5 ms·
Anti-racism betrays Asian students
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoThis tired old argument is getting threadbare. Fairness, to the privileged, can look like persecution. I.e. Because some parents are more interested in boosting their children scholastically when very young, doesn't mean they deserve a disproportionate share of the public school services. They've been getting it because helicopter parents are pushy. When there's pushback they make these spurious claims of being more deserving, and somehow persecuted.
- tandymodel100 5y ago
- qgin 5y agoIt seems like it depends on whether you’re looking at students as individuals or not. If an individual student is getting less than average access to resources in order to statistically balance allocation of resources by race, that individual student isn’t getting (or even asking for) a “disproportionate share of resources”. They’re asking for an equal share, but in reality getting less because what group they are being categorized into.
- tsol 5y agoAsian immigrants are privileged? They have high of poverty, this is a weird take just because some Asians are well to do
- sniperjoe360 5y agoJoe with all due respect your logic is flawed. Parents who are interested in boosting their children scholastically are not necessarily privelidged. They could be privelidged. But wouldn't it also make sense for the least privelidged parents to also want to boost their children scholastically? Do you have to be privelidged to be a "helicopter parent?"
- Lascaille 5y ago>Parents who are interested in boosting their children scholastically are not necessarily privelidged. Believing in the value of education and pushing your children to achieve educationally is an inherent demonstration of the possession of privilege.
- nescioquid 5y agoIf "believing in the value of education...is an inherent demonstration of the possession of privilege", then mere belief can render one privileged or unprivileged. This sort of thinking seems...religious.
- thelock85 5y agoAgree to some extent but you are not addressing the “pushing toward achievement” part of the comment. A parent can only push as far as their ability to identify, access and afford opportunities, and that’s where privilege does play a major role in terms of information asymmetry and spending power.
- ryan93 5y agoinformation asymmetry? what parent doesnt have access to the knowledge that doing well on your homework and tests in school will lead to better college opportunities.
- Lascaille 5y ago>access to the knowledge Having 'access to knowledge' is one thing. Believing that knowledge - say, from personal experience of it applying to people you know - is privilege.
- thelock85 5y agoExamples of information asymmetry: - not understanding standard of care regulations around early childhood education and thus believing that your child's current learning environment is of sufficient quality or not knowing there are paths to advocate/demand more - having your child attend a school that lumps all students with learning differences and behavioral issues in the same classroom (for all kinds of systemic reasons like the lack of qualified special education teachers), and not understanding how to get your child diagnosed in a way that gives them legally-mandated better accommodations... like more time to take the "tests in school" - having the school itself be unaware or untrained in all of the accommodations your child could possibly need, or having the school be ambiguous about where learning/values/behaviors are the responsibility of the school vs. home, and thus having no direction on how to partner with your child's school An okay analogy is "doing taxes". Sure all of the rules, codes, regulations are there in plain sight, but unless you know someone who has maximized their tax return under a similar situation as your own, then you're just doing your best unless you have the resources to hire an accountant. Similarly, a parent can know all of the ingredients that go into a successful education pathway, and can endeavor to understand all of the rules and regulations. But with no understanding of how these things play out for their kid's specific use case (or with no money for tutors, test prep, application coaches, college visits) then it can be tough sledding in actual practice.
- ThrowawayR2 5y ago> "Fairness, to the privileged, can look like persecution." Given the history of anti-Asian racism in the US, I don't know how anyone can say with a straight face that Asians are "privileged". As for "parents are more interested in boosting their children scholastically", this being HN, few here will see that as anything other than an absolutely good thing that we should want all parents, regardless of color, gender, creed, or anything else, to be doing.
- redwall_hp 5y agoThe Chinese Exclusion/Geary acts weren't even repealed until the 1940s, when they "generously" allowed ~100 to immigrate per year. It prevented naturalization on grounds of ethnicity, prevented extant residents from coming back if they left, and restricted land ownership. Then there was that whole Japanese internment camp and mass land seizure thing too. (Check out how much California farm land is worth now: it was a generational theft on a massive scale.) The earlier half of the 20th century was an awful time to be asian in America, and the systematic suppression of generational wealth for purely racial reasons is not an effect that just goes away overnight.
- ashwagary 5y agoCompared to the black native population, Asians are extremely privileged. This is not a controversial statement. Black Americans fought for Asian's rights to immigrate to the US and once they arrived, Asians were turned into a buffer class because they mostly had no interest in fighting the global system of white supremacy (partially due to ignorance). This made them less of a threat to the ruling class and dominant society. This game is still being played (even in this thread) and many recent non-white immigrants are still too ignorant of unsanitized/heterodox US history to understand why native blacks fought & died for them to come here in the first place. US mainstream historical propaganda - 1 Native black Americans - 0
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoCertainly true. And its the very point - not everybody helps their children. Asian parents by-and-large do. ANd certainly the school system favors their children. That's the premise we started with. The children are doing well because their parents are helping them. Then fudged the rules