5 ms·
Review of Lessons in the Fundamentals of Go by Toshiro Kageyama (2011)
- xiaodai 5y ago
- NhanH 5y agoFor English speaking audience, Japanese publisher still probably has the broadest catalog (both in classic books and new releases). The new book by Shibano is fairly good. There was only a couple of Korean books translated and released more than 10 years ago, and Chinese Go Books are in the similar situations
- morelisp 5y agoIn addition to the nationalist undertones of this comment, it reminds me of the pop culture chaos esp. endemic to front-end development. Yes, modern professional go is full of innovations you won't find in the older Japanese titles that make up the majority of recommended English-language books. Yes, that probably prevents you from winning that elite title. No, that doesn't stop you from playing amazing games after learning from them. The fundamentals haven't changed, and the fundamentals are 99.9% of the game.
- explodingman 5y agoAnother entertaining non-leetcode book on go is The Treasure Chest Enigma (a go miscellany) by Noriyuki Nakayama. The core of the book is a collection of essays originally published in the Igo Club magazine in 1975 and 1976. Great read!
- zoul 5y ago(Go the game, not golang)
- rulakhy 5y agoTook me several seconds to realize this.
- shusaku 5y agoI want to add a recommendation for this book to any novice player (though not to an absolute beginner). It really improved my game, and gave me a new perspective on how to play.
- padiyar83 5y agoIt took me 10 min to see that he is talking about the game and not the language. There is even a "Endgame Pointers" chapter in this book :).
- morelisp 5y agoThe "(2011") in the title is a bit confusing in this regard since that's when the review was published; but the subject is more obvious if you know the book itself was published in 1978.
- everyone 5y agoI play go and I really don't understand most players, who seem to be desperate to improve at it. Go is an abstract game, played for fun. Go skill has limited to no applications outside of being good at Go. I don't think improving makes the game any more fun. If you're playing with a friend irl, if one of you gets too good ye will no longer be able to have fun games together. If you're playing online, then as you improve you will simply face opponents at the same improved level for eternity so nothing will change from your perspective. So, improving doesnt make the game more fun and can potentially make it less fun. Online go servers like KGS and OGS seem to be hyper focused around their ranking systems and almost every player is desperate to grind more rank. Ive always found this baffling but I have a theory. Maybe if you can put a number on someones skill at something, these people feel good if the number goes up cus they feel reassured they are improving at something in a measurable way? (Even if that thing is utterly trivial) Perhaps certain people need some kind of metric to feel good about themselves? Could also apply to the trend of acquiring excessive amounts of money or luxury goods.
- Madmallard 5y agoIt's human nature to be competitive
- kuboble 5y agoIt's a natural desire for many people to improve and get better at whatever they do. For some the process of getting better is fun, but not necessarily higher skill itself. >Perhaps certain people need some kind of metric to feel good about themselves. ?
- morelisp 5y ago> Go skill has limited to no applications outside of being good at Go. At the very least all games of this style are excellent working-memory exercises. Go also trains pattern recognition and balancing short vs. long term priorities. > as you improve you will simply face opponents at the same improved level for eternity so nothing will change from your perspective. No, the quality of games changes. They're more interesting, and you get more out of them. Just like most skill-based activities. > almost every player is desperate to grind more rank. It's true that KGS/OGS have a fair number of "leetcoder" equivalents but this book is probably the exact opposite of this attitude. The author's humble and funny, topped out at a relative low rank compared to his peers, and maintained strong ties to the amateur go scene during his time as a pro. He clearly loves the game more than "the system" and is trying to communicate not just how to play effectively but how the game fits into a life.
- kuboble 5y agoI'm an OK go player and I love this book. It is one of the few materials which had direct and immediate effect on my game quality. 10/10.
- kqr 5y agoI'm a weak go player but every other year or so I re-read this book and get a couple of stones stronger for it. (I then drop back to my previous level when I pause my playing for a while.) This book has also taught me a few things about mastery of any subject in general! Some of the lessons are surprisingly transferable.
- jfzoid 5y agoI have a copy of this book, though I never got past the few pages. When I tried to read it I got through the first chapter, which says the first thing one should do is play many games, and I put the book down to do just that. It also makes a great point that while amateurs play the game for fun, professionals will labor at it. I thought that was a fantastic point For context, I occasionally play against the AI on an iPad app called SmartGo, probably 24-36 kyu rank.
