3 ms·
This is bad, but nuclear isn't uniquely dangerous here: just imagine the same kind of shelling around a large dam.
by eru 5y ago
This is bad, but nuclear isn't uniquely dangerous here: just imagine the same kind of shelling around a large dam.
- ornornor 5y ago> a large dam It would be catastrophic but much more localized. Fallout from Chernobyl went around the world several times, poisoning most of the humans alive or being made at the time (not to mention the rest of the biomass)
- akvadrako 5y agoNot at a dangerous level, say more than eating a banana. The dam breaks killed and hurt magnitudes more people.
- numlock86 5y ago> Fallout from Chernobyl went around the world several times, poisoning most of the humans alive or being made at the time [...] > Not at a dangerous level, say more than eating a banana. Born 1986 in Germany and I got a rare metabolism illness that only ~2000 more people have, all born around June/July/August in 1986 in Western and Middle Europe with some exceptions distributed around as late as born in September and October. But the Spring of 1986 was probably just a famous year for pregnant women eating exceptionally many bananas I guess? At least I agree that dams killed more people than that specific event. But wait till you see the numbers for fossil fuels ...
- eru 5y agoYes, I brought up the dam since hydropower is something that's typically seen as good; but still has the potential for big disasters. (I totally think hydropower is good on balance.) Fossil fuels, and especially coal, have worse impact in total but they are typically more diffuse. So I left them out of the discussion.
- watwut 5y agoA single dam break did not killed and hurt magnitudes more people then singly Chernobyl.
- akvadrako 5y ago> In 1975 the failure of the Banqiao Reservoir Dam and other dams in Henan Province, China caused more casualties than any other dam failure in history. The disaster killed an estimated 171,000 people and 11 million people lost their homes.
- dewey 5y agoWere they able to rebuild their homes in the years past that in the same spot? Yes. Are people able to move back into the Chernobyl fallout zone in the next few thousand years? No.
- eru 5y agoSee https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/world/2016/04/17/chernobyl-30-anniversary-babushka-ukraine/82887336/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/world/2016/04/17/chernob...
- ciphol 5y agoChernobyl killed about 10k people. A single dam collapse killed 170k people a few decades ago.
- ornornor 5y agoChernobyl killed millions of people over time. Tons of thyroid cancers that would have never existed if Chernobyl didn’t explode.
- suyjuris 5y agoDo you have any kind of source for this? As far as I am aware, estimates for deaths based on thyroid cancers are ~160 [1]. Not 'thousand, just 160 – you claim is off by five orders of magnitude. Estimates for the total death toll are up to 60000 if you assume the linear no-threshold model [2], so might be much lower in reality. [1] See e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deaths_due_to_the_Chernobyl_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deaths_due_to_the_Chernobyl_di.... [2] The model assumes that any amount of radiation is harmful and estimates the harm of low doses as a corresponding fraction of the harm of large doses. Empirical evidence is unclear, at best, but it functions as worst-case estimate.
- spopejoy 5y agoHow about the 2009 epidemiology study that estimates > 900,000 dead by 2009 with no end in sight? Quoting from a summary (easy to find the original): > In 2009, the New York Academy of Sciences published a book Chernobyl: Consequences of the Catastrophe for People and the Environment. A team of European scientists led by Dr. Alexey Yablokov, former environmental advisor to Russian Presidents Boris Yeltsin and Mikhail Gorbachev, assembled over 5,000 research studies, most written in Russian and not previously published. > The results were staggering. Yablokov’s team estimated that just in the first 20 years after the Chernobyl meltdown, some 986,000 deaths attributable to it occurred, many in parts of Ukraine, Belarus and Russia. The percent of children living in these areas considered in good health plunged from 80% to 20%. Rates of certain cancers soared, including childhood thyroid cancer in Ukraine (20 times higher) and Belarus (200 times higher). Rates of disease in covering many organs in the body all increased in areas closest to Chernobyl. > Yablokov’s team indicated that the number of casualties would continue to grow, well after publication of the book.
- dewey 5y agoI hope you realize how bad of a comparison that is. If a dam would break and flood some area it would kill people but after a year the chaos will be cleaned up and things will be back to normal. If the same thing happens to a nuclear power plant the area can't be lived in for millions of years.
- eru 5y ago> If the same thing happens to a nuclear power plant the area can't be lived in for millions of years. Some people have been squatting in the Chernobyl exclusion zone for decades now, and are still alive. See eg https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/world/2016/04/17/chernobyl-30-anniversary-babushka-ukraine/82887336/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/world/2016/04/17/chernob... I wouldn't want to live there myself, and cancer levels might be slightly higher than normal.
- dewey 5y agoLiving secluded in a big exclusion zone with ~180 other people, no stores or infrastructure and higher levels of cancer is definitely something we should strive for.
- eru 5y agoThe lack of stores and infrastructure comes from lack of other people, which could be fixed. I'm not sure if there is a higher level of cancer. But I grant you that we can assume that. It's not pretty, but it's also not something that prevents people from living. Remember when everyone used to voluntarily increase their risk of lung cancer by crazy amounts? Back when everyone smoked? Civilization still persisted.
- c1ccccc1 5y agoActually, the estimates for when the region will be habitable range from 3 centuries to 20 000 years. [1] "Millions" is off by several orders of magnitude. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chernobyl_disaster#Exclusion_zone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chernobyl_disaster#Exclusion_z...