8 ms·
A wave function does not collapse upon detection?
- belter 5y agoWave function https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wave_function https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wave_function
- gus_massa 5y agoOversimplifying, but hopefully not too much. For simplicity, let's assume that it's the wave function of an electron, but this applies to any particle. The first problem is the question. What does "detection" means? The technical term is "measurement", and the most important idea is that you can measure different things, for example the position of the electron, or the speed of the electron, or the energy of the electron, or ... If you measure the exact position of an electron, the wave function collapses to a point. But you can measure other thing, for example if it's inside a box or outside the box. In this case the wave function that initially is spread perhaps in all the universe, will collapse to a smaller wave function. In some cases to one that is completely inside the box, and in other cases one that is completely outside the box. Knowing the initial wave function it's possible to know how the wave functions inside or outside the box will be, but the details are quite technical. What is not possible to know if after the measurement you will get the wave function that is inside or outside the box. As fas as we know this is a random choice. Nobody likes it, some people thing there are not random rules, but most people think it's sadly random. Note that the probability to get the wave function that is inside or outside the box are not equal. It may be la loaded "dice". The exact numbers can be calculated if you know the initial wave functions, but the details are quite technical. Very informally, if the box is small, the probability of getting the wave function that is inside is small. If you have an electron inside the box and open it for a very short time and close it, then the probability of getting the wave function that is inside is big. To get a formal definition, you must read all the nasty technical details. --- The idea is that you can somehow detect that the electron is inside or outside the box, but it does not collapse the wave function completely. You still have a complicated wave function inside or outside the box. And you can make this wave function colide with other wave functions and get some weird quantum mechanics results that are impossible if you assume that the wave function has collapsed for a very short time to a single point inside or outside the box. Or you can generalize this with two boxes and the rest of the universe. It's possible to measure if the electron is in box A, box B or outside. It's also possible to measure if the electron is in any box or outside. In this case you get entangled boxes that are even weirder. --- The experiment in the link use photon in a one or two slits experiment. The physical details are very different but the calculations and the idea is very similar. The box is the slide, and outside the box is the screen.
- belter 5y agoThanks
- goldenkey 5y agoTo summarize: a measurement need not give enough information to convert a wavefunction into an impulse (point) function. Not all measurements give you point information. A measurement could provide enough information to constrain the wavefunction to a more restricted (knowledgeable) form (lower entropy if you use integrate over the wavefunction -- that is Integral(-P(x)*Log(P(x)))) This is especially the case with entanglement. By measuring one entangled observable, we often increase our knowledge but not absolutely like in the naive explanations that have you believe it is always an entangled pair of spin up and spin down.. All measurement does is reduce uncertainty/entropy of the wavefunction. The strange part is that one can actually undo this restriction by erasing any traces of the measurement. See the Delayed choice quantum eraser experiment. Collapse doesn't really exist.. It's more like expressions that can be reduced, appear reduced, until they cannot be reduced..thus they appear expanded. Imo, entanglement is evidence that all interactions are lazily computed and are copy-on-read or lisp expressions that gradually become larger as interactions continue, and are beta or alpha reduced when possible.
- andi999 5y agoI like it. Dont confuse tgis entropy with the von neumann entropy which increases (or at least stasy the same) when a measurement is perfomed (pure state turning into mixed state)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pdonis 5y ago> If you measure the exact position of an electron, the wave function collapses to a point. Note, though, that in reality you can never measure the exact position of an electron (or anything else); the best you can do is to measure that the electron is inside some finite-sized (possibly very small) region. The "exact position" measurement is an idealization that can be useful for pedagogy but can't be realized in any actual experiment.
- stevebmark 5y agoI’m not sure if this is the same concept: There’s the idea that an observer, through something magical about consciousness, collapses a quantum state on observation, forcing the universe into that state. This sounds interesting until you realize the question: what is the speed of observation/collapse? And then the idea of an observer forcing a collapse doesn’t make sense anymore.