- mark_l_watson 5y agoAnother good iPad app is CS Pro Go. It will do game analysis which is useful, but time consuming. I took online lessons a few years ago from a South Korean Go master and enjoyed having my games analyzed. CS Pro Go is obviously not as good as a Go teacher.
- pdpi 5y agoCould you link the app directly? Googling Valve's CS: GO makes googling for "CS Pro Go" borderline impossible.
- mark_l_watson 5y agoSearch for "CrazyStone DeepLearning Pro" https://apps.apple.com/us/app/crazystone-deeplearning-pro/id1160054151 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/crazystone-deeplearning-pro/id...
- mark_l_watson 5y agoI bought that book a long time ago, perhaps in the late 1970s? Go is such a great game. I retired yesterday (but I will still be a ‘gentleman computer scientist’, write books and do open source code). I made a list of 21 things I want to do in retirement and playing online Go is on that list. https://online-go.com https://online-go.com is a good resource, and there are others also.
- influx 5y agoIs your list published anywhere?
- mark_l_watson 5y agoYes, I just wrote a blog about my list this morning https://mark-watson.blogspot.com/2022/03/i-retired-yesterday-my-list-of-things.html https://mark-watson.blogspot.com/2022/03/i-retired-yesterday...
- fileeditview 5y agoFor a pretty good client and a rather large western player base https://www.gokgs.com/ https://www.gokgs.com/ always was a good place to play.. Didn't play for a few years though, so things could have changed.
- 3np 5y agoI love this book, partly because of the entertainingly condescending tone: --- I know that there are many who spend morning to evening every day in go clubs, playing tens of games a day, but make no progress. No matter how ardent their will to learn was at the beginning, let this condition continue for two or three months, not to mention one or two years, and hope is abandoned. The player comes to recognize himself as ‘a permanent 6 kyu’ and everyone else does too. This condition is unbearable, yet how many go players find themselves in it? Almost all? If so, it would be a crime just to let them go on as they are, and that is why I am writing this book - to explain in detail what is needed to break through the barriers
- Tarsul 5y agoI considered myself one of the worst players who loved the game of go. That's because I had no ability whatsoever to visualize in my head how the next few steps would go. Without this, you really can't play. It's way worse than in chess because in Go this is more obvious to the visually-handicapped player that this ability is needed to really play the game. I played chess in my youth and didn't really understand that most others (most definitely the good) players would visualize everything in their head wheras I would say in my head "I do this and then this.. hmm, maybe something else", basically more than 3 steps weren't really possible for me. So this is a longwinded explanation but what I'm saying is that these types of games require a different type of thinking (that is visually) than almost everything we usually do (even most math) and many people can't really do it (well; and I couldn't do it at all). That's why it is basically always a niche game. If you can learn to think visually, you notice the intricacies of the game much more. So why did I love it, even though I couldn't do it? Because I saw some puzzles (tsumegos) where the result was often like: Wow, that's awesome. I never had this epiphany with chess puzzles. And how did I learn to visualize it (at least a bit^^)? I had to silence my inclination to always "talk" through what I want to do. But that's just one aspect, it's different for everyone I think. Also, I've come to the conclusion that the more you are in a dream state the better you can visualize things. Even so far that when you're tired you might play better. Anyway, it's a most fascinating game with its simplicity but also its complexity and its entanglement of tactics and strategy but also of weird moves that change the whole game. Most fascinating and I will always love it even though I was for the longest time the weakest player who loved it :)
- fileeditview 5y agoYou might "suffer" from Aphantasia[1]. I learned about this a few years ago. Before I thought it to be totally normal to not "see" any images in my head. Turns out it really isn't that normal. There is definitely a grey area here but for me it's pretty black. I cannot imagine any picture in that sense. I also play chess and it always was a mystery to me how people can play blindfolded. I always got lost somewhere in the middle game.. probably just because I could not visualize the board in my head. I am still pretty good at calculating tactics in chess and Go.. so it's hard to say what is actually important for what aspect of the game.. the brain is a complex beast! [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aphantasia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aphantasia
- yeldarb 5y agoThe In Sente YouTube channel has a good series of videos that cover each of the chapters from this book: https://youtu.be/6YvKJN2qso4 https://youtu.be/6YvKJN2qso4
- elzbardico 5y agoThis reminds me of another reason why calling the go language just “go” was an act of supreme assholery