3 ms·
> The jurors ignorant of the science behind the evidence that influenced their decisions? Isnt the whole point of jurors being ordinary person from the street
by watwut 5y ago
> The jurors ignorant of the science behind the evidence that influenced their decisions?
Isnt the whole point of jurors being ordinary person from the streets with no special knowledge making decisions purely going by what was said in courtroom? If you tell them "this guy is great expert" and then that guy dont get meaningfully challenged, you dont get to blame jury who went by what they have been said.
> The judges and lawyers equally so? The labs and employees perpetuating bad science, or the schools that taught them? The police that collect and document it?
Yeah, these. The judges, lawyers, prosecutors and the police who are the actually the ones who decide which lab is going to be used often and which not. Which person is going to be treated in courtroom as expert in front of jury, regardless of actual knowledge and which is not even going to be asked to be there.
It is not that deep.
- tomnipotent 5y ago> The judges, lawyers, prosecutors and the police I agree wholeheartedly, but the world seems to have a problem holding government employees responsible for their actions. Ended up on Wikipedia reading about the history of jury trials, and found this lovely snippet: One issue that has been raised is the ability of a jury to fully understand evidence. It has been said that the expectation of jury members as to the explanatory power of scientific evidence has been raised by TV police procedural and legal dramas, in what is known as the 'CSI effect'. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_trial https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_trial
- watwut 5y agoAfaik, jury is answering series of specific questions in a process controlled by layers. So you have tidbits like jury not being able to take own notes, because rules says so. That is real world example. The quote you have there is complaint about jury expecting too convincing evidence. And the real world issue is them falling for real evidence. The issue here is with "experts" saying non scientific crap in courtrooms and juries being told this is science. Experts who have little to no scientific training, little to no checking done over methods they use and so on.
- pmichaud 5y agoI think this is an interesting issue. We have this idea of “common people” being jurors, who are supposed to apply common sense to the facts of a case, as a sort of balance against corruption and weenie-headed legal technocrats, but the whole system is implicitly predicated on those jurors mostly being inside some culture window where they know what’s happening at all. Like hypothetically if you plucked a guy from an isolated tribe in the amazon (who spoke perfect english), then put him on a jury, he would just be lost. “Well, so, we gave them net90 terms in the original contract, but then in the email dated…” — the content is just beyond his ability to reason about from where he’s sitting. Maybe our culture has a sufficiently large internal spread either between itself or between the legal system, that the average juror is more like the tribal guy on the jury than not? It’s mostly not a problem because tricky contract disputes aren’t normally jury trials, it’s mostly people doing comprehensible things for human reasons, which is a good match for jurors. But then you introduce stuff like I Fucking Love Science propaganda plus Hair DNA Matching: SCIENCE! And how are people supposed to use their common sense to apply judgement? The original context of jurors was like “I don’t know about no fancy laws, but wrong is wrong,” like folksy, probably-religion-based moral intuitions that prevent legal nerds from running amok. But where are we now, if the nerds can just say the word SCIENCE and the jury has no choice but to sign off? I have no idea what the right answer is, but probably the current setup isn’t it.
- tomrod 5y agoJury selection weeds against jury nullification, implicitly choosing for those who feel illegal determines immoral.
- alistairSH 5y agoThe judge is supposed to determine which evidence is allowed. The jurors only need to understand the evidence to the extent it proves guilt. Given new science, the prosecution and defense make their case and the judge allows/disallows the evidence. But, the judge isn’t a scientist, she’s a lawyer (if we’re lucky - some parts of the US have elected judges with little to no professional requirements). And the prosecution might have more money and better experts.
- watwut 5y ago