10 ms·
What's the problem with old but excellent Mac apps?
- dukeofdoom 5y agoSkill sets are being lost. At one time desktop development was the thing. Now its not. Things get memory holes as technology advances. Not many brick layers around anymore that could build Brunelleschi's Dome.
- ilrwbwrkhv 5y agoI am reminded of the excellent "Preventing the Collapse of Civilization" talk by Jonathan Blow: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZSRHeXYDLko https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZSRHeXYDLko
- Kibranoz 5y agoI think Catalyst is no longer relevant with the SwiftUI framwork
- math-dev 5y agoWhy? I thought they go hand in hand
- gumby 5y agoThat’s the plan but I don’t think SwiftUI is there yet. Even the name gives it away: catalyst is like Carbon or Rosetta — intended to be transitional.
- Tagbert 5y agoSwiftUI is still a little rough in some places though it is growing fairly quickly. If you are doing simple UIs where there are already UI components built, it works well, but if you need more custom or more complex you get into the weeds pretty quickly. Catalyst is helpful for the near term (next few years?) to bring over more complex iOS apps that use the iOS UI framework. That gives developers a product now while they work on a SwiftUI version or whatever direction they end up going.
- Turing_Machine 5y agoAgree with the others: SwiftUI is a long, long way from being ready for prime time at this point. In practice you're going to be stuck using a nasty, ugly mixture of SwiftUI and AppKit/UIKit for anything beyond the most basic design, and that way lies madness (at least for me). But I also agree that SwiftUI is very promising, and I like what I've seen a lot. It's just not there yet.
- alin23 5y agoI think they serve different purposes. Catalyst is mostly used when you’ve already written your iPad app (either in UIKit or iOS specific SwiftUI) and now you want to make that app available on Mac without rewriting parts of the code. You can indeed write a multiplatform app in SwiftUI nowadays. That’s what I’m doing with Volum (https://lowtechguys.com/volum https://lowtechguys.com/volum) which easily shares 95% of the code between macOS, iOS and iPadOS, and only platform specific code like keyboard shortcuts or volume OSD is isolated. But you kinda have to start with that multiplatform mindset from the start, otherwise you’ll soon find out you used too many custom NSViews and Cocoa APIs, your UI is not designed for portrait mode, and it’s a burden to place #if os(macOS) guards all over the place now.
- AlabasterAxe 5y agoIt's funny to me that there's no acknowledgment that high fidelity web apps and electron apps are taking the wind out of the sails of platform specific desktop app development.
- Razengan 5y agoThey’re taking the wind out of the entire hardware alright.
- Torwald 5y agoNot on the Mac. If you take MS Office and the Adobe stuff aside, the iconic indy Mac apps are still ruling their respective categories.
- AlabasterAxe 5y agoThat may be true today but it feels like it's changing, though. And I think it kind of aligns with what the authors are talking about. Apps started today are natively collaborative and they're written with web technology.
- btmoore 5y agoAnd they're terrible.
- lupire 5y agoHave any of those been newly invented in the past <10 years?
- ohCh6zos 5y agoI've yet to see a good web/electron app.
- infinityio 5y agoVS Code is the standard example
- GeekyBear 5y agoI would certainly rather have a Catalyst app than an Electron app, just from a system resources used standpoint. Slack, for example, can be absolutely ridiculous.
- kitsunesoba 5y agoIf I could run the Slack or Discord iOS apps on macOS I absolutely would, along with several other apps that have both Electron and iOS apps. Are Catalyst apps as good as true designed-for-mac AppKit apps? Not usually, but they’re still several steps up from Electron apps and I’ll take what I can get. Unfortunately the companies behind these apps have elected to not allow users to make this choice, so once Universal Control is released these apps will be permanently moving to my iPad.
- spondyl 5y ago> If I could run the Slack or Discord iOS apps on macOS I absolutely would, along with several other apps that have both Electron and iOS apps. To clarify the situation for any unaware readers, you can indeed run iOS/iPad apps on M1 Apple Silicon devices however not all. From memory, the policy was actually that everything was allowed to be installed by default with developers having to opt out of allowing users to install their iOS/iPad apps on macOS devices. There used to be workaround that may still work, but I haven't tried it in some time. You can use https://imazing.com https://imazing.com (you'll just have to look past the marketing site for a minute...) to download apps you own as IPA files. Once you've got those, you can use the built-in macOS IPA installer to install those apps, even if developers have marketed them as not installable via the App Store. https://www.theverge.com/2020/11/18/21574207/how-to-install-run-any-iphone-ipad-app-m1-mac https://www.theverge.com/2020/11/18/21574207/how-to-install-... for a bit more info on the process
- saagarjha 5y agoIt’s a bit more complicated than that. First you need to dump the unencrypted app from its IPA (you can do this on an M1 Mac when SIP is enabled, or a jailbroken iOS device). Then, take the resulting IPA and resign it with a valid provisioning profile and you can then double-click to install it. I’ve been using Slack and Discord this way for months and apart from some minor bugs it’s a great experience.
