3 ms·
> Stop eastward expansion of NATO and make it clear Ukraine will not be allowed to join NATO. Yep, this is Putin's demand but it's a demand in bad faith as we'
by indigochill 5y ago
> Stop eastward expansion of NATO and make it clear Ukraine will not be allowed to join NATO.
Yep, this is Putin's demand but it's a demand in bad faith as we'll get into in a minute.
> Just visualize what would American response would be if Mexico or Canada considered joining a non-American Security Alliance. We already know how America will respond, when Venezuela brought up joining Russian security alliance, few years ago.
This is just whataboutism. I don't know the details of Venezuela, but it's totally possible the US was in the wrong. Whatever the case, it has no bearing on whether Russia is in the right.
> And, now we are seeing the poisoned fruits of how it is threatening world peace.
This is the meat of my objection, since arguing NATO's a threat to world peace is empirically Russian nationalist nonsense. Between Russia and NATO, one has been militarily invading its neighbors for years now and the other is a purely defensive pact. Which is not to say that NATO is not an arm of American imperialism, but supposing a NATO member state wanted to start an aggressive war against Russia or its allies, NATO would not apply. When the US invaded Iraq, for instance (another popular whataboutism topic from Russian nationalists, but one with more merit than Venezuela IMO), they had to drum up support from allies without being able to invoke NATO. Those allies could have refused to support the invasion.
> Ukraine has become an American pawn in geo-political chess.
On this, however, we can agree.
- vandreas2 5y ago> Ukraine has become an American pawn in geo-political chess. Shouldn't we at least consider what's their view on this instead of painting everything as big power rivalry? Didn't they democratically choose to apply for EU membership? Considering neighbouring Poland has joined the ranks of high income countries and Ukraine has been stagnating under Russian protection can you blame them? Also, considering the blood ties between Russia and Ukraine before this war why would Ukraine consider joining NATO if it was not afraid of Russia (and still isn't apparently)? I think this line of reasoning of Ukraine pursuing NATO membership before all this started is a bit absurd. https://freepolicybriefs.org/2018/03/12/polands-road-high-income-country-status-lessons-learnt-not-countries/ https://freepolicybriefs.org/2018/03/12/polands-road-high-in...
- indigochill 5y ago> Shouldn't we at least consider what's their view on this instead of painting everything as big power rivalry? Sure, but these aren't mutually exclusive topics. A terrible blunder on Russia's part may have been the sole catalyst, but that doesn't mean it's not a prime geopolitical opportunity for the US.