5 ms·
Was the economic structure of USSR the real problem? I thought it was the power structure (dictatorship) and general lack of accountability of management.
by mleonhard 5y ago
Was the economic structure of USSR the real problem? I thought it was the power structure (dictatorship) and general lack of accountability of management.
- vkou 5y agoThe economic structure wasn't great, but people can disagree as to whether it was due to the power structure (a militarism and imperialism-obsessed dictatorship), and how much of it due to the fundamental problems of... The weird, state-capitalism flavour of 'communism' that was used in practice in the second world. Then you get into no true Scottsman arguments about what is, and what isn't communism, and whether or not state capitalism is guaranteed to be a failure, or whether it was state capitalism, as practiced by the Eastern Block is guaranteed to be a failure. And then you can further split hairs as to whether or not having some aspects of state capitalism in your economy are better than having no aspects of it, and where the optimal line is. And then you find that you've wasted hours of time arguing, but haven't actually convinced anyone, or learned anything new.