4 ms·
The first comment in this thread is proposing that there is a corrupting force working with builders to install smart ovens. Centralising power in a regulator i
by roenxi 5y ago
The first comment in this thread is proposing that there is a corrupting force working with builders to install smart ovens. Centralising power in a regulator isn't targeted at the actual problem, and creates a single point of failure that might well end up with smart-ovens becoming mandatory in new builds, where possible.
- hutzlibu 5y ago"end up with smart-ovens becoming mandatory in new builds, where possible." Oh for sure. To fight climate change(and dependence on russian oil and gas), we all have to get a smart oven, to make sure we are all using our energy in the most efficient way. And not too often. Let's say a budget of 1 moderate use per day per adult user. And if the grid gets too unstable, your oven might smartly switches off and on during baking, to help stabilize the grid.
- soheil 5y ago> your oven might smartly switches off and on during baking, to help stabilize the grid I think you're being needlessly pessimistic. Consider a few points: 1. By the time any "smart" oven is mandated by law technology has probably moved ahead so far of where we are today that all the asinine intricacies people are complaining about have been remedied. Just look at how far wifi has come, only 15 years ago you couldn't imagine an office that could connect to the internet reliably without anything but RJ45 cables. 2. Read the comments on the internet from the 90s or early 2000s about almost anything and see how pessimistic everyone was about the future of new technologies. This is probably even more true of nerds who live on the cutting edge and see things at a closer range but also at a slightly skewed angle. 3. So what? Seatbelt laws induced the same type of reaction initially, but over time people adjusted, and no one even notices the annoying chime every car makes if you start it without putting on your seatbelt first and not to mention giving away your freedom not to wear them because we decided for you it would be in society's best interest to lower the cost of auto insurance. And now not just because it would be illegal not to but also because the societal norms dictate that you wear your seatbelt every single time.
- trident5000 5y agoAn oven is not a PC, just turn on and cook my food. And any energy savings with some wifi controlled monstrosity (if thats what were getting at) is better met with more sustainable energy sources that produce more power. Cutting energy is never going to be a solution of the future; producing more will be.
- llukas 5y agoControl doesn't have to be malicious. For example electric oven: 1) Oven or any other appliance can just list current price of electricity. 2) High power appliances can tell network to book energy (how much/how long) so usage is more predictable. It is more likely we end up with camera taking photos of our food and sending it to mothership - but one can still wish it will go other way.
- franga2000 5y agoNeither of these should be mandatory (for #2 at least not yet)
- hutzlibu 5y ago"Read the comments on the internet from the 90s or early 2000s about almost anything and see how pessimistic everyone was about the future of new technologies." We live in a time, where allways on devices track and spy everything by default about everyone and secret algorithms decide what posts get viral and what gets blocked or banned automatically, with no chance for the ordinary person to contest these decisions. And all of this gets used, to manipulate peoples attention to sell them shiny crap, or influence them politically, without them noticing. But yeah, people adopted to that total surveillance and algorithm control and starting the day with tailored advertisement. Why resist the change of the glorious new age? But apart from that, I absolutely would buy a wifi controlled smart oven, where I can check on food and maybe adjust temperature without going to the kitchen - but only if I control it and not some server in china or wherever.
- quanticle 5y ago
- franga2000 5y ago1. That regulator already has the power, so this in no way increases their ability to do something like that. 2. Yes, manufacturers making deals with builders is one reason people end up with Internet Of Shit devices, but not the only one. Sometimes people buy them because they weren't properly informed, or locks are added in a software update, or it's simply the best all-round product so the person makes a compromise, or the local shops don't even sell anything without these anti-features. Either way, the existence of such an anti-feature is unacceptable. Why should we have to fix every single situation where people end up with these, when it's far more effective to just outlaw them? (And please don't mention any freedom of the manufacturer, corporations don't have rights. They should serve the people and people alone.)
- BizarroLand 5y agoI wonder how long it will be before we hear reports of people having their ovens turned off to "conserve power" by their power company during the day. 20 years? 15? Place your bets!