6 ms·
Seek first to understand, then to be understood. Understand the Russian history, self and world view, reasons for their views, why they are concerned with NATO
by verdverm 5y ago
Seek first to understand, then to be understood.
Understand the Russian history, self and world view, reasons for their views, why they are concerned with NATO expansion, why they conduct their security as they do.
Ukraine is as much a justified defensive strike for them as it is an unjustified attack by most of the world. The public rationale are not the real rational and has been in the works for more than 10 years.
- NoPie 5y agoIt's completely wrong. Ukraine is an independent nation that is not going to hurt any other country but only tries to improve the lives of their citizens. Russia, or particularly Putin, has ambitions to force Ukraine to follow their lead. This was going to end and that's why Putin decided to attack. But his mental state that sees them as potential danger is wrong. It is a reality but still wrong.
- verdverm 5y agoWas it wrong for the Soviets to invade Poland to fight the German Nazis in WWII? We accept that people have different religious views. Is abortion completely wrong? Is it so difficult to see they have very different world views?
- NoPie 5y agoIn the first example you are trying to insinuate that Ukrainians are Nazis. They are not. It is not about different world views but that some of those views are nonsense. As for religious views – yes, it is wrong for one religion to attack another. Crusades are wrong, especially today.
- gus_massa 5y agoI always though Soviets invaded Poland because they wanted a chunk of it. They had a non aggression pact with the Nazis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molotov%E2%80%93Ribbentrop_Pact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molotov%E2%80%93Ribbentrop_Pac...
- verdverm 5y agoThere were two competing thoughts on how to defend Russia from Germany, simplified... fight on your own territory, fight on someone else's territory, the second won out but failed terribly and they were forced back into their own lands
- TheCoelacanth 5y agoThat's nonsense. Germany and the Soviet Union cooperated to divide up Poland between themselves. It wasn't until nearly two years later that hostilities between them began.
- verdverm 5y agoOur statements are not exclusive, they are both parts of the same story
- gus_massa 5y agoLooking at other of your comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30559634 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30559634 Is this your real opinion? I think it's interesting to discuss with people I disagree, because they may have a different point of view in some topics. I don't expect to reach an agreement in these topics that have a strong political and emotional charge, but I think it's worth having an honest discussion. If this is not your opinion, the problem is that you may be misrepresenting their point of view. You many be holding a straw man so people takes turns to punch it. And the only takeaway is that anything can be misinterpreted if someone tries hard enough, that is hardly surprising.
- sidibe 5y agoThis is the purported reason of the Russian leadership and supported by academic "geopolitics experts" in the West, who trade in depicting the world as 2 or 3 powers and a bunch of helpless will-less vassals doing their whims and suffering for it. More likely from what he says Putin's reasons are for returning Russia to some bygone glory. But for the public that supports the war, they are being told it's to fight Nazis. That should be easier to deprogram than the NATO expansion story
- tanseydavid 5y agoHow exactly is NATO expansion a "story"?
- RealityVoid 5y agoEasy, NATO expansion is a consequence of Russia's imperialist intentions. Reality corroborates this world view. You could hardly call a neighborhood watch a ill-intentioned alliance against the poor thief. Also, Russian security concerns lie: https://www.reddit.com/r/CredibleDefense/comments/t2mb0c/the_russian_security_concerns_lie/ https://www.reddit.com/r/CredibleDefense/comments/t2mb0c/the...
- liamwestray 5y agoBullshit. Putin has stated he wants to reunite former Soviet states. Ukraine becoming more democratic and wanting to join western systems like the EU and NATO make that impossible for Putin. Putin cannot afford a large successful Slavic democracy to be a direct comparison to the authoritarian regime he’s built. If democracy and free markets succeed in Ukraine, no amount of Putin’s propaganda will protect him from long term instability and potential overthrow by the people that have been under Russia’s corrupt yolk for 30 years.
- jstx1 5y agoParoting a tyrant's excuse isn't "seeking to understand". Assuming that Putin's statements are representative of the Russian people is clearly incorrect. Invading another nation isn't "conducting security". You can use your line of reasoning to justify any action however evil or wrong as long as the person taking it is giving a reason in the meantime.
- verdverm 5y agoIt's not my line of reasoning, it's the russo line of reasoning. Putin has more supporters than you likely think he does. Their world view is very different from the west's
- jstx1 5y agoOkay, I genuinely don't understand if you even have a point that you're trying to make. OP: How to argue that invading Ukraine is wrong? You: Here's what Putin and his supporters think. Sure, he's made public statements about this, I don't get how they're relevant here given his position. Every tyrant and aggressor in history has had a bullshit excuse and a group of supporters. That doesn't make their position equally good to the people they're opposing - and that's what I thought you were saying with your previous comment.
- NoPie 5y agoThis is bullshit. Their world is exactly the same. Before this war you could go to Russia, at least in the biggest cities, and the life was exactly the same as in any other European country. The beliefs are due to propaganda. Most Russians have close ties to Ukraine and would never think of waging war for no reason.