3 ms·
Well the headline is about people's claims that they don't eat meat, not about whether that claim matches your definition of what a vegetarian is. Similarly th
by giraffe_lady 5y ago
Well the headline is about people's claims that they don't eat meat, not about whether that claim matches your definition of what a vegetarian is.
Similarly there are cultural and possibly generational differences to these things. In the US people seem to use a very strict definition, but I have lived in places where a meal without meat in it is considered vegetarian, even if it contains animal products like lard. These people might not be vegetarian according to your standards, but if they consider themselves to be how should they answer the question on a survey?
Plus I mean, it is ok. It is. If someone asks me I will tell them I don't smoke because my identity is as a nonsmoker, even though I had a cigarette a few months ago. Individuals could reject my claim based on their view of what that cigarette means, but that doesn't make me wrong to make the claim or identify in this way.
- PretzelPirate 5y ago> Well the headline is about people's claims that they don't eat meat, not about whether that claim matches your definition of what a vegetarian is. I simply used my personal experience to highlight that people can’t be trusted to give accurate information around how they consume animal products. I used veganism (not vegetarianism) because it has a rather well-defined criteria, and is what I have the most experience with. > If someone asks me I will tell them I don't smoke because my identity is as a nonsmoker, even though I had a cigarette a few months ago. Certainly, this depends on the question, but a good survey question won’t leave ambiguity. It will likely specify a time frame and give you choices on how many cigarettes you’ve used, as well as asking if you identify as a smoker. If I asked you “are you a smoker?”, your answer would rightfully be “no” since the definition of “smoker” requires regular use. If I asked “have you smoked tobacco products anytime in the last six months?”, I’d expect your answer to be “yes”. With veganism, you can be directly told “I’m a vegan too” when someone hears you’re vegan. If they also choose to consume animals products during a casual meal with many vegan options, there’s no definition of the word “vegan” that they’d fit.