: “those French guys…they have their own word for everything!”. Or perhaps the author considers that “hot garbage” too.
- mikl 5y agoA few points: 1. You’re not supposed to quit Finder.app. Unless you customise macOS somehow, the ability to do so is carefully hidden. There’s no menu item to quit it, Cmd-Q does nothing, and even the Force Quit menu has “Relaunch” for Finder rather than Force Quit. Any weirdness you might encounter from quitting Finder is entirely your own fault. 2. There’s a long history behind some of these things. macOS UI conventions stretch all the way back to macOS 1.0, released in 1984. Apple has preserved much of the behaviour of older versions of macOS, like keyboard short cuts and (some) of the spatial behaviour of the Finder. It might not be to your taste, but other long-time Mac users enjoy them. If you don’t like the spatial-ness, the Finder’s column view might be more to your liking. 3. Speaking of taste, many of these gripes are just complaining that macOS doesn’t work like other operating systems. If you want your OS to work like Windows, maybe just use Windows? You think the Enter key should open things in Finder? Long time Mac users would be incensed if Apple changed this, because we’re used to using Enter to rename things, and Cmd-O if we want to open them. Window zoom not making sense to you doesn’t mean it doesn’t make sense to other people. There certainly are some valid points in there, but I certainly hope Apple doesn’t “fix” your other complaints, because that would break conventions we’ve spent decades getting used to.
- gatonegro 5y ago> Window zoom not making sense to you doesn’t mean it doesn’t make sense to other people. Could you explain it to me? macOS is not my favourite OS at all, but I can use it without much trouble if I need to and agree that many of these complaints boil down to the author not liking or understanding the macOS workflow. Window zoom, however, always struck me as wildly inconsistent and unpredictable. For context, I started back in the days of Mac OS X Tiger, up to Catalina. Window zoom never made the slightest amount of sense to me.
- mikl 5y agoWindow zoom asks the application to “right-size” their window. The application then gets to decide what the “right” size is. For example, a Finder window will size itself so it can display all the contents of the folder it displays (if possible). It’s up to the application developer to implement this correctly, so if it is inconsistent, that’s technically not Apple’s fault. For applications that does not support this, the fallback is just to fill the screen, a bit like maximise does on Windows. In more recent macOS releases, the new(er) full screen mode works more like maximise does on Windows, and has now taken over the green button on the menu bar for most apps, so the old zoom feature is more obscure than ever.
- mattl 5y agoMy favorite remnants of old Mac OS X are both Finder features enabled by the `defaults` command. One is slow motion mode. I love to minimize things to the Dock (which is best placed on the right of the screen). The other is single-window mode. You turn this on and switching apps is just a matter of clicking their dock icons. It’s not 100% perfect but it’s also idea for someone with limited trackpad skill.
- Casteil 5y agoLong time PC/Windows user here - got a 14" M1 pro back in October. Really enjoy MacOS overall, with some minor gripes here and there (like text selection & manipulation - selecting words at a time then copying/pasting is more cumbersome than it is on Windows). Trackpad gestures & Mission Control make for a great single-display experience. One thing that really bothers me with MacOS though is having to click into a given window to interact with it (e.g. clicking a link in Safari / Edge while you're in VS Code or another window). Not sure there's any way around this.
- ksec 5y agoI think what we need, is a list of things that macOS does differently to Windows, and explain why it is designed the way it is. So people ( like the Author ) could actually understand why it is done that way. It is not wrong, but different. And many people need to understand why it is different so they get less irritated by its design.
- qeternity 5y agoI’ll take macOS bugs over Windows bugs any day of the week.
- sam_goody 5y agoOne more. No way to right click and "Create new Text Document" or Create shortcut or anything like that. Also, the "closing window doesn't close the app, even when it is the only open window" has a huge side effect. Closing a window with tabs, such as a browser, will delete all tabs, even if they would be restored after close. More than once, when allowing Win users to use my app they will close a window that I wanted open, thinking they are closing the app. There is a certain logic to it though, solved in Windows by allowing for apps to minimize to the right side of the toolbar.
- RamblingCTO 5y agoThat's a weird article. I was actually looking forward to some nice intricate OS details. That's just a bad instance of "I'm using the wrong OS and I don't like". Nobody cares bro, just use whatever you want.
- tkgally 5y agoMy macOS peeve: truncated file names. You can see the problems in the screenshots in the linked article: Files with visible names like "Screen Shot 2021-07...AM.png" and "Screen Shot 2021-0...AM.png" and "Screen Shot 2021-07...AM.png" (again) and "Screen Shot 2021-07...AM.png". The information distinguishing these files from one another has been replaced by the ellipsis. The same problem exists in iOS. In the Music app, for example, I have playlists in which the list of track titles is something like: Bach Cantata No. ... Bach Cantata No. ... Bach Cantata No. ... Bach Cantata No. ... Bach Cantata No. ... and there’s no way to display the rest of each title. I don’t know how other OSs handle this, but it should be possible to distinguish files from each other at a glance regardless of how long the names are.
- fattybob 5y agooh my! Apple just don't seem to appreciate classical music in any way!!!!
- goosedragons 5y agoMy least favorite Finder behavior is by default having no scroll bars and allowing files to exist off to the side where they are not displayed and you have zero indication they exist. Like why is this even remotely the default? Why would I even want files to not wrap to the size of the Finder window? Oh and when Finder won't open a new Finder window because one of those useless "Finder" drag app to Applications folder windows is open despite the fact you can't really find anything with those...
- marssaxman 5y ago> By default, file icons will preserve their arrangement, which is never what I want. Tastes clearly differ, because that has always been what I wanted! There is a whole school of thought bemoaning the loss of the "spatial Finder" style prior to OS X, which took this principle even further.
- pabbasian 5y agoHahaha, macOS has some issues but not those you talk about. I've heard every windows user complain about such problems - which are not if you accept the fact you are on another Os ant not windows - when starting to use mac. nice clickbait btw. ps. you forgot zip/unzip
- qalmakka 5y agomacOS isn't perfect, but so what? All GUIs suck, that's a fact of life. Windows is messy and inconsistent, macOS has his own share of issues too, KDE is awesome but has way too many features, GNOME is beautiful but terribly limited, and so on. The trick is to just pick the one you can tolerate the best.