11 ms·
>Why did Russia raise the stakes in December? Sure, NATO's eastward push has demonstrably increased tensions but the eastward push has been frozen since about 2
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
>Why did Russia raise the stakes in December? Sure, NATO's eastward push has demonstrably increased tensions but the eastward push has been frozen since about 2014 since countries can't join NATO if they have territorial conflicts.
Formal joining was on hold, but everything else was accelerating since 2014. Most notably arms shipments, military funding, and NATO/US troops in Ukraine. At some point, there are simply too many NATO arms in Ukraine to invade. Russian power is waning, and at the same time Ukraine-NATO integration was approaching the point of irreversibility.
In 2016, Ukraine was granted a NATO Comprehensive Assistance Package (CAP), comprising the advisory mission at the NATO Representation to Ukraine as well as 16 capacity-building programmes and Trust Funds.
In 2018, Ukraine was officially given an aspiring member status.
In 2021 NATO reaffirmed that “Ukraine will become a member of the Alliance with the Membership Action Plan (MAP)", which is the most traction on the topic since 2008.
From the Russian perspective the window to stop Ukraine was closing. Look at how much trouble they are having now. It would only have been worse with another year of arms shipments and training. Perhaps Russia miscalculated an they already waited too long.
- mcguire 5y ago"...NATO/US troops in Ukraine..." Do you have a source for that? Don't forget, "On June 1, 1996, Ukraine became a non-nuclear nation, sending the last of the 1,900 strategic nuclear warheads it had inherited from the Soviet Union to Russia for dismantling. Ukraine had committed to this by signing the Budapest Memorandum on Security Assurances in January 1994." That was certainly a stupid idea.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Do you have a source for that? US and other Western troops (not NATO per se, though I think all were NATO members) were openly present in Ukraine training the Ukraine military up until shortly before the recent Russian escalation of their long-running invasion of Ukraine (they were pulled out to avoid getting caught up in direct combat with Russia in the event of an invasion.) EDIT: if you need a source, here's an article on the US/UK trainers being withdrawn: https://www.forbes.com/sites/annakaplan/2022/02/12/us-uk-pull-military-trainers-out-of-ukraine-with-russian-attack-possible-any-day-now/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/annakaplan/2022/02/12/us-uk-pul...
- mcguire 5y agoThank you!
- landemva 5y agoBiden's withdraw of US troops in February was the green light for Russia to walk in.
- alphabettsy 5y agoWeren’t there less than 200 US troops and Russia had already amassed at the border of Ukraine? Seems like it was going to happen regardless since the removal of US troops was because of the Russian build-up and not the other way around.
- lsllc 5y agohttps://www.cnbc.com/2022/02/12/pentagon-orders-departure-of-us-troops-in-ukraine.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/02/12/pentagon-orders-departure-of...
- BitwiseFool 5y agoIt's a little more complicated than that. Ukraine did not have the ability to use any of those nuclear weapons because they never had the launch codes. They were basically stationed in Ukraine but were still under Moscow's control. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permissive_Action_Link https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permissive_Action_Link A rough analogy would be this, if the United States broke apart South Dakota would have hundreds of nuclear warheads but the South Dakotan Governor / State National Guard would not be able to use them because they never had the ability in the first place.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoAnd they lacked the knowledge and infrastructure to maintain or modify them. And Russia didn't want them to have them and knew their exact locations. And NATO and the rest of the world saw Ukraine as a violation of the non-proliferation treaty and didn't want them to have them.
- Sylamore 5y agoI suspect they had the knowledge, considering Ukraine was where one of their early nuclear research facilities were - they were able to reproduce early fission experiments and made a proposal to leverage the ability in bombs in 1940 but were dismissed by nuclear experts in Moscow[0]. And it was Ukrainian's who worked to reverse engineer the V2 rockets post WWII and turned it into the rocket design that put Sputnik into space[1]. [0] - https://www.wilsoncenter.org/publication/ukraine-and-soviet-nuclear-history https://www.wilsoncenter.org/publication/ukraine-and-soviet-... [1] - https://euromaidanpress.com/2021/07/26/how-ukraine-wants-to-make-its-space-industry-great-again/ https://euromaidanpress.com/2021/07/26/how-ukraine-wants-to-...
- KptMarchewa 5y agoIf only they tried 00000000...
- mcguire 5y agoIn 25 years? Ukraine is a country with a population of 44,000,000 not that much smaller than the UK or France; South Dakota has a population of 900,000. Would Russia have recovered them if Ukraine did not want to relinquish them? Maybe, but in the 1990s they were in very bad shape, and before 2004 (and between 2010 and 2014) Ukraine was under a pro-Russian government. The point here is that, at this point, if any country is under the illusion that it does not need nuclear weapons to maintain its independent existence, they probably deserve to be absorbed by their neighbors.
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>That was certainly a stupid idea. It is not at all clear that it was a stupid idea. The nukes were useless because Russia had all of the access codes and the ICBMS had a minimum range of 5000 km. They could hit the USA but couldn't be aimed at Russia. The rest were disabled and Ukraine didn't have a nuclear weapons program or ability to repair them. If they tried to keep them, they could have faced retaliation or attack from Russia, the United States, and other NATO allies.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Formal joining was on hold, but everything else was accelerating since 2014. Most notably arms shipments, military funding, and NATO/US troops in Ukraine Yes, after suffering defeat in an unprovoked invasion and occupation by Russia, Ukraine cranked up arms purchases and outside training for it's military. Blaming this on NATO and not the invader is...beyond stupid.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI was answering a specific question as to why now, not assigning blame or cause. There we also lots of donated arms funded by NATO. Keep in mind that in this time period the US also had a bombing campaign on Russian allied Syria and was actively killing Russian troops there. My point is not to say one side is right or wrong, but show that Russia and US relations were very hostile, with attacks, military posturing, and threats from both sides.