3 ms·
The Mind Map Book
- account-5 5y agoI wanted to use mind maps when I first learned about them (when I found out I was dsylexic in later life and told I would be a visual learner), and sometimes I do, but not often. Certainly my hand written notes are full of arrows, circles, boxes, etc; linking things across the page(s). My issue with mind maps, as it is with other things like concept maps, is that until you know the whole subject, and all the points you're going to need, you waste time drawing, and redrawing them; because you've missed something or you need to link a node to another that's on the other side of the web of lines. I find that if the thing I'm making a mind map about is simple enough to show on a mind map I can usually write the same thing as a simple (nested) list. Obviously I might be missing the point. I'd love to be proven wrong.
- tough 5y agoI really like MindNode, lets you reorder as you go, export to markdown, etc
- lancesells 5y agoI like MindNode as well but want something that's not a subscription. Still use it without the pro features but wish I could just buy it for a flat fee.
- allenu 5y agoI was disappointed about their move to a subscription model. Luckily. I had purchased their previous version and that thankfully still works. It’s a beautiful app and makes creating mind maps easy. To the other poster’s comments, I use mind mapping to sketch out ideas and do a brain dump of what I know about a topic. I usually don’t end up referring to them long term. It’s kind of like a scratch pad for me.
- voltaireodactyl 5y agoIf you’re in the Apple ecosystem, I’ve found iThoughtsX to be even better than MN, and one time purchase.
- pc86 5y agoIsn't drawing & redrawing it part of the process?
- tconfrey 5y agoBuzan was my hero. I started with speed reading and used mind maps extensively for college notes in the 1980's. I've dabbled with mind maps on and off ever since. On paper with multi-color pens they really help you explore an idea or information space, and they definitely help with retention. OTOH I've never found a software implementation that worked, at least for me. There's something too tactile, unconstrained and creative about the pen-on-paper model.
- pc86 5y agoChanging the input medium from a pen and an essentially blank canvas to a keyboard and mouse really changes what happens if your brain. I wonder if something electronic on a tablet with a stylus, that automatically syncs to your computer and is reformatted for that medium, would be closer?
- mensetmanusman 5y agoI use iThoughts on the iPad. Really is helpful :)
- jnxx 5y agoa graphics tablet could be useful here, they are much more similar to pen and paper, though the coordination between hand and eye needs to be re-learned a bit.
- karmakaze 5y agoThis is the part that I have a problem with: p.125: methodical branch-by-brach development of Mind Map is not desirable limits thought My position is that anything you can write down, is incomplete and limited and a subset of your own growing understanding. To write it down is to hamstring greater understanding. It is better to write throwaway notes used to make a picture of a particular context for the situation, use it, embellish it, then when the problem at hand is solved, discard it. I used to keep log books. What I found is that it was mostly a write-only journal. In rare cases there were specific pages that I would refer back to frequently because it was good documentation of a particular thing. Most of the pages were scrap. So now I mostly just grab the closest piece of paper and use it like a whiteboard. The other thing I'm coming to realize is that my knowledge isn't necessarily representable in words or even pictures. They tend to be concepts related to other concepts by conceptual links. I could try to draw one such picture, but that would make it less likely that I can find a corresponding picture in an analogue as it takes thoughts away from the conceptual/formless structures. Related term 'Ideasthesia'.