5 ms·
One of the hosts wrote this about it [1]: particularly appropriate quote: > What casual observers might not understand, however, is just how far the policy go
by freedomben 5y ago
One of the hosts wrote this about it [1]:
particularly appropriate quote:
> What casual observers might not understand, however, is just how far the policy goes. Not only does YouTube punish channels that spread misinformation, but in many cases, it also punishes channels that report on the spread of misinformation. The platform makes no distinction between the speaker and the content creator. If a channel produces a straight-news video that merely shows Trump making an unfounded election-related claim—perhaps during a speech, in an interview, or at a rally—YouTube would punish the channel as if the channel had made the claim, even if no one affiliated with the channel endorsed Trump's lies.
[1]: https://reason.com/2022/03/03/youtube-rising-the-hill-election-misinformation-suspension/ https://reason.com/2022/03/03/youtube-rising-the-hill-electi...
- hammock 5y agoOceania was at war with Eastasia. Oceania had always been at war with Eastasia.
- bashinator 5y agoNot at all. Google is a private concern with the right to publish or not any content they see fit. That they can defacto censor opinions they don’t approve of is a failure of the market.
- erichocean 5y agoCorporations do not have rights, they are government-defined entities—not people. There's no "Bill of Corporate Rights" or "UN Convention on Corporate Rights." Corporations have locally-defined privileges and exist by, and at, the will of the people where they reside. Governments can change what those privileges are at any moment, for any reason—or no reason at all. If we don't like what Google is doing, we can simply write laws regulating it differently. ----- In reply: > "In a U.S. historical context, the phrase "corporate personhood" refers to the ongoing legal debate over the extent to which rights traditionally associated with natural persons should also be afforded to corporations." Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_personhood https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_personhood Hint: ongoing legal debate, i.e. it's up to government to decide what "corporate personhood" means—exactly what I am saying. It's up to government, not "inalienable" or "natural" or whatever. It's a purely legal question whether trillion dollar corporate mega-platforms with billions of users have the same regulations and responsibilities as widows and orphans. We don't have to let the Googles and Facebooks and Amazons and YouTubes of the world trample on basic human rights "because ackshually, corporations are people too." Certainly nothing about the 14th Amendment requires it.
- michaelmrose 5y agoThe government cannot easily remove the rights of the individuals who make up said corporations without going through the cumbersome and probably impossible process of amending the constitution.
- krapp 5y agoCorporations do have rights, including the right to free speech and association, because even as entities they are not separable from the people (or the rights of the people) who create and interact with them. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_personhood https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_personhood >Government can change what those privileges are at any moment, for any reason—or no reason at all. No, this isn't the way government works anywhere outside of a dictatorship.
- webmaven 5y ago> >Government can change what those privileges are at any moment, for any reason—or no reason at all. > No, this isn't the way government works anywhere outside of a dictatorship. It really is. The executive branch is the most constrained in practice, but the legislative branch is relatively free to do whatever they want (spend money, create or abolish departments, set the rules, change the rules, allocate money to enforce the rules, etc. Even revise their own deliberative procedures), and the judiciary is even less constrained except that it is the other two branches that control who gets appointed as judges. There are checks and balances, but those are pretty much always another part of government, so ultimately, anything the three branches agree on gets done. Anything. There might be consequences including failing to get reelected for the executive and legislature, but that doesn't necessarily undo what's already been done.
- jmalicki 5y agoCorporations are people, at least within the United States [1], with all rights available to (groups of) individuals. Just not natural people. [1] https://www.history.com/news/14th-amendment-corporate-personhood-made-corporations-into-people https://www.history.com/news/14th-amendment-corporate-person...
- 5y ago
- dmix 5y agoIt’s funny how “as long as you can = you should” works here for Google et al but we’d never apply that logic to a million other social issues we have.
- choward 5y agoThis argument is only valid if the government wasn't pressuring Google. Because they are Google can now use it as an excuse to censor whatever it wants. The government also has big contracts with Google so they can use that as leverage too. This is another form of government censorship that actually benefits Google. The government and Google are both at fault.
- bashinator 5y agoThe government would not be able to bring that pressure to bear if YouTube, g-suite, and Google cloud weren’t all the same company, and if there were a competitive market for internet video distribution.
