3 ms·
If you have genuine issues with any part of the existing rating in WP:RSP, it's entirely appropriate to raise that on the talk page. "I think this source shoul
by zozbot234 5y ago
If you have genuine issues with any part of the existing rating in WP:RSP, it's entirely appropriate to raise that on the talk page. "I think this source should be ranked higher/lower than it currently is, and here's evidence" is a valid concern. Wikipedians are well aware that verifiability standards may reinforce biases in article coverage, and some have even proposed (though not very seriously) that doing away with verifiability altogether may be better than the alternative of being left with a systemically biased encyclopedia.
- actuator 5y agoI have tried making an effort for this in the past but it didn't work as there was no opposition but there wasn't much support as well. Also, I am not sure how we can verifiably prove that the editorial stance of one source is either day pro or against something, so it should be rated higher or lower, and if equal whose tone do we go with. As wiki editorialisation of news events is not preferred, you will have to go with existing editorialisation in media
- zozbot234 5y ago"Some support but no opposition" qualifies as consensus, at least provisionally. So you should be WP:BOLD and just edit the policy page directly. People might be upset and revert you, but you won't be in the wrong because you did after all seek consensus on talk, and they didn't object.
- davidgerard 5y agoeditors trying this on WP:RSP get reverted in short order
- zozbot234 5y agoEven after arguing for the change on the appropriate talk/noticeboard pages and getting qualified support and zero opposition? I'm not sure this has ever been tried properly, but I see no reason why it wouldn't work.