5 ms·
"How do you out-will the singular authoritarian leader and/or his small group of oligarchs?" If the Russian people are unhappy enough, regimes change from with
by giantg2 5y ago
"How do you out-will the singular authoritarian leader and/or his small group of oligarchs?"
If the Russian people are unhappy enough, regimes change from within. We can see that with some of the Russian soldiers surrendering.send me to Ukraine? OK, I'll just surrender so I don't have to fight and die for a bogus cause.
- rectang 5y agoUnfortunately, it seems that Putin is fairly popular in Russia. Anecdotally, there's been an HN commenter around who claims to be Russian and who buys Putin's line that something had to be done about NATO. Apparently they are not alone: https://www.cnn.com/2022/03/03/europe/russia-reaction-war-ukraine-dougherty-intl-hnk https://www.cnn.com/2022/03/03/europe/russia-reaction-war-uk... > But Arina's mother sees it completely differently: "My mom believes everything she sees on TV," Arina says. > "She believes that it was a necessary measure by Putin because there are weapons surrounding the country...there's a threat from the West, which is why Putin is doing this." Sanctions may be indiscriminate, but not as indiscriminate nor as final as shelling apartment buildings. There seems to be a significant slice of the Russian population who are entirely too content with the current state of affairs, and who need to be woken up to the ungodly horror being unleashed in their name.
- friedturkey 5y agoSo long as the people with guns have their bellies full, not much will happen in Russia. Just like as much as the world wants North Korea to change and become more free, most of the people enforcing the law can’t imagine living any other way and they’re happy to maintain the status quo. Maybe a rapid decline in quality of life will be enough to turn things around in Russia. Or maybe just enough people are so used to struggles there that nothing will change. North Koreans went through decades of wars and invasions—the people there haven’t known that life can be better, so they don’t feel a reason to revolt. People in Russia who were alive during pre-Putin era struggles most likely do really see him as lifting the country to a higher level. The possibility for Russia becoming a new NK-style state isn’t completely impossible.
- snek_case 5y agoThe USSR collapsed over 30 years ago. There's a lot of people who were born after that, or who saw their quality of life improve after it happened. I bet you not many of them want to go back to those days.
- Animats 5y agoThe death rate in Russia went way up after the fall of the USSR.[1] Democracy and a free market did not deliver a better life for the average Russian. It's important to understand this, because it's part of why Russia ended up with an autocrat. [1] https://akarlin.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/life-expectancy-in-russia-1950-2013.png https://akarlin.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/life-expectan...
- dash2 5y agoThat death rate is IIRC mostly caused by increased alcoholism, so it may have more specific causes than just “democracy and the free market”.
- giantg2 5y agoWouldn't despair about their predicament or future lead to alcoholism? Something that could be related to regime change.
- kwhitefoot 5y agoCould you be more specific?
- dash2 5y agoThis article is a response to a critique, by the original authors. It should have cites to the debate: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09668136.2012.691657 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09668136.2012.6...
- 5y ago
- twh270 5y agoAccess to many viewpoints and sources of information does not mean much, as we see here in the U.S. The idea that we just need to shower Russia with the "right" information to get them to turn against Putin is simply a fantasy. However, it's still worth doing as it will help some.
- rectang 5y agoI don't expect plain rhetoric to change the minds of Putin supporters. Unfortunately, we have to resort to economic pain, which is quite grim even if it's not having your leg blown off and your home reduced to rubble: businesses ruined, working class populations impoverished, massive uncertainty... It's also not guaranteed to work, as aggressors and oppressors are adept at wallowing in self-pity and inventing victimization narratives. What's changed for me is that I've come to believe that the Russian population is a bit more at fault here for buying Putin's bullshit.
- vixen99 5y agoWhatever the truth of that ('she believes it was a necessary measure ...'), as someone remarked "Putin has done more for European Defence in three days than anyone's done in 30 years". The reaction of the European countries has been astounding. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/03/03/putin-will-live-regret-war-has-united-europe-against/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/03/03/putin-will-live-... Sadly paywalled.
- int_19h 5y agoAs of February 26-28, roughly 50% of the Russian population believed it to be a justified war, according to this poll (which is as independent as it gets in Russia): https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Ym9e7ot4t-JVBDqtK0m4n6iYPqdZy8LL/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Ym9e7ot4t-JVBDqtK0m4n6iYPqd...