- tus666 5y ago> But surely the wave function is smeared across both slits That's the whole point of the experiment - you can't get an interference pattern if it does not. > and the act of detecting which slit the photon could go through, if it were a particle The whole point of the double slit experiment is that there is only one photon, and which slit it goes through is irrelevant. Whether a photon is a wave-function is missing the point entirely - the point is how do you get an interference pattern if the photon/wave-function only goes through one slot? The point of this experiment is to show that sometimes light behaves like a continuous wave, while other times it behaves like a particle of sorts. And if you think QM has actually provided answers to any of this, you might want to read up... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wave%E2%80%93particle_duality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wave%E2%80%93particle_duality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interpretations_of_quantum_mechanics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interpretations_of_quantum_mec... In short, QM might have produced some nice mathematics models, but it's claims about objective reality are contested. Some people don't agree there is any paradox, and that the double-slit experiment correctly identifies light as a wave, and that claims that the photoeletric effect proves light is a "particle" are based on false inference (particularly that energy quantization implies packetization). Some people still seriously propose that consciousness affects basic particle physics (as if particle know when they are being measured). Despite all that the cool smarty pants brigade who have read some 1st year QM books (while understanding only a fraction) come away all puffed up that QM actually provides deep insight and wide consensus as to the underlying interpretation of reality. The fact is, it's as paradoxical today as when the great physicists up to the last of them (Feynman) correctly identified it as such. Quite sad really.
- devoutsalsa 5y agoIsn’t a wave function essentially just a representation of all possible answers? Like a (perfectly flat) coin flip would be something like 0.5h + 0.5t = 1, where if t is 1, then h is zero, and vice versa?
- josevalerio 5y agoThe confusion with the Copenhagen interpretation comes from two main sources in my opinion: 1. What can count as a measurement? 2. Quantum ‘thing’ interacting with a classical world One of my favorite talks on this subject is by Sean Carroll and offers the ‘many worlds ‘ interpretation as an alternative, mainly for its simplicity. Recommend watching the whole thing but if you want just the “debunking”: 25:11 https://youtu.be/5hVmeOCJjOU https://youtu.be/5hVmeOCJjOU
- pishpash 5y agoInterpretation is a crutch, gives nothing extra, and only obfuscates things; it should be discarded. Let's just accept that (1) we don't know the objective reality, and (2) there is something that ensures consistency of information across fairly large distances -- entanglement experiments have been done up to 1000+ km's -- maybe even across the entire universe, though the latter has never been tested.
- tome 5y ago> entanglement experiments have been done up to 1000+ km's Do you have a link to more info on that? I've never heard of such an experiment and I'd be interested how you send entangled particles 1000+ kms without disturbing them in a way that invalidates the experiment.
- Dudeman112 5y ago>Interpretation is a crutch, gives nothing extra, and only obfuscates things; it should be discarded. It assists people in considering where the models might go and make them think of experiments to invalidate/validate the interpretation. They are as good as any hypothesis and there is a point when you have to guess what things might be, even if you are not sure yet. You can't move forward without conjecture at some point.
- hegzploit 5y ago"Shut up and calculate"
- andybak 5y agoWhich is fine and dandy if calculation is your goal. If "understanding the nature of reality" is your goal then engaging with various interpretations of QM is unavoidable. (which is not to say it will be fruitful. This stuff might be genuinely beyond the reach of science. We might be hitting the brick wall of the unknowable. But that's not an excuse to stop trying. Some current formulations of the question are probably meaningless or based on false premises but philosophy, theoretical physics and experimental physics creep forward hand in hand)
- hegzploit 5y agoTotally agree, that was a popular quote back when people weren't satisfied with the Copenhagen interpretation.
- russellbeattie 5y agoDoes anyone have a link to a real world example of the double slit experiment where the photons are observed at the slits, causing the wave function of the light to collapse so the light acts as a particle beyond the slit, ending up in two piles on the detector screen, rather than the wave pattern. Every time I ask this, some do-gooder will not read a word I wrote and send me a video of the basic slit experiment and think they've somehow educated me. Every time. It's amazing. What I'm looking for is a photo or video of a real experiment showing just two groupings. There a million photos/videos of the wave pattern. I'm looking for an example with exactly two clumps of photons because the light is observed as it passes each slit. In real life, not a computer simulation. Watch this video if you're unclear what I'm asking: https://youtu.be/Q1YqgPAtzho https://youtu.be/Q1YqgPAtzho
- tome 5y agoIf you're trying to say there's something that seem suspicious about such claims then I agree with you. I don't know what it means to "observe" a photon at a slit without completely invalidating the experiment.
- russellbeattie 5y agoI'm just stating the double slit experiment as explained in that PBS video and others and curious about seeing an actual picture. My only suspicion is that no one has done the actual experiment in a long time.
- tome 5y agoAh, well the video is about electrons, and it's somewhat more plausible to "observe" them going through one slit or the other, since they will emit an electromagnetic field. There do seem to be such recent experiments, for example https://phys.org/news/2011-01-which-way-detector-mystery-double-slit.html https://phys.org/news/2011-01-which-way-detector-mystery-dou...