- zackees 5y ago
- hammock 5y agoMy point was that YouTube seems prefer to erase historical events rather than promote a favored narrative of those events. That's interesting to me. All this hub about right to publish is a non sequitur.
- jquery 5y agoPlease stop using 1984 to make extremely insipid and banal points that don't even really make sense in context. This doesn't really map to anything in 1984, if anything Google makes an attempt to say there is such thing as a shared reality, and that reality isn't just whatever the propagandists say it is. EDIT: all these talking points are the same ones I remember the alt-right getting in a tizzy about when Google started adding information about the Holocaust under holocaust-denial sewage.
- oliveroak 5y agowhy don't they build their own platform? youtube can do what they want on their website.
- Lascaille 5y ago>youtube can do what they want on their website. This isn't a sophomoric forum like reddit. This is meant to be a place where adults discuss. Adults can see that there are democratic implications of the scenario you're describing worthy of discussion. 'Another platform' may take years to develop, and nothing stops Youtube or another hostile player from simply buying it out and kneecapping it, and how many elections are influenced while that takes place? Please don't just repeat talking points, it adds nothing to the conversation.
- lliamander 5y agoOther platforms exist. I'm sure they pop a champagne cork every time youtube ends up in the news for something like this.
- bckr 5y agoI agree with this sentiment, although I agree it's stupid that The Hill was suspended. If anyone wants to give a reason why these arguments are always about freedom of speech VS censorship, instead of being about private property + free markets, please I'm open to this.
- DenisM 5y ago1. Markets fails under the weight of monopolies. Youtube needs to be broken up or regulated. 2. There was a supreme court decision that a platform (in that case a large mall) that makes itself a de-facto public square has to act like one, accruing responsibility to protect speech. I believe this is the right link: https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/583/pruneyard-shopping-center-v-robins https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/583/pruneyard-s...
- bckr 5y agoCool thanks for a useful answer. I agree with your first point definitely.
- tablespoon 5y ago> If a channel produces a straight-news video that merely shows Trump making an unfounded election-related claim—perhaps during a speech, in an interview, or at a rally—YouTube would punish the channel as if the channel had made the claim, even if no one affiliated with the channel endorsed Trump's lies. Welcome to our new algorithmic future, brought to us by VCs and software engineering. Suppression of misinformation is an important function if you want a marketplace of ideas to actually work. However building massively scaled platforms for information dissemination ensures that it will be done by robots with no judgement (either the machine kind, or poorly paid people following a script).
- krapp 5y ago>However building massively scaled platforms for information dissemination ensures that it will be done by robots with no judgement (either the machine kind, or poorly paid people following a script). The article makes it seem as if a human made the decision, not an algorithm. At the very least, humans came up with the policy and wrote the algorithms, and could override them if they wanted to.
- tablespoon 5y ago> The article makes it seem as if a human made the decision, not an algorithm. At the very least, humans came up with the policy and wrote the algorithms, and could override them if they wanted to. Yeah, but to do that you need a humans with judgement and time to think, and that's expensive. I wouldn't be surprised if Youtube's human moderators are paid on production, and quite separate from whoever's writing the policies they execute.
- renewiltord 5y agoThis makes sense. The use-mention distinction does not exist in common parlance. For instance if I were to say “The n-word is reprehensible” this is acceptable but if I were to use the alternative signifier for the same referent, I would likely be banned. If not here, then in most places. With this shift in society, it makes sense for our AI banning tools to also conflate use/mention. It is less a programmatic problem and more a real problem. Since even if you don’t use but mention you are considered to have signal-amplified and therefore used. That is, mentioning is now using.
- sirspacey 5y agoI like this axiom and how it maps to the behavior of information sharing and its potential impact. A disclaimer is a way to demonstrate transparently that a reasonable consideration was made before magnifying false claims. There may be better ways, but it at least accounts for the cost of signal amplification in some way.
