3 ms·
Although it supports the Ukrainians and that’s important, I don’t see how sanctions reduce the likelihood of wider war? It is, in its way, an escalation, though
by skybrian 5y ago
Although it supports the Ukrainians and that’s important, I don’t see how sanctions reduce the likelihood of wider war? It is, in its way, an escalation, though a safer one than directly entering the conflict.
It seems Putin sprung this on the rest of Russia as a surprise decision. (Of course the signs were there.) Did he bother to get the support of the oligarchs or anyone else first? It’s not at all clear he has anyone’s support; he just has their obedience.
Morally speaking, this looks rather simple: it’s Putin’s big mistake. To the extent that others failed to stop the invasion, it was by failing to influence him. But a paranoid and isolated dictator isn’t easily influenced.
Punishing other Russians for this, particularly outside Russia and Ukraine, often has no purpose and is a form of cruelty.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Although it supports the Ukrainians and that’s important, I don’t see how sanctions reduce the likelihood of wider war? By reducing the capacity for wider war. I think this summarizes it, without a focus on war capacity specifically, but the impact on war capacity flows directly from this: https://mobile.twitter.com/DmitryOpines/status/1499157917399977987 https://mobile.twitter.com/DmitryOpines/status/1499157917399...
- branko_d 5y agoLifting sanctions can becime a powerful motivator in any future negotiations.
- bigfudge 5y agoLet’s be clear. The Russians being punished outside of Russia have blood on their hands. They should never have been allowed to buy property and football clubs in the uk, because they weee gangster crooks who had stolen from their own country. That the uk govt was complicit in this at the time doesn’t make it wrong to act against them now. I have a lot more sympathy for the people hurt in Russsia now. Russians, whether they have been brainwashed into supporting Putin or not, are in for a bad time in the coming years.
- skybrian 5y agoThis might be true, but they aren't being tried for their own crimes. It's just revenge.
- jacquesm 5y agoClearly it is not revenge, that is a ridiculous thing to say. Sanctions are the kind of things that tend to send unmistakable messages: we are serious about this and we're willing to hurt our own interests to hurt yours, stop what you are doing or it will get worse. Of course that requires a modicum of rationality on the other side, which we may not have in this case, and obviously the rulers will usually be utterly unaffected. But six degrees works as well in Russia as it does elsewhere, and living under sanctions is a lot more comfortable than living under a rain of artillery fire. If you aim at the Russian industrial complex (which produces a lot of the arms), and the government with sanctions then obviously you will it the people too. But that's not as bad as a shooting war (or a nuclear war) would be. And it doesn't rule either out.
- skybrian 5y agoUK Property and football clubs don't contribute to the Russian war effort, though. Yachts are not warships. Since trade with Russia has stopped, even selling them would make little difference. If anything we should be encouraging Russians to flee the country.