4 ms·
I could make the argument against "rationality" a lot better than the strawman the author picked. "Rationalism" is, too often, a way of insisting that one's mo
by jfengel 5y ago
I could make the argument against "rationality" a lot better than the strawman the author picked.
"Rationalism" is, too often, a way of insisting that one's model of the world is so self-evidently true that any objections to it are of necessity irrational. They often like to insist on simplified models, and insist that those simplifications must be fair because they're simple, while denying the ways in which they're constructed to reinforce their own preferences.
Economics is one especially popular place for that. Magazines like Reason will insist on "supply and demand" to explain everything, and simply ignore when reality fails to bear it out. Supply and demand is first-week-of-the-first-year economics. It shouldn't come as a surprise that it's no more effective than the frictionless massless pulleys taught to equivalent physics students. Which is to say, not ineffective, but nobody would try to run a real economy or a real engine with just that.
Rationalists aren't often very good even at the purely tangible stuff, much less the intangible stuff. Especially when that intangible stuff is things like the experiences and points of view of people who have been excluded because they've specifically defined those things as "intangible" and thus not subject to their rationalism.
In general, it's helpful to be skeptical of self-complimentary labels like "rationalism". Nobody sees themselves as irrational, so what is it they're actually setting themselves up in opposition to?