4 ms·
I have relatives and friends and they say so far civilians are not harmed in a directed way. I am worried about them. Is it true that there is a genocide?
by throwaway290 5y ago
I have relatives and friends and they say so far civilians are not harmed in a directed way. I am worried about them.
Is it true that there is a genocide?
- grey-area 5y agoYes, civilian housing is being deliberately hit with shells, thermobaric bombs and cluster bombs. There are no military targets nearby. This is a campaign of terror similar to Aleppo and Grozny and the end state of cities will be the same.
- throwaway290 5y agoAre you basing this off watching news? Some media cried mass murder from day 1, while I had been in touch with people living in the East and first-hand information begged to differ. Now they finally decided to leave their city where active skirmishes were ongoing, so I don't have first-hand info anymore. Reportedly calm so far where they are (I hope they will leave the country, but men are not allowed to leave and his wife does not want to go without).
- grey-area 5y agoI’m basing that on multiple videos from Ukrainian civilians on twitter showing tower blocks, shopping centres and parks being shelled or bombed and civilians dead, the one that struck me was repeated shelling of the side of a tower block by tanks or artillery - that was targeted and aimed at killing civilians. Very hard to fake and no real incentive to do so. Definitely only in certain cities right now but as the war spreads the atrocities will get worse in contested areas. But it’s a very hard decision to leave everything behind and travel is dangerous too. I hope they will be ok and I’m sorry your friends are in such a horrible position.
- bitcharmer 5y agoDo we have the same internet mate? You can look it up yourself... https://www.reddit.com/r/ukraine/comments/t6p7e7/russians_are_destroying_residential_buildings_in/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ukraine/comments/t6p7e7/russians_ar... https://www.reddit.com/r/UkraineWarVideoReport/comments/t634ff/drone_video_on_destroyed_building/ https://www.reddit.com/r/UkraineWarVideoReport/comments/t634...
- throwaway290 5y agoI have people on the ground, I trust them more than social media.
- grey-area 5y agoIf you have doubts about what the Russian army will do under Putin, look at Grozny and Aleppo, and their actions so far. This will become total war - there are no limits and civilians in cities are at severe risk. Your sources have a very local view and may well be safe for now but not later. Unless they are in Western Ukraine they are at risk of carpet bombing as Russia gets more desperate.
- throwaway290 5y agoI never questioned that civilians are at risk, especially in cities. This concern is repeated by my contacts, most of whom are outside of cities. Carpet bombing would be very bad, as Serbia/Montenegro bombings have shown civilian deaths happen and I have less certainty about the precision of Russian military compared to NATO's. As to my sources, sure, and I would want to know first-hand information to the contrary, but I am dubious about social and mass media links. I am amazed by the number of people willing to say "your friends are wrong, they are being killed" while giving reddit links in support.
- grey-area 5y agoNobody is saying your friends are being killed or even bombed right now (depends entirely where they live), we're pointing out that civilians are being bombed indiscriminately by Russia, this is likely to vastly increase in the coming weeks (or months and years if this last that long), and anyone in a city should get out now if they possibly can. Putin will not give up, he will escalate as he has done in the past. He destroyed an entire region of his own country (Chechnya) in order to save face. He views Ukraine as a rebellious region like Chechnya which must be put down by any means necessary. The evidence is there, if you care to look. Frankly your distrust of social media is tending towards paranoia - civilians don't have the means or inclination to mass fake videos, I'd say most are valid reports. Yes videos will be mislabelled (e.g. wrong region) and repeated without question sometimes, but some of the evidence is very clear and very hard to fake.
- brabel 5y agoThe Ukrainians are understandably overstating their case. They are trying to make NATO join the conflict by making us even more scared of what's going on (see the overblown reports about atomic power plant attacks, unfounded claims that Ukraine is only a first step in some grander attack against the West etc). Be very careful in what you believe. If the Russians wanted genocide (which I find, honestly, about as nonsense as Russians saying Ukraine has a Nazi governement), they wouldn't need to send troops in, right? They could just have bombed their cities indiscriminately from a safe distance. The Russian attacks are happening in the cities, it's true, but where do you think the Ukrainian military is?? Why didn't they fight the Russians outside the cities to avoid that? Have you heard of "protracted war"?
- peppermint_tea 5y agoI think you are spot on, just to add to this, I understand why the Ukrainian military does not want to fight outside the cities, It would make them open target for Russian shelling. and the imbalance in forces would probably become more obvious.
- NoPie 5y agoWhile not all information is correct, I don't see Ukrainians overstating that they are facing existencial risk. The country is being attacked, million people are refugees now, thousands dead, probably even more injured, maimed, civilians are being killed, their houses destroyed. The nuclear power plant was attacked, what is incorrect about that? It is clear that Russia has started to war to deprive Ukraine to their independence. There is no doubt about that.
- strogonoff 5y agoI wish I had never been in a position to weigh the two but deprivation of independence and selective political persecution, however bad, does not go as low as genocide. Genocide indeed targets the entire demographic and is insidious in part because it may be misleadingly quiet and peaceful (see the ongoing sterilization of Uyghur women). That said, one can consider deprivation of independence as adjacent to cultural genocide.
- bitcharmer 5y agoYour friends and relatives are misinformed to say the least. Father and son trying to escape being shot at by the Russians: https://www.reddit.com/r/ukraine/comments/t3hukp/phone_camera_footage_recovered_from_the_occupants/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ukraine/comments/t3hukp/phone_camer... And the aftermath: https://www.reddit.com/r/ukraine/comments/t2ihg8/russian_invaders_killed_civilian_family_and_dogs/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ukraine/comments/t2ihg8/russian_inv... This is very disturbing footage so be warned. Some people need to be shaken to wake the fuck up.
- throwaway290 5y agoMy relatives are there, are you? They are in a surrounded city with no food, but they are not shot upon. But I have no way of getting food to them, stores are empty and nothing gets in the city.
- sam_lowry_ 5y agoWe throw your statements away, pitiful anonymous
- throwaway290 5y agoKeyboard warrior, go take some time off and match my donation to UNHCR if you care.
- bitcharmer 5y agoSo this video recording means nothing to you unless corroborated by "your people on the ground". Got it.
- throwaway290 5y agoI might be overreacting, but a video posted online means very little to me as of recently. I am exchanging messages with my contacts (who, if I believed the media, do not have internet now) and with them hoping things deescalate ASAP.