4 ms·
Unless CO2 removal is profitable without subsidies, it's pointless and the money should go into Renewables. If you can cut emissions, the CO2 takes care of itse
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
Unless CO2 removal is profitable without subsidies, it's pointless and the money should go into Renewables. If you can cut emissions, the CO2 takes care of itself quickly from natural sinks.
Per the ipcc model, if we could wave a magic wand and have zero emissions tomorrow, CO2 levels would fall faster than they have been increasing.
We already have free CO2 removal. The challenge is and always has been on the emission side.
CO2 levels are about 420 ppm and go up about 1.5 per year. A 120 year half life yields -3.5 ppm per year.
It is worth investing some money in development for the moonshot possibility of economic viability. Unless it becomes cheaper to capture than build renewables, the the money will always be better spent on green energy.
- gonzo41 5y agoThe profit / reward is your kids get to live and have kids.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoYou are missing the point. I am spelling out how to save your kids lives. As long as there are finite dollars to save the planet, we need to use them wisely.
- vkou 5y agoHow can CO2 removal ever be profitable without 'subsidies', like carbon taxes and credits? Anything useful you could make out of CO2 can be made much easier from fossil fuels.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThat's the point. If x dollars can be spent on carbon free Power generation, or carbon capture, you will get more impact from the former. Spend money where it has the most impact on what you care about.
- photochemsyn 5y ago"Per the ipcc model, if we could wave a magic wand and have zero emissions tomorrow, CO2 levels would fall faster than they have been increasing." Traditionally, the idea is that the ocean would absorb the 'excess' CO2 put there by fossil fuel combustion over the industrial era. However, this is quite a slow process and it's entirely possible to reach a new steady state of relatively high atmospheric CO2 (and high global temperature, i.e. ice-free poles) and stay there for several million years - it's happened in the past. Furthermore, we have the permafrost melt ongoing across the Arctic, and shallow marine sediments are also releasing methane and CO2. This will continue for decades in the immediate zero-emission scenario, that turning point has come and gone. Maybe if a full transition off fossil fuels had begun in 1980, when the science was clear, we'd be stabilizing at current conditions (*it takes ~100 years for the climate system to finish responding to current forcing, assuming no additional forcing, mainly due to oceanic warming lag effects). We're in for warming for the next 50 years, no matter what, and the world is clearly not getting off fossil fuels any time soon, all the major fossil fuel actors have plans for status quo production for the next 30 years (rather than say 3% reduction per year, which would mean no fossil fuel production in 30 years). It's going to happen slowly on human time scales, i.e. the scale is decadal for noticeable differences in the year-to-year average, but it's also inexorable. "It's in the post" is the British saying that applies. Like trying to throw the rudder over on the Titanic after the iceberg is detected, it's all too little too late.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThis negates none of what I said. If you can prevent X tons of co2 for $y dollars , it is better than capturing X tons. for $>y dollars. It only makes sense to capture co2 if you have already prevented everything you can. Yes it would have been better to start in the 80s, but that doesn't change the math today or tomorrow. If the carbon cycle changes, it will still be better to stop emissions than capture.
- _3u10 5y agoThere are many great and economically profitable ways to capture CO2, the only problem with them is they impoverish the wrong people. (More correctly they don’t make the right people even more rich) > It only makes sense to capture co2 if you have already prevented everything you can. Like I said in another thread, it’s this kind of stuff that makes net zero never happen as many people, like yourself, are inherently opposed to CO2 emissions.
- lmm 5y agoObviously if reducing emissions is cheaper than removal we should do that. But building more renewable production doesn't necessarily cut emissions - it might just increase energy consumption.