- seumars 5y ago>I’m so stuck in my daily work routine of creating apps that I’m not a good customer of apps Surely that can't be a good thing?
- pketh 5y agoMaybe not. I think you’ll find creators and auteurs in other fields like film or video games that feel the same way about their field
- bertez 5y agofantastical is quite nice
- sys_64738 5y agoIsn't the wider issue that developers follow the money. What's a few million Mac users compared to 100s of millions of iOS users? I can charge a buck and sell a few 100K iOS sales but where is the market for MacOS apps to sell? Is there one?
- Turing_Machine 5y agoWell, the main difference is that Mac users are still largely willing to actually pay for software -- they don't demand that everything be "a buck". You could write a combination of Photoshop, Microsoft Office, and AutoCAD, and put it on the iOS app store for $2.99 and people would complain about the price.
- fxtentacle 5y agoFully agree. And in general, developers won't want to spend too much money on osx-only work because other platforms have (like you said) much more users and also a lower maintenance burden. Native Mac apps tend to require recompile and updates for every minor os upgrade. Electron is slow, wastes battery time, and is usually unsafe, but it'll shield the developer from Apple's aggressive api deprecation.
- kitsunesoba 5y ago> Native Mac apps tend to require recompile and updates for every minor os upgrade. Electron is slow, wastes battery time, and is usually unsafe, but it'll shield the developer from Apple's aggressive api deprecation. In my experience this varies a lot depending on the type of app. Your typical CRUD app (which the vast majority of apps are) will probably work fine for many releases in a row without needing significant changes to source or even a recompile, but if you're doing anything fancy with hardware or lower-level APIs you're more vulnerable. Rate of change in AppKit/Cocoa is glacial relative to just about any front end or even back end web framework. Not too long ago I got an early-2000s open source Mac app compiling and running on current macOS over the course of a weekend… there were deprecation warnings all over the place but it worked fine. Meanwhile when I unearthed an early-2010s RoR project, resurrecting it was an exercise in futility.
- egypturnash 5y agoThe problem for me is as much that excellent Mac apps are being replaced by shitty Electron crap as anything else. I relied on Evernote for ages but then it got rewritten as a sluggish web app and now it's just utterly unusable and I have not found anything that fits its place of being a notebook that lives in native apps on my Mac, iPhone, and iPads, and lets me collaborate on some things with my friends who use Windows and Android. I am sort of starting to maybe substitute Scrivener for it. Which is a super-amazing native app designed for writers that sets a pretty high bar for anyone who wants to "continue to improve writers’ workflows in the coming decade and innovate in that space". Most of the apps I've installed on my Mac lately are to change the way the OS behaves, to be honest. Like, Bartender is useful and makes dealing with all the little utilities that want to live in the menu bar a lot easier. I'm an artist and Illustrator is my main medium; Time Sink's tracking tells me that I've spent about 3.3 days in Illustrator so far this year, and 9.5 days in Safari, and everything else is measured in hours and kinda looks like a rounding error compared to those two apps.
- dntrkv 5y agoIf you’re ok with something a little more barebones, I highly recommend Bear App. Been using it for years. It’s super minimal, while at the same time allowing you to achieve everything you need to do. One of those tools that just gets out of the way and you never fuss with it. Also great performance and you can sync it across devices seamlessly.
- egypturnash 5y agoLast I checked it looked nice but it failed the “collaborate with Windows/Android friends” requirement. Has that changed?
- ohCh6zos 5y ago1password was an amazing app and now it's an electron app that frequently doesn't work for me, if you want another example.
