3 ms·
It’s funny, but this is how I felt about my son’s kindergarten. They taught him about “numbers” but instead they only used Natural numbers. The least they could
by renewiltord 5y ago
It’s funny, but this is how I felt about my son’s kindergarten. They taught him about “numbers” but instead they only used Natural numbers. The least they could have done is mention at least the one-point compactification of that space.
Fortunately, I was able to intervene before he was permanently damaged by the class. He’s still struggling with showing that it is homeomorphic to the subspace of R formed by {1/n for all n in R that are in N} union {0} and I blame today’s pedagogy for that.
- GTP 5y agoThe context is different, the problem here is the hype that goes in a very specific direction (i.e. you can do anything with ML) as I briefly explained in another comment
- nautilius 5y agoI feel "Numbers" are pretty hyped-up!
- GTP 5y agoGoing back to your original comment, if I say "let's talk about linear functions" and then all I say also applies to a more general context, eg. polynomials, then it is fine. But if I say "let's talk about polynomials" and then all I say only applies to linear functions then it is wrong. Your sarcastic comment falls under the first case, the article discussed here falls under the second.
- nautilius 5y agoI wish you had read my original comment, where, let me repeat it a second time for you, I state that the author writes about how to approximate a 'function in the laymen sense of the word'. And that's what he does. Nowhere does he bring hype into it; no one reading about how to approximate a simple y=f(x) will misread this. My guess is that you read the website like you read my comment, if at all, otherwise we wouldn't be having this ridiculous conversation. renewiltord's comment is spot on and much better phrased than I could have done it.
- GTP 5y agoI got that you say that the author is talking about a 'function in the laymen sense of the world', what I'm saying is that this might not be clear from reading that webpage without some prior knowledge of the cases when this will fail.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]