3 ms·
I see lots of self-driving car advocates talk about this "on-demand car" model, but I don't see any way it works in practice. No actual sharing: At rush hour,
by allturtles 5y ago
I see lots of self-driving car advocates talk about this "on-demand car" model, but I don't see any way it works in practice.
No actual sharing: At rush hour, I and most of the people around me will need a car to get to/from work. Therefore the rental fleet will have to be large enough to meet this peak demand, and effectively there will have to be a car in the fleet allocated to me (to get me to and from work). So (amortized over time) I will have to compensate the company for the cost of the car, plus the cost of bringing it to me every day, plus overhead, plus profit.
Reduced convenience: A car may not be available immediately when I need/want it. I have to either risk not having a car for some important event or plan in advance and book what I need. The car I'm allocated on any given day may be too small to meet my needs. I have to wait for the car to arrive, can't store my stuff in it, have to take time to install/uninstall car seats, get charged a fee if I leave my empty soda can in it.
IMO, for a regular car user (i.e. someone who currently uses a car for multiple trips per day) moving to an on-demand model will be at least as expensive as and less convenient than owning a car. There might be exceptions in very dense urban environments where parking is very expensive, but those places usually have a good public transit alternative.
- colinmhayes 5y ago> effectively there will have to be a car in the fleet allocated to me I think most people will carpool to work in self driving vans. It'll be so much cheaper than having your own car.
- allturtles 5y agoThey could carpool to work now in their non-self driving cars. So why don't they do it? What does self-driving change?
- colinmhayes 5y agoIt's hard to coordinate and doesn't save money since you still need your own car to do errands. Pre covid many people absolutely were using uber pool to carpool to work.