5 ms·
How did they manage to flip the second craft from it's reentry position (nosecone down) back around for landing? Wouldn't carrying the extra fuel to slow the c
by zdw 15y ago
How did they manage to flip the second craft from it's reentry position (nosecone down) back around for landing?
Wouldn't carrying the extra fuel to slow the craft on reentry make this cost prohibitive, thus why most craft use parachutes or similar passive slowing devices?
- powertower 15y agophysics.
- zdw 15y agoHaha... the point I was trying to make is that flipping a spacecraft in a vacuum is easy as there are very few external forces involved. Flipping a craft while hurtling toward the earth at some large velocity through an atmosphere which generates friction with very few control surfaces is not.
- cincinnatus 15y agoNowhere in the video do they show any drogue or drag chutes but I would assume they enter into the picture as well, and would be involved in the mid-altitude slowing and flip of the second stage.
- jarin 15y agoYou can definitely do a deorbit burn and then flip around using thrusters before aerodynamics kick in. The Space Shuttle did it all the time.
- bsiemon 15y agoThe extra reaction mass is just a balance between the various costs. Building a new rocket per launch vs some constant factor off the top of your payload capacity.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- palish 15y ago> How did they manage to flip the second craft from it's reentry position [...]? Apologies, I think I don't understand... The video is a concept video, not a real-life recording.. it's CG. But you're asking about real-world physics. And everyone else is talking about it too, as if the video actually happened, even though it's just a CG animation. I'm just really confused; sorry. Heh. I know I'm missing something obvious here -- figured I'd ask what it was, even though I look silly. :)
- keeperofdakeys 15y agoThe video wouldn't have much point unless it was showing the design of how the rockets will actually work. Sure, the actual design and details of the rocket may be different in real life, but the basic idea of having the components soft-land back at HQ would be real.
- sigterm 15y agoI think it's possible to flip by shifting the center of mass, which can be done by moving some mass (for example, fuel) inside.
- watmough 15y agoI believe the video showed the final stage vehicle flipping using thrusters in orbit, then re-entering engine facing Earth.
- JulianMorrison 15y agoNo, it flipped, decelerated, flipped back (off screen), re-entered brown bit first - that is the ablative shielding, then it must have flipped (off screen) while falling through atmosphere after re-entry because it came in to the landing pad feet first.
- lutorm 15y agoYeah, I saw this too. You'd better make sure you're going slow enough before you turn that thing sideways or you'll do a Challenger...
- JulianMorrison 15y agoIt should slow right down though, it's an empty tank.
- lutorm 15y agoThat's the problem, it will slow down so fast it might not stay in one piece (this is what happened to Challenger, hence my comment.) A pipe like that going sideways has a tremendous aerodynamic resistance.
- JulianMorrison 15y agoNo, I mean, it will slow quickly while doing the nose-first heat shielded re-entry, all the way down to terminal velocity, and then be safe to do its flip to feet-first.