3 ms·
There was a group at the end of the DotCom Boom that wanted to create an elevated rail system of sorts for autonomous vehicles. I found this an interesting conc
by hinkley 5y ago
There was a group at the end of the DotCom Boom that wanted to create an elevated rail system of sorts for autonomous vehicles. I found this an interesting concept because it essentially reduces the driving algorithm to a 2 dimensional problem (linear distance and time), which is not much more complicated than cruise-control with distance-keeping. They went beyond self parking to "drop me off at the front door and go park in the garage". That would have been a game changer for retail space in dense urban cores because you could consolidate parking blocks away and increase retail footage at ±1 floor from street level.
Rail and water are so much more efficient than rubber on roads. Water especially. It still blows my mind when my friend with a boat told me how much the boat weighs, and yet I could still push it off the dock or 'catch' it if they come in too hot. I'm pushing tens of thousands of pounds. I can't even push my car without two other people to help. We can't build (many) new water systems, but we can build rails. In fact it's a shame we let them dismantle the old ones.
As we're discovering, rubber is quickly rising as a PM2.5 source as ICEs are being more and more regulated. Michelin has been experimenting with biodegradable additives to their rubber (in fact they claim better performance at 50% tread wear in large part due to this new formulation) but I'm not sure how much that helps in the long term. Nor regenerative braking vis-a-vis brake pad dust.
What's likely going to help more is that GenZ seems to have an aversion to driving. Cars and autonomy are no longer synonymous.
- mwint 5y ago> Nor regenerative braking vis-a-vis brake pad dust. Huh? To be clear, you’re claiming regen braking may not significantly reduce brake dust? I drive an EV with relatively weak regen (‘15 Leaf), and easily 95% of total energy goes to regen; the last few MPH go to the real brakes. The service manual lists _inspecting_ the brakes at 60k miles and again at 100k. I don’t expect to ever replace the pads in this, unless they rust off from lack of use. So if that pad is lasting that long, it must be making less dust.
- smilekzs 5y agoI think they meant "regardless of what method of braking you use, the tire still has to do the same amount of work, therefore produce the same amount of tire emissions".
- mwint 5y ago“Brake pad dust” is pretty specific. I wonder if tire emissions are true. One on hand, EVs tend to be heavier. On the other, efficient braking inside the regen zone should mean more gradual stops, lower average accelerations and speeds.
- hinkley 5y agoThe tire dust I’m sure is worse during acceleration and deceleration, but just rolling across pavement breaks down the tire. If it didn’t, then why do you have to replace them every five years?
- hinkley 5y agoIt will never cease to amaze me how often developers get trapped in thinking in absolutes. Someone once blamed it on Boolean logic but I laughed it off. Maybe it’s not so funny. Helps and solves are very different things. Yes, using brakes less means less pollution. But you can’t get to zero that way. Reducing pollution by 2/3s doesn’t “fix” the pollution. For anything that doesn’t break down (or not readily, such as metals), it’s a matter of whether you’re dead in four years or twelve. You’re still dead, and to anyone living in that future, it hardly matters if we ruined something in 2025 or 2045.
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>There was a group at the end of the DotCom Boom that wanted to create an elevated rail system of sorts for autonomous vehicles. I found this an interesting concept because it essentially reduces the driving algorithm to a 2 dimensional problem (linear distance and time), which is not much more complicated than cruise-control with distance-keeping. Heathrow Terminal 5 has a pod parking system somewhat like that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CqS4IovY8Cc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CqS4IovY8Cc