3 ms·
I am a casual wikipedia page contributor, and have been since the earliest days. I tend to agree there is a problem with 'page guarding' and collusion between
by mistrial9 5y ago
I am a casual wikipedia page contributor, and have been since the earliest days. I tend to agree there is a problem with 'page guarding' and collusion between long-time editors. Its annoying to see the political litmus tests take a large part of these threads. With all that said..
I believe there is a strong and non-obvious aspect to Wikipedia evolution, that is exemplified by an anecdote: When I started doing "family history in New England" research in the 1990s, the Daughters of the American Revolution publications, in hardback volumes, was considered good sourcing, with some caveats .. In the space of five years, in the 1990s, the "facts" printed in impressive DAR fashion, were shredded, in not a few cases. There simply had never been the ability to check and cross-check, so quickly, over such vast numbers of resources. Truth in family history is evasive sometimes, but tends towards very verifiable. The Internet itself, and the eyes and minds of millions of participants, just created an information environment that had never existed; library of Alexandria on steroids, if you want to be colorful.
So now, decades into the process of Wikipedia, we find out that there are not one kind of fact, there is not one kind of editor, and the attention economy is more real than ever. Mix in human nature, and there is a sort of unsolvable situation.
so what to do? admit imperfection, don't waste pages on obviously irreconcilable situations like "the son of the current Presidential candidate of the USA and allegations", I mean sure, but not dominating the response here; and then do find the cases where the process can be evolved, like breaking up smug cliques of editors, when it needs to happen.. fairly, periodically perhaps.. whatever..
Wikipedia -- amazing feature of the entire Internet