- russellbeattie 5y ago
- GistNoesis 5y agoThere is an intuitive way to picture what particles are and what their measurements is. So simple even a 5-year could play with it. You take a shoe lace. You tie a loose knot in it. Prevent the extremities of the lace to move, by placing your feet on them (or rocks, or whatever). Put your finger inside the knot and slide the knot along the rope. You have just played with a "particle". The knot is the particle. Pinch the rope with your left hand somewhere along the rope. Pinch the rope with your right hand somewhere along the rope. Slide your fingers along the rope to bring them together. This will progressively tighten the rope between the fingers. Alternatively you can just tighten the rope by pulling on it. If there is knot in the region you just tighten, congratulation you have just measured your first particle. If not, try again by placing your finger at different spot, and try again you may get lucky. Quantum physics is a matter of probabilities. Now that you have caught your particle, you have to loosen the knot, so you can explain the uncertainty principle. Once you have played with one knot. Try adding a second knot, move them. Can you get one to go through the other ? Is the number of knots on the rope always conserved ? Now that you have played with knots, here is a fun twist. You need to have a flat lace or a belt though. Lay the flat lace flat. Do a half twist on an extremity of the lace. And like you did with the knot before, slide the half twist along the lace between your fingers, tightening and loosening it as you like. Congratulation you have discovered another type of particle. Try adding another half-twist. How do the twist interact along the rope ? Did you succeed in making them disappear. And can you create a pair of particle out of nothing by twisting the lace in the middle ? If it feels too easy for your 5-year old, you can now show him the belt trick to continuously rotate a cube attached by its faces https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Belt_Trick.ogv https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Belt_Trick.ogv and he will have a better grasp on what an electron is than 99% of high-school students. This analogy can be extended for more complicated kind of knots, twists, elements of lie algebras... And you can also extend it from the 1d case of the rope to 2d case of a fabric (twist along one dimension, twist along the other dimension...), 3d case. If you want to learn more about physics, don't throw the lace away, you can play with it in a ton of different ways (vibrating modes of energy...), even before needing to introduce springs; but that's a story for another day.
- plasticisbad 5y agoThis experiment has been conducted numerous times over the decades by many qualified investigators. Should we disregard their work?
- ElephantsMyAnus 5y agoContrary to what used to be hammered into people, it must be observed by the observer, that is, by you. Any random interaction will not trigger the collapse. An interaction must itself be observed by the observer, otherwise it will not cause a collapse. It seems that the universe works pretty much as Haskell does. Things that don't matter to anything else do not happen.
- Yajirobe 5y agoUmm.. no, the observer need not be conscious.
- ElephantsMyAnus 5y agoIt has nothing to do with consciousness, but the event must matter, or it doesn't happen. Even your consciousness only exist if it matters and will be observed.
- ThePhysicist 5y agoThere's a difference between strong and weak quantum measurements. Experimentally we can now even apply feedback on quantum states to stabilize them, which requires making partial, non-destructive measurements of a quantum state and then applying signals to correct deviations. The whole talk about "wave function collapse" originated from the beginnings of quantum mechanics where the measurement process was poorly understood, in my opinion it should be replaced by the modern understanding, in which a measurement is a combination of an entanglement process between the system under test and a large external system, followed by decoherence caused by the many degrees of freedom of the external system. That produces wave form collapse, but it's not an abrupt or absolute process but rather a continuous, controllable one.
- ElephantsMyAnus 5y agoI think the most reasonable explanation is that unobserved things do not happen, at all, or only happen on some abstract statistical level. That doesn't imply that consciousness is special. The reason why you are aware of reading this, if you are indeed aware of reading this, is that your life matters for some future event, which on the fundamental physical level has already happened, but its exact results depends on how your life unfolds in some way. If I locked you up in an impenetrable box that is to be completely obliterated at some future point in time, so that whatever you do in the box would make no observable difference, the rest of your life in the box would not happen.
- fkfkno 5y agoWhat's that "meow" sound I hear coming from that box over there?
- ElephantsMyAnus 5y agoThat's an observation. Schrodinger cat isn't both dead and alive. Nothing happens in the box while it's closed. Really think about how this is an elegant solution that makes it completely un-paradoxical, excluding that events happen out of order compared to our intuition.
- raphlinus 5y agoThis is the video that finally made it click for me[1]. Despite the somewhat click-baity title ("What Popularizers of QM Don't Want You to Know") it actually goes into quite a bit of detail of what is and isn't a measurement, in the sense of interactions in a quantum mechanical system that strongly resemble classical behavior (it can be said that the quantum mechanical world is a simulator that can run classical mechanics). [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc
- rstuart4133 5y agoThanks. It's perhaps not surprising an approaching quantum "paradoxes" as classical "computer" trying to analyse the quantum computer it is running on appeals to computer programmers. It sure appeals to me.