3 ms·
A tower might have advantages against long range ballistic attacks. Consider a wizard who owns a building that is being attacked by an enemy lobbing projectile
by tzs 5y ago
A tower might have advantages against long range ballistic attacks.
Consider a wizard who owns a building that is being attacked by an enemy lobbing projectiles, and assume that the building is either box shaped or is a cylindrical tower.
If it is a long range attack all the projectiles arriving in the target area of the building will be traveling almost in parallel. Due to uncertainty and imprecision in aiming they will be randomly distributed over an area.
Suppose the sun at the time of the attack happens to be positioned such that sunlight near the building is moving in the same direction as the projectiles.
A projectile that would have hit a given point on the ground if the building had not been present hits the building if and only if either that point is directly under the building or that point is in the building's shadow. Let's call the area directly under the building plus the area in shadow the building's target area. The chances of being hit by a given random projectile are proportional to the target area.
Now lets compare towers with boxes. Suppose the projectiles are coming in at a 45 degree angle.
Consider a wizard with a cylindrical tower with a radius of 10 m that has 10 floors with 3 m between floors. The gives floor space of around 3100 m^2.
A one story box with the same floor space would have a target area of 3250 m^2, assuming a square floor plan and the attack is coming in from a direction perpendicular to one of the sides.
The tower, if I've done the math right, has a target area of around 900 m^2.
If we double the height of the tower, making it 20 floors and ~6300 m^2, its target area is ~1500 m^2. A 6300 m^2 box with a square floor plan has a target area of ~6500 m^2.
Note that doubling the area of the box doubled the target area, but doubling the area of the tower only made the target around about 67% bigger.
For the one story box, target area is always larger then floor area, and the ratio approaches 1 as floor area goes up.
For the 10 m radius tower with floors 3 m apart, the ratio of target area to floor area goes to ~0.19 as the number of floors goes up.
Although tower wizard's chances of getting hit by a random projectile are lower the box wizard's chances, it should be noted that a hit on the tower is potentially more damaging than a hit on the box. Box wizard doesn't have to worry about a lucky shot collapsing his building. When deciding which kind of building to build, you need to take into account your enemies and decide whether whether a higher chance of a hit being a critical hit is worth a lower chance of not getting hit.