4 ms·
I feel like Russia breaking up into smaller states and then each state joining the eu on a long timescale once they meet various civic legal and economic target
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
I feel like Russia breaking up into smaller states and then each state joining the eu on a long timescale once they meet various civic legal and economic targets is the kind of boring solution that will be fought for years and then happen once all other options have been exhausted. This war is really about Ukraine (even the Russian speaking parts, the anti-Nato, Anti-EU people in Ukraine) thinking they'd rather be part of the EU once they get their civic society sorted than immediately be a corrupt part of Russia.
- raverbashing 5y agoI'd favour putting the eastern Russia parts under the umbrella of China if they weren't happy to go buddy buddy with Putin. So I dunno, give it to Japan. Or Korea. Gift Koningsberg to Ukraine.
- jacquesm 5y agoYou may well be on to something here: that Russia is doing this as a warning to other states still under its control that if they flirt with the EU they will get turned into rubble. That would at least make some sense.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI thought this was the generally accepted rationale? What other explanations are there?
- jacquesm 5y agoThat Putin was given faulty intelligence that Ukraine would roll over and welcome the invasion because of their urge to return to the Russian fold.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI don't think I've seen that take and you may be mixing up what he says with what he thinks, always confusing when talking about blatant liars. I've seen people saying that he thought he could force them to install a pro-russian regime (or further split the country) with shock and awe and merely the threat of great violence and underestimated the will and ability to resist, and overestimated his ability to project power, but not that he's totally disconnected from the reality of public opinion in Ukraine. The whole point, whether the invasion worked really well or not, is that he needs to overule their democratic opinion by force. He seems to grasp that or nothing he's doing makes any sense.
- jacquesm 5y agoWhat Putin thinks only Putin knows, everybody else is reading the tea leaves.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoYes, but when people like Meirschiemer predicted this a decade ago, and blame the US and Ukraine for it because this is the obvious response to Ukraine trying to leave the Russian sphere of influence and other people who blame Putin also predicted it a decade ago for basically the same reasons, and also correctly predicted it last month when the "don't blame Putin" side was wrong, it seems theres a general consensus on what's happening even if who to 'blame' is apparently up for debate.
- jacquesm 5y agoYes, we know, whatever Putin does is also the fault of the West. Clearly, Europe and the USA are responsible for Russia invading Ukraine. /s 'Look at what you made him do'... > Yes, but when people like Meirschiemer predicted this a decade ago Seriously: I'm getting a a bit tired of people who can't even spell "Mearsheimer" are trotting him out at every opportunity to make it clear that he predicted all this and more, and that therefore 'the West is at fault here'. So what? Seeing Ukraine and the Baltics as the obvious potential flashpoints in Europe does not require any degree of genius. The question that you forgot to ask was: was it inevitable or not? And if it was then whatever the response the West made was irrelevant, dictators do as they do. I predict that Russia will at some point attempt to take over the Suwalki gap. When I'm proven right that won't amount to a thing, it is as logical as the sun coming up tomorrow morning.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI'm not sure you read to the end of my comment. As far as I'm aware, all sides think this is happening for the same reason, they only disagree about whose fault it is. You raised the possibility that Putin invaded accidentally because someone told him Ukraine wanted to be invaded and he believed them, I don't think that adds up and if anyone is actually saying that it's more likely Russian propaganda than a serious attempt to understand Putin's motives. I'd heard the Russian conscripts sent in to kill and be killed in Ukraine had been told that was what was going to happen, but not sure how far up the chain the lie is supposed to have started, and how many actually believed it.
- bagels 5y agoIt's incredulous that he would believe that after Ukraine flirting with joining NATO and receiving a lot of defense funding from the west.
- jacquesm 5y agoBy all information available the Russians did not believe that their campaign would last longer than 3 days. Lots of little bits of evidence, starting with the amount of fuel and food given to the invaders to the stories those told to their family when after capture Ukrainians allowed them to communicate with their parents to the leaked news article that got withdrawn.
- rr808 5y agoUkraine is not homogenous. Check the results of the election, I'm sure the East of the country (and by Moldova) wouldn't mind being part of Russia, the rest not so much. https://euromaidanpress.com/2019/04/09/first-round-of-ukrainian-presidential-elections-overall-fair-but-issues-in-donetsk-oblast-statistics-show/ https://euromaidanpress.com/2019/04/09/first-round-of-ukrain...
- jacquesm 5y agoWhat you are sure of doesn't really matter though, does it? Elections in occupied territory, especially when there are substantial doubts about the fairness of those elections in those territories (see the article you linked) make it hard to know what is really going on there. And regardless, Russia has already invaded on the pretext that Ukrainians had launched attacks on those regions (which turned out to be staged) so I think we're a bit past that point now. Furthermore, there is plenty of evidence that the citizens of those regions are far, far from happy with the Russian invasion. Ukraine may not be homogenous, but it became a lot more united a week ago.
- rr808 5y agoIts virtually impossible to know exactly what is going on, esp in a war and like you said people's views change. The East really has been a mess for the last deacde. https://www.osce.org/special-monitoring-mission-to-ukraine/511327 https://www.osce.org/special-monitoring-mission-to-ukraine/5...
- jacquesm 5y agoIt's going to get a lot messier.
- nirav72 5y agoAnother theory being thrown around is that Putin also wants to reduce Russia's western defensive line by reducing it down to 600 km versus the 2000+ km it currently has after the break up of the Soviet Union. By taking non-nato nations on the European side, its back to the original line before the pre-soviet collapse.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThat is just the same theory expressed in a different way. He cant control the people of Ukraine by giving then a decent life as a Russian satelite, so he's invading them to force a pro-Russian government on them.