4 ms·
So you know cash has processing fees associated with it, right? Really. They're totally orthogonal to the cost of physically creating paper or metal currency,
by patio11 15y ago
So you know cash has processing fees associated with it, right? Really. They're totally orthogonal to the cost of physically creating paper or metal currency, and they're mostly subsidized by merchants. Cash management is a hard problem. WalMart spends about 3 million every year moving pennies around -- that actual coin type. Every time a salon owner has to spend time driving to the bank or money leaves a cash register, that's just another cost incurred because the merchant accepted cash money as a payment type.
Checks also have processing fees associated with them. They're mostly subsidized by banks.
Credit cards have processing fees, paid for mostly by merchants.
Merchants really want banks to subsidize their use of debit cards, like banks subsidize their use of checks.
There is no such thing as free, there's just free-from-the-perspective-of-your-own-P&L-statement.
- seanalltogether 15y agoI also understand that maintaining roads is not free, however I'm not paying fees to private companies for the privilege of using them because of how important they are to national infrastructure. I should be paying less overall in taxes to maintain these roads then I would be paying a collection of individual for-profit companies to get the same level of service...in theory. Is digital currency still too immature to consider the same?
- jerf 15y agoReal costs are probably higher than you expect. Sure, it's so cheap it might as well be free to write a program that debits one number and increases another and run it a few billion times, but reliable financial systems require more than that. Consider what it takes not just to implement a chargeback, but to be able to implement a chargeback, and to be able to stand behind it legally, and to be able to defend against lawsuits, to be able to prove compliance with various regulations, etc etc. Everything looks easy from the outside. I don't see any compelling reason to think the government would intrinsically do any better, it would just move the costs around and probably incur more of them overall when the full accounting was made, which it never would be, because who can regulate the regulators?
- justincormack 15y agoIs there any evidence that there is a competitive market driving the prices down though? Looks like this regulation was designed to push down costs by fiat, but people wanted to keep their profit margins and shifted the costs, so no worse than what you are saying the government would do. The government should be trying to design cmpetition into the system.
- chrischen 15y agoI think he was saying that the gov't should make it free, not that it is a free service with artificial costs attached to it.
- mahyarm 15y agoWhy do banks in the USA charge so much for generic P2P wire transfers between accounts? It's cheaper and quicker to give someone a check in the USA in a face to face situation vs. a simple wire transfer to their bank account. Wire transfers would be cheaper for the bank since they wouldn't have to process paper checks. ACH is kind of there, but that's not open to the general public.
- ramchip 15y ago> WalMart spends about 3 million every year moving pennies around -- that actual coin type I tried googling the data but I didn't find it. Is there a reference for that?
- patrickc 15y agoYes. Google walmart "moving pennies" and click on the first result
- laaph 15y agoPlease don't use google as a reference. Please, when you want to make a reference, use anything else. The first two results are to hacker news (this page!) and after that the results are to pages about penny stocks. http://www.google.dk/search?q=walmart%20%22moving%20pennies%22 http://www.google.dk/search?q=walmart%20%22moving%20pennies%... I know my google-fu is worthless but I can at least follow directions, and it still comes up with nothing.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- ramchip 15y agoTo be honest, I think he was making a joke about the HN post being its own reference, although I'm not too sure...
- laaph 15y agoI was trying to illustrate that telling someone to google for references when they already indicated that it was unsuccessful, is not likely to be successful.