7 ms·
How Angry Should Other Writers Be About Brandon Sanderson’s $22M Kickstarter?
- mensetmanusman 5y agoThey shouldn’t be angry, as that can lead to dark thoughts of envy and that is bad for mental health. We should be happy for the success of others.
- toss1 5y agoYes, particularly in this case where the success of one validates that there is a new path to success for others. (When the success of others is based on extraction, rent-seeking, and other methods which tend towards exclusivity... not so much)
- DrSiemer 5y agoWhat is there to be angry about? He didn't do anything malicious. Brandon is a great writer, who created his own multifaceted universe through a large volume of interconnected fantasy novels. His world building is excellent and his work rarely disappoints. He practically saved the Wheel of Time, that had become a slog until he took over. Other authors can be envious, but being vocal about that jealousy feels petty. It's a free market, the customer decides where the money goes.
- vagrantJin 5y agoOffroading a little bit on your point about the customer deciding I have a theory about readers. We are not interested in the story as much as how the writer's style presents it. I've passed some books after a chapter but when an audiobook version comes out - turns out it was actually a masterpiece. Curious.
- bluefirebrand 5y agoI think a lot of people prefer books that feel fun to read over books that are hard to read but more interesting stories. Striking a balance between the two things must be a huge challenge as an author. This is also why fantasy genre tends to repel many readers, I think. A lot of fantasy novels come with worldbuilding stuff that is very challenge to present to a reader seamlessly, especially since the characters in the books already should know the information the reader needs. A decent proportion of fantasy novels have invented language, maps, and indices full of trivia that readers must reference to get the whole picture.
- techer 5y agoExtremely hard working and generous artist makes money…why would anyone be angry? I’d be far angrier that someone has to write this article but they have to make a living too… Sanderson’s YouTube lectures of his BYU 2020 creative writing class: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-6HOdHEeosc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-6HOdHEeosc
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoYou should be angry at yourselves. He’s just shown you what was possible.
- dartharva 5y agoThis article is a typical example of modern "journalism" where you make catchy headlines out of non-issues and downright false notions. Literally no one is angry at Sanderson for this. The article itself mentions only two tweets, out of which one is private (invisible to public) and the other gets clarified by its author's next tweet that she doesn't have a problem with Sanderson raising that much money, she was only pointing out how fantasy readers just settle with a few favourite authors and don't try anything new. I wish people stopped reacting to such nonsense and giving it clicks and views.
- rtkaratekid 5y agoDumb point of view. He raised money to self publish. What in the world is wrong with that? However I didn’t know about his success in raising this much money. I read Mistborn, and then I tried to read some other books but found his writing to be immature and his characters flat and not compelling. Am I in the minority? I had just finished reading the Expanse series, which are extremely well written, so maybe it was whiplash.
- Irongirl1 5y agoNo, I feel the same way about his writing. A long time ago, I read an article that said he was a practicing accountant before he took up fantasy. I'm happy that he has found success...it's nice that people can see an example of someone working hard for a dream that's so different, but for me he's never left his accountancy past. He doesn't have the "prose flow" of Jordan or Tolkien. But no one is forced to read his work...except if you want to finish WoT.
- Flatcircle 5y ago“How jealous/petty should other writers be about…”
- whobar 5y agoWho can blame readers for supporting an author they know can produce good output that they enjoy. Maybe there are good books by other lesser known authors out there, but then you have to take a risk with something new. Up until 6 months ago, I had read probably 3 books in 10 years. 6 months ago I started reading again. I started with Rothfuss' Kingkiller Chronicles, books 1 and 2. That set a high bar. Next was the Dune trilogy after I saw the movie. Overall it was good but a bit heavy for reading before bed, I often didn't manage for more than 30 mins before starting to drift off, whilst with Kingkiller chronicles I could easily read 1+ hours. I gave up on Dune book 3, I'll read it on vacation some time. Then I tried Ready Player One, which opened up a whole world of realizing that books can be really bad, just like other art forms. I feel like I've never read a bad book before this (despite not reading for 10 years, I did read a lot as a teenager). The first 25% of the book relies 80s references every other sentence, clearly the writer is trying to nostalgia trip the reader into enjoying it. Then after that he is describing playing a video game. People bemoan how there is a big cultural shift towards watching people play video games, but here is even worse; he describes a super boring boss battle involving an 80s arcade game. Every chapter I read, I got more annoyed at how bad the book was, until I realized I could just abandon it. And now I just started Sanderson's Mistborn #1: The Final Empire, and it feels good to be reading something quality again.
- rdtwo 5y agoThe Obama book deal is more of a legal bribery than something people actually read
- thenerdhead 5y agoIf there's anything I've noticed about the writing community and the internet, it's that people turn green with envy on a whims notice to harvest some type of opposing clout with the community. And they use that envy to take pot shots at somebody for living their own life and has their own views on the world.
- xdfgh1112 5y agoI'm not a fan of his work, but he completely deserves it. He works so hard and releases so many books. Are we angry at GRRM for making millions off Game of Thrones, a series he has basically abandoned?
- wjnc 5y agoTo answer that question: Yes, I am and I’m not alone. GRRRM is free to not give a thing about this anger (look up the response to someone asking if he was going to do a Jordan) but I came to the conclusion that in buying and reading fantasy series I feel there is an understanding of fans that we expect authors to finish series. Obviously that is naive and there is no contract or obligation but there is ample precedent for authors being happy that their series take of and finishing them especially for the early fans. If you start a series still being written you are supporting the authors ‘live’. Could have sponsored the Tolkien estate instead.
- Irongirl1 5y agoActually, I'm with you up to a point. The Publisher obviously gave him an advance for the last two books. Not finishing them...and not returning the money (which tbh we don't know if he did or did not) is theft. Plus it undermines trust and causes issues with the Publisher being able to deploy those funds elsewhere. He obv. no longer cares about the fans; he sold us off to HBO as soon as he could and has insulted us left, right and sideways. He is correct; he doesn't owe us anything, but we gave him millions collectively with the understanding that we would be receiving a conclusion to our series. No problem; I'm never going to give him another cent, but if the Publisher cares about being taken seriously from now on, then they will find an author to finish the last two novels. They should have no difficulty. I'm quite sure that there is an author in Germany or The Scandies with the skill and lyric talent to do the last two books justice. We have probably never heard of them because a great many books are never translated for the US audience. It is thought that fantasy doesn't sell well here enough to make it worthwhile. Meanwhile, HBO maybe in for a painful experience. Because yes, we are all still very angry at not only not having a completed series, but about how badly the TV series ended. Hollywood seems to have forgotten the books that they used to read when they needed to escape from things going badly. I am quite sure they all have favorite books; at the same time, they treat our Worlds badly and then wonder why we refuse to support the crap they produce at the levels they want/expect us to...hmmm, seems a no-brainer to me. Peter Jackson found success with a difficult and dangerous (life-threatening) project because he had enough sense to treat Tolkien's World respectfully...and he sold Weta for $2 Billion. By my reckoning, HBO has left Billions on the table by abusing Westeros and they won't make it back by making new spin-offs. But that's just my half penny...which matters not at all.