3 ms·

Piracy is illegal not because it is unethical, but because at some point in history some creators got rich enough to attempt to protect their profits through le

Piracy is illegal not because it is unethical, but because at some point in history some creators got rich enough to attempt to protect their profits through legislation. The action itself, the copying of information, is morally neutral. It's only illegal because, in theory, it precludes someone from making money from that copying. But that's nonsense, because by that standard it should also be illegal to not pirate and not purchase the copy.

wutbrodo 5y ago
> Piracy is illegal not because it is unethica I'm not making this claim. I'm saying that in the context of this thread, saying "I wouldn't be pirating in that case, I'd be using YT with adblock" isn't very meaningful because using YT with adblock is equivalent to piracy from multiple relevant perspectives, including ethically[1] and economically. The legal perspective is not an especially relevant one to this thread, since the baseline was already being comfortable enough with the level of legal threat to pirate regularly. [1] including the belief that both are ethically acceptable. Just clarifying again, because people seem to be reading a lot of implicit claims/value judgments into my comments that are not in there
- deadbeeves 5y ago
  You're right, but I guess we both made the same mistake in different directions. slothtrop said >Likely [I wouldn't pirate]. Probably I'd use YT with adblock or stream on bandcamp. You assumed they wouldn't pirate because it's unethical, and I assumed they wouldn't do it because it's illegal. The actual reason could be entirely different.
- Apocryphon 5y ago
  Piracy, whether torrenting or finding some other site to download files and then manage them, are a lot more hassle than simply streaming from YouTube. There’s also plenty of YouTube videos that are basically entire albums in one. One can listen to that copyright infringing content too without even bothering to enable AdBlock. Really for all of your considerations on the legal implications, UX is king and the really the only major factor after the economic, for the end-user.

wutbrodo 5y ago

> Piracy is illegal not because it is unethica I'm not making this claim. I'm saying that in the context of this thread, saying "I wouldn't be pirating in that case, I'd be using YT with adblock" isn't very meaningful because using YT with adblock is equivalent to piracy from multiple relevant perspectives, including ethically[1] and economically. The legal perspective is not an especially relevant one to this thread, since the baseline was already being comfortable enough with the level of legal threat to pirate regularly. [1] including the belief that both are ethically acceptable. Just clarifying again, because people seem to be reading a lot of implicit claims/value judgments into my comments that are not in there

deadbeeves 5y ago
You're right, but I guess we both made the same mistake in different directions. slothtrop said >Likely [I wouldn't pirate]. Probably I'd use YT with adblock or stream on bandcamp. You assumed they wouldn't pirate because it's unethical, and I assumed they wouldn't do it because it's illegal. The actual reason could be entirely different.
Apocryphon 5y ago
Piracy, whether torrenting or finding some other site to download files and then manage them, are a lot more hassle than simply streaming from YouTube. There’s also plenty of YouTube videos that are basically entire albums in one. One can listen to that copyright infringing content too without even bothering to enable AdBlock. Really for all of your considerations on the legal implications, UX is king and the really the only major factor after the economic, for the end-user.