- danShumway 5y agoThis is what people don't get about these policies; they think that it's a debate between people who believe Trump's lie and people who don't believe Trump's lie. And sure, there are people in full force coming out here to argue that the election was stolen, but it's not just about whether or not those people get to speak. Inevitably, these policies always end up clamping down on people who talk about misinformation, because at the scale of Youtube, moderation can't really figure out context. This happens all over the place; policies around abuse end up getting applied to people that report that they are being abused, policies around misinformation get applied to people who report that misinformation is happening. It's kind of big news that Trump is still pushing this narrative in 2022. It actually is entirely legitimate to report that he's still saying this, he's likely to be the Republican candidate in 2024, people should know that he hasn't stopped making this claim. There's a debate about disinformation censorship that's all about whether or not censorship is the right way to stop people from telling these lies, but even before we get to that debate, regardless of whether or not someone believes that censorship actually helps prevent the spread of misinformation -- the reality is that platforms like Youtube/Twitter are too big to effectively apply many of these rules, and often they end up affecting the opposite of their intended targets. We have these high-level conversations about whether or not censorship on broad platforms that are nevertheless private is appropriate, and there's some value in having those conversations. But how often do we step back and ask, "are the platforms even capable of pulling off the censorship that they claim in the first place? Is Youtube even capable of censoring election misinformation without also censoring a bunch of other stuff that they didn't intend to?" A conversation about censorship on tech platforms that doesn't take into account how clumsy these filters are in practice isn't really an accurate reflection of the reality. We have debates about whether or not private censorship on a broad scale is a good idea, but it's not even clear that any of these tech platforms are capable of doing censorship in a targeted way for any context-dependent topic. It reminds me of how we used to have a bunch of conversations about the morality of self-driving cars making moral choices during accidents, but you zoom out and realize that even those debates are just incredibly optimistic, and in reality the cars just crash into guardrails because their sensors aren't good enough. We should not go into these conversations assuming that accurately targeted censorship of the kind that Youtube proposes even is possible at the global scale Youtube wants to operate on, we have a lot of data showing that large platforms aren't really capable of moderating with the same degree of precision as smaller platforms.
- dillondoyle 5y agoIt's just bad 'AI' because they won't give up revenue to do what would be required to actually avoid censorship while still cracking down on coordinated bs. I think we need a better word than censorship. More like inept penny pinchers.
- jquery 5y agoThey got hit for signal-boosting Trump's nonsense without correcting it. YouTube is well within its rights to say "hey, we aren't a platform that exists to signal-boost Trump's lies."
- a_shovel 5y agoThis is it. This isn't really a discussion about freedom vs. censorship, it's about how social platforms need moderation, but they've become so big that they're utterly impossible to moderate properly. The Uber strategy, services with no possible path to profitability being propped up indefinitely by billionaires that refuse to stop believing the dream of infinite growth, is incredibly damaging to any ecosystem it infests. Youtube only exists because Google wants data. Video hosting is just too expensive for any realistic business model to support storing and distributing every vacation video ever made, for free, forever. This cradle-to-grave life support preempts all competition and creates monopolies so large they begin to creak and splinter under their own weight. The strategy for Youtube moderation is maximum efficiency per dollar: deal with as much muck as possible with the smallest budget possible, and just let the errors happen because it's too expensive to prevent them (but if the public outcry is big enough, they can reverse the decision.) They can't make things better. There's just no money for it, because Youtube is just too big and it doesn't, cannot, and will never make any money. I was in a chat with someone who worked with Google once and they said, paraphrased, "Our company suggested we could have a team for providing support for non-Partner users, and Google flat-out said 'It doesn't matter how cheap you go, it cannot be done.'" I'm really glad Patreon exists. I think the only solution to all of this is to break the notion that web hosting (and, on another topic, creative work) is free, or that it can be supported by ads. Things cost money. People should be expected to contribute to support services they use. (And of course, that brings up the issue of those who don't have money being excluded. There is no societal problem more than six steps away from poverty/income inequality. Probably no more than four steps, even.)
- unclebucknasty 5y ago>The platform makes no distinction between the speaker and the content creator But this actually is a potentially thinly veiled way to spread disinformation, right? If you wanted to push a dishonest narrative, all you'd need do is show clips of someone else speaking the words and call it "reporting". And this is all within the context of a massive surge in d/misinfo across these platforms. They're already having trouble keeping up. I think that context is important, because it warrants a different level of "aggression" in policing. If someone is spouting lies is it reasonable to, say, block the original producer of those lies, but let thousands of other accounts repeat them and generate millions of impressions for the lies? Because, the lies would still be getting out there, and these platforms are trying to combat being the conduit for them no matter where it comes from. Seems reasonable.