4 ms·
The stock market is usually correct about companies, you need to have a really good explanation for why it is wrong. Lots of people thought that Facebook or Goo
by Jensson 5y ago
The stock market is usually correct about companies, you need to have a really good explanation for why it is wrong. Lots of people thought that Facebook or Google etc were overvalued. They weren't, even if you account for the low probability of them taking the market the combined valuation of every similar company together shows they weren't overvalued.
- andrewmcwatters 5y agoYes, and those explanations are based on valuation strategies: discounted cash flow being the most generous, though also perhaps more "accurate" than other methods despite being very sensitive to changes in discount rates with historically low interest rates. If you did discounted cash flow analysis on Facebook or Google, you'd find that despite their high price to earnings ratios, their earnings produced fair valuations, not overvalued ones.
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoNo, they aren't. The explanations are based on different estimates of cashflows. As a concrete example - people didn't miss GOOG when it went public because of "valuation methods". People missed it because they didn't imagine that in 2022 a search engine company would be doing $75 bill a qtr of high margin revenue. People didn't miss AAPL in the late 90s because of "valuation methods", they missed it because they didn't see AAPL doing $90 bill a qtr of pretty high margin revenue. Understanding the future cashflows of a business is really difficult stuff. Playing with numbers in a spreadsheet is really easy stuff.
- andrewmcwatters 5y agoI enjoy the definition of investing as an act of thorough analysis promising safety of principal and an adequate return, and all other behaviors otherwise bring speculative. If you’re paying $42.14 per dollar of earnings there is a likelihood that more often than not you’re overpaying. If you can’t pass simple mechanical litmus tests you’d better be damn sure, and frankly there just aren’t many exceptional companies where I feel damn sure about them.
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoThorough analysis isn't what you are doing, it's simplistic analysis. That's the very problem with it. It sounds like you are dying for the Ben Graham era - when simplistic analysis based on financial statements was all that is required because the competition in investing was... not much. It's a very different game now, and you actually have to have deep insight into the companies and the industries they are in. You can't just do a simplistic extrapolation of the last couple years in a spreadsheet. Google couldn't pass your "simple mechanical litmus tests" when it went public. Apple couldn't pass it in the late 90s. Amazon couldn't pass it most of it's life. IBM could for a good number of years (just look at the numbers when Buffett was buying it...) Most of the banks could in 2005/6/7.
- systemBuilder 5y agoExactly true the rise in the cost of next-generation fabs has completely changed the business model so that only foundries can survive. Benjamin Graham analysis is not capable of detecting this inflection point in industry strategy nor can it detect Intel's stubborn refusal to adapt and change!
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoYup. And by all reports Ben Graham was a brilliant dude. If he were in the game today, I doubt he'd be playing the way he played back in the day. He'd get in there and figure it out.
- andrewmcwatters 5y agoThe mathematics of investing haven't changed, but if you have some literature to suggest otherwise, I'd be very interested in reading it. You seem to think that I use these mechanical estimates as the primary method for purchase, but they are not. I'm not sure what your point is about IPOs: they're historically a terrible time to invest, which is common knowledge. And actually all of the companies you have mentioned have easily passed such litmus tests over their life time at different times. Sometimes they're overbought, some times they're oversold. If you buy when they're overbought, you'll end up with a lower IRR than if you hadn't.
- cudgy 5y ago> stock market is usually correct about companies Correct about what? What people are willing to pay for the company at that point in time? Sure. What the value of discounted cash flows generated by a company over a span of years? Definitely not.
- wowokay 5y agoLike it was with GME?
- mgh2 5y agoExactly, media controls the narrative and people en masse are gullible to manipulations. The stock market in the short term is at best a perception, perhaps only on the long term reflects a normalized, economic reality
- ethbr0 5y agoGME is the way it was because it is, effectively, not an open market of buyers and sellers, due to deliberate (if decentralized) manipulation. This is in contrast to the vast majority of other securities.
- gruez 5y ago"In the short run, the market is a voting machine, but in the long run, it is a weighing machine"
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoI don't understand why you are getting downvoted. This statement that the market is usually correct is basically right. Maybe a better explanation is: something like 90% of the time 90% of companies are priced within 10% of the "true" valuation.
- x3sphere 5y agoInteresting that you mention FB, considering it's just had a 40%+ drop over a matter of weeks. Compared to other FAANG, the drop is massive. FB is now only up around 30% compared to early 2017. If you'd bought GOOG or AMZN during the same time, you'd be up over 200%. What warrants such a huge drop if the market was correct about FB? Seems to me like it was indeed overvalued, but the market just came to that realization a few months ago. Even though we're experiencing a broad selloff in the market FB has been hit way harder than comparable companies.
- clove 5y agoIt was the earnings report that effected the drop. Users dropped for the first time in the company's history, potentially signaling peak growth, meaning it's downhill from here. I think the market acted accordingly and the drop was justified.
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoPets.com