4 ms·
Desktop apps today are just such a huge regression compared to the past. I was recently looking at software for PDF reading and note taking. I tried all these E
by rayiner 5y ago
Desktop apps today are just such a huge regression compared to the past. I was recently looking at software for PDF reading and note taking. I tried all these Electron apps that ran like crap and made the fans spin up on my 2020 MacBook Pro with 32GB. Meanwhile they have far fewer features than a 1990s shareware app. I used Scrivener for a bit but it’s pretty crap about sync so I switched to Emacs with org and pdf-tools. It’s a total hack of elisp and C but it’s vastly more functional than any of the $10/month SaaS note taking platforms out there. Do you remember the essay “worse is better?” Web apps are a manifestation of that.
- ironmagma 5y agoAnyone who’s tried to learn native app development, especially on Mac or iOS, will know that it’s a massive pain in the backside. Documentation is sparse, located in exactly one place, not readable on mobile (!!! the ultimate in irony), formerly available but now deleted, or only available in live video presentation format. I blame the OS vendors as much as anyone.
- kitsunesoba 5y agoNative iOS dev is pretty easy to get started on these days, there's loads of material for both UIKit and SwiftUI. From my view it's easier than getting started on native Android dev by a good measure. Native Mac dev on the other hand is another matter. The situation has improved some since then, but it's not too different from when I picked up Objective-C + Cocoa/AppKit back in the early-mid 00s, where nearly all instructional material came in the form of print or random tidbits scattered across various developer blogs.
- spike021 5y agoI'll mostly +1 this as someone who got into iOS dev and went straight to SwiftUI for the past 2 months. There are some individual doc pages that seem to be auto-generated and a bit sparse when it comes to useful context. For instance, sometimes X object cannot be instantiated on its own according to its relevant doc and you need to use Y internal API that provides it instead. However, there's no explanation as to why or what can be done instead, which doesn't help someone who's very new to the architecture and frameworks.
- jfb 5y agoI had to go bug people I knew who had worked on QuickTime frameworks BITD to get anything done when I worked at Apple the first time, in 2004. It's not and never has been simply an external problem.
- ironmagma 5y agoAll three of those are orders of magnitude harder to learn than web technologies, which have been backwards compatible for something like the past 2 or 3 decades and see little churn in the APIs. Not saying it’s better, but it is a lot easier to learn, so the vendors need to work a lot harder if they want to compete, which they don’t do, which is why Electron is so popular.
- dylan604 5y ago>(!!! the ultimate in irony) It's not like people are developing using their mobile device. I'm sure the online docs are assumed to be read by people on a non-mobile device. I can't imagine trying to read docs on mobile while banging out code on a laptop. Seems pointless, especially if the docs have links for downloading something or what not.
- ironmagma 5y agoIt’s only pointless if you don’t believe the iPhone is a revolutionary communication tool that changes how we interact with the Internet, which seems like a strange position to be held by someone on the iOS team. It’s really some of the only documentation I’ve come across that can’t be read on mobile, and it’s all because of a sidebar which isn’t even a good reason.
- dylan604 5y agoI don't care how revolutionary one may or may not think it, but it is an extremely horrible tool for a developer actively working on a project and referencing the docs.
- marcodiego 5y agoInteresting, the linux desktop landscape has moved on the opposite direction. Still has a long way to go but has been improving consistently. I often see windows users using aberrations to read PDF's with ads and trying to persuade the user to join an online service like foxit or adobe. On linux, evince has gained very discrete features over the years but works very very well, actually better than before; it probably eats a bit more memory because of the newest libs. Okular is on the same direction but is more feature rich, not surprising considering the KDE heritage. The pdf reader scenario is just one of many cases the desktop on other OS's became a vector to spread ads while the linux has only improved over time. Considering the popularity of android, it has the same problems as windows in terms of apps being just a way to spreads ads; fortunately f-droid saves me from these. So, I hope things will continue to improve on the FLOSS desktop. Hope it brings more users too. With regard to the electron apps... With 4 cores and 8GB of RAM, I really don't care that much about the performance loss. It feels a bit inconsistent sometimes, but I like to know that I'm using the same app as my colleagues on other OS's.
- rayiner 5y agoYeah, the latest Fedora is getting pretty nice between Gnome and Wayland. What’s shocking to me is how bad first party software is getting. Acrobat DC kills the battery on my MBP doing, among other things, constantly running some cloud updater thing. It’s worse at browsing PDFs than a decade ago. Same thing for Outlook. They’ve started integrating a bunch of web technologies into it. It actually has less features now than before (tasks and notes redirect you to the website). And I don’t just mean that the latest version is slower on older hardware. It’s vastly slower on current hardware than the old versions were on the hardware that was contemporary at the time. My work machine is a ThinkPad i7 that boosts to 4.2 GHz. Just hitting Win-Right to snap Outlook to one half of the screen causes it to visibly spasm.
- convolvatron 5y agodoes linux have a reasonable replacement for xfig yet?
- marcodiego 5y ago
- fiddlerwoaroof 5y agoFor PDF reading, at least, I always found Skim the best.
- alophawen 5y agofor pdf reader, Skim is a nice light weight app for macOS. https://skim-app.sourceforge.io/ https://skim-app.sourceforge.io/ (For Windows there is SumatraPDF: https://www.sumatrapdfreader.org/free-pdf-reader https://www.sumatrapdfreader.org/free-pdf-reader)