- smoldesu 5y ago
- alin23 5y agoAll the new apps I use and create are utility apps. • rcmd for faster app switching (https://lowtechguys.com/rcmd https://lowtechguys.com/rcmd) • Lunar for adaptive brightness on monitors so I can stop fussing with monitor buttons (https://lunar.fyi https://lunar.fyi) • Soulver for converting between units/currencies and testing math formulas • Cleanshot for annotating screenshots (because showing people what button to press to solve their issue is faster than explaining it in words) • TextSniper for copying uncopyable text • HyperKey for turning that useless caps lock key into some kind of global modifier • NotePlan for writing stuff down while still being able to back reference it by day • MateTranslate for super fast menubar language translation I guess I have a bit of compulsion to always make my every day work more efficient, while in fact I spend quite a lot of time testing these new apps and readjusting my workflow for them. Now I feel that they’re an essential part of my workflow, and I feel like everyone’s life would be better if they’d use them. But actually I have mostly met people who, like the article author, rarely get out of their work routine and don’t need more apps because they don’t encounter new annoyances.
- DavideNL 5y agofyi, free and opensource (Swift) alternative to TextSniper, works with Alfred too: https://github.com/schappim/macOCR https://github.com/schappim/macOCR
- replwoacause 5y agoAnybody have a list of these so called "old but excellent" Mac apps? I guess mine would be Typinator. I just picked up a license which is a one-time cost. The product is solid and so is the support. I wish I knew of other types of products like this because I would most likely buy them without hesitation. I'm tired of seeing so many damn subscriptions on my bank statement.
- jslpc 5y agoI'd also love to have a list of some of these apps, just commenting to come back to this in case someone provides one.
- flenserboy 5y agoOther than a couple professional apps, the actual Mac apps I use on the regular are Ulysses, the Affinity suite, nice, little tools like Soulver, and built-ins like Pages. I very much miss the old days of software, not just Mac software — paying for software that was purpose-built, tested, and often, it seemed, liked by its creators was much easier, even at 80s & 90s prices, than dropping $3-$100 on what today is a crapshoot that will likely move out from under your feet with an update six months from now.
- lupire 5y agoBut the software back then couldn't do 1% of what software does today. It's a tradeoff. You can run that old software in an emulato if that's all you want. And abandonware is free.
- flenserboy 5y agoPerhaps, though I doubt it. Modern software may have more features and functions, accumulated over time, but what it so often lacks is a good way to encourage discoverability (and can make it much worse — e.g., the Office Ribbon) while making things work better through internal consistency (though that internal consistency was often at the expense of being applicable application-to-application). It's funny how much paid software is so much worse than FOSS options when it comes to actually using it — the FOSS stuff may not look as nice, but it does the job, gives more and better options, and has something resembling documentation. Old software is much closer to FOSS tools than modern paid software in spirit, and much has been lost in the quest for paid-but-cheap.
- ds9soft 5y agoPeople want cheap software, and that’s what they get.
- chezzwizz 5y agoTo the title I respond: its the same answer as any planned obsolecense argument. People don't like paying for sustainability. Would you wan't to just pay someone to keep using your 1956 Kitchen Aide mixer? Just cause it ain't broke yet? Perfection is not a good business model.
- Brajeshwar 5y agoI try to stay with the default native apps and programs that comes with the OSes (currently Apple) as much as possible. I have begun to ponder upon and want to go linux once I retire from active work. I try to keep backups of the content in either open or universal formats to be able to move and decouple from Apple smoothly, if needed. I continue to experiment and tinker with new tools but after using it, buying/pro/premium it, and I begin to realize I just need to learn a little more with the native apps and I can do that smoothly enough that my muscle memory kicks in. Well, I even subscribed to SetApp[1] and use less than 5 App there at most. My approach these days is -- I need to be able to own and/or control the content but use any tools, and be able to walk of the tools when needed. I try to keep a note about it and will update that -- https://oinam.fyi/digital/apple/ https://oinam.fyi/digital/apple/ 1. https://setapp.com https://setapp.com
- dmix 5y agoI miss the days I first got my Mac and discovered Textmate.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI’m a BBEditer. Have been, since the days of MacOS 7 or 8. Other editors have come and gone, in that time, but I have never found a compelling reason to switch. There’s a lot of “junky eye-candy” out there. Cool-looking apps that actually fall flat, in their primary reason for existing. I will often try one out, then let it lie fallow. Every now and then, one deserves a place in my canon, but it’s rare.
- perilunar 5y agoI love BBEdit. One of the very few paid Mac-only apps I use. Almost everything else I use is either free, cross-platform or Electron-based, or a web app.