3 ms·
We don’t really know what Russias strategy is here. They could be hitting the north near Kyiv as a primary distraction to build a land bridge to Crimea and hold
by dmix 5y ago
We don’t really know what Russias strategy is here. They could be hitting the north near Kyiv as a primary distraction to build a land bridge to Crimea and hold on to the east.
They know at some point a treaty will be signed so it’s whatever they can compromise is the end goal. This would only take a few months at most if that’s all they care about (that and punishing western movement as a side gain).
- RealityVoid 5y ago> They know at some point a treaty will be signed Do they though? Looking at Putin's actions, I wouldn't be so sure.
- dmix 5y agoWhy would Russia who lost in Afghanistan and defended Syria’s regime expect to hold something like Kyiv or Kharkov long term via regime change? I really don’t see that happening and I haven’t seen one good explanation from anyone about how they would do that. Syria is the example people are missing not some tiny weak state like Chechnya. The west had tons of local support in Syria but Russia just had to prop up the state and local military long enough to ‘win’ that war. That’s all the west has to do to ‘win’ in Ukraine. To me it only makes logical sense for Russia to be feigning a full state takeover like a chess match, with a dual goal of just maintaining Baltic coast and punishing Ukrainians for Euromadien. Otherwise they are crazy and dumb, which they are regardless given their now near total economic isolation, but there has to be some logic here beyond some shortsighted George Bush style ‘regime change’ strategy.
- dylan604 5y agoIn Syria, the Russians were as you said propping up the gov't that was already in place. In Ukraine, they will have to hold onto control long enough to remove the current gov't so they can install the crony/puppet gov't. Once that's in place and the peoples are placated enough to accept the regime, they can pull back. Of course, the threat of coming back to settle any disagreements would be ever present.
- redisman 5y ago> maintaining Baltic coast Do you mean Black Sea or I’m not understanding this point
- GolfPopper 5y agoActually, we do know Russia's (or at least Putin's) strategic aims: to seize all of Ukraine. His captive news agencies accidentally published them in a pre-planned "victory" editorial last Sunday that was not-swiftly-enough taken down: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-60562240 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-60562240
- dmix 5y agoI’ve read too many John Le Carré books to believe Russian ex-KGB strategy here would be so blunt and simple as swapping out some political leaders. There has to be a midgame here besides attempting to level a few major cities (Syrian cities were absolutely smashed and their state held on). But like I said we don’t really know for sure, especially because some state controlled media did something like leak convenient information.
- tokai 5y ago>Syrian cities were absolutely smashed and their state held on Yes ofc, those cities were smashed for the state. Russia and Assad are allied.
- DoingIsLearning 5y ago> We don’t really know what Russias strategy is here. They could be hitting the north near Kyiv as a primary distraction to build a land bridge to Crimea and hold on to the east. I agree, this whole belief that they are fixing history (from a russian perspective) and forcing Ukraine to be Russian again seems to be a bit of a pretext. They have huge reserves of Oil and Gas in Crimea, this would have guaranteed many more years of Gazprom cash cow for Russia. The problem is Crimea does not have it's own water supply it depends on mainland Ukraine, this is why I think they first focused on securing Cherson and Marioepol. This is probably the part they want to keep after negotiations, they just miscalculated expecting that the international response would have a been a shoulder shrug similar to South Ossetia in the Georgian war of 2008.
- woodpanel 5y agoI think you are mistaken to believe, a country as natural-resourceful as Russia is in Ukraine for the purpose of natural resources. For Russia it is about protection. If say Russia would be able to permanently place "security-troops" on the east-bank of the Denjepr it would have reduced its "Ukranian flank" by 50% in length. If the west remains NATO-free, perfect from their standpoint. From looking at former election results, the eastern bank as well as the southern steppe, would be relatively safe for permamently stationed Russian troops.