- snek_case 5y agoI thought it was much more than 50%, had been lead to believe the majority of the Russian people supported this war. As the Russian economy tanks, mothers find out their sons died for a pointless war where civilians are getting killed, and the notion that Russia is being internationally shunned starts to sink in, this number should drop. Hopefully that makes a difference. I do think it's smart to do everything we can to sanction Russia's rich. Those people have power. They're the ones backing Putin. If they start to feel the pinch, feel that the party is getting ruined because of Putin's mood and his thirst for power, they might do something about it.
- int_19h 5y agoI think a lot of Westerners are forgetting what "no free press" means. Your average Russian citizen - who does not have foreign bank accounts etc - may not even find out the details about the sanctions. Their quality of life will suffer, but their TV will feed it into resentment of the West.
- brabel 5y agoIn other comments, people are talking about how it's impossible for Russia to control all communication in Ukraine because there's always a way for the "resistance" to exchange information in a way the enemy cannot stop... yet, we also see comments like yours that assume Russians have no way to get information from non-state-sponsored actors, despite them being still mostly connected to the Internet (despite Ukrainian requests to remove them) and a simple VPN would give you full access to any website you may want to visit (and that a lot of international sources are still available in Russia - they just now cut off the BBC, for example, but it had been available the whole time before that).
- simonh 5y agoWe thought that about Belarus, and Syria. All that happens is the regime becomes as brutal and oppressive as necessary to stay in power. The USSR broke up because it was held together by an ideology and political structure which fragmented. Putin doesn’t have or need an ideology, any more than Assad or Lukashenko do.
- riffraff 5y ago> If the Russian people are unhappy enough, regimes change from within. We all hope that, but it's not been effective for north korea and basically everywhere else. Waiting 70 years as for the Soviet does not seem an ideal outcome.
- giantg2 5y agoTrue, but what escalations would be preferable? Nuclear war, protracted ground war with near-peer adversaries, WW3, etc are not ideal courses of action either. Assassinations could be an option, but would likely have to come internally to have the desired affect.
- veganhouseDJ 5y agoPersonally, I don't understand this point of view. Most despotic leaders are not well liked by the people. There are so few examples of the people rising up to depose a despot. I actually can't even think of one that would apply in this situation. He is probably insulated with layers of old Soviet/KGB true believers/cronies. Somehow the common person is going to penetrate that? I just don't see it.
- School-Cotton 5y ago> Most despotic leaders are not well liked by the people. Are you sure? This is not at all obvious to me.
- barry-cotter 5y ago> If the Russian people are unhappy enough, regimes change from within. Apart from when the US got the UK and France to kneel and kiss the ring in 1956 with Suez when hav sanctions worked? Grenada? North Korea and Iran have been under crippling sanctions for a long time. It leads to plenty of civilian suffering but there’s not much record of success in forcing governments to do what the sanctioners want.
- School-Cotton 5y agoSanctions got Iran to sign the nuclear deal which was a huge accomplishment (unfortunately later torpedoed by Trump for no reason, but that’s not relevant to the point). They don’t have to topple the government to be effective. That said, I do think there’s not enough public recognition of how hostile and damaging sanctions are to innocent normal people.
- wahern 5y ago> unfortunately later torpedoed by Trump for no reason Not just Trump, but the entire Republican Party and its voter base. And not for no reason: the reason is that it's easier to keep Iran as a public punching bag than try to deal with real and far more difficult strategic problems like North Korea, Russia, or China, all three of which seized the opportunity to pursue their strategic goals while the U.S. was distracted in Iraq and Afghanistan. Iran took that opportunity, too--the wars provided both the impetus and the time to pursue a nuclear program.
- giantg2 5y agoEh, this isn't exactly true. The three main reasons were that the deal did not have permanent enforcement, Iran is still pursuing ballistic missile development (not covered by the deal), and they provide support to the Hezbollah terrorist group (although this is declining and technically done through a non-government group). I'm curious, what strategic goals did North Korea, Russia, and China achieve during that time that the US should have dealt with, and what could be have done that we haven't already?
- odessacubbage 5y agoi've seen this sentiment echoed lately and it seems patently absurd, US presence in iraq and afghanistan was massively unpopular by the middle of the bush administration; it took another 14 years for us to leave. it seems like foreign policy is still trapped within the fallacies of Giulio Douhet and Curtis Lemay, simply replacing firebombing with starvation. not to mention that the economic devastation and looting of the 90s was how we ended up with Putin today.