3 ms·
I agree that there is room for productive discussion around what should be patentable, but you are greatly over simplifying the process. Take a biologic develo
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
I agree that there is room for productive discussion around what should be patentable, but you are greatly over simplifying the process.
Take a biologic developed for cancer treatment for example.
A tremendous amount of work goes into determining what gene does useful work, and Much more work goes into showing that it is safe and effective for treating disease.
I generally agree that simply reproducing a gene found in nature should not be patentable. However, most genetic patents are more specific and take a different form. Instead of "put X gene into Y", they are use "X gene, to make Y protein, to treat Z".
Figuring out what protein can treat Z, is an invention, takes hard work, and should be rewarded.
Legally speaking, just putting X gene into Y, isn't patentable because it fails the non-obviousness test. Doing something new with known methods to yield predictable results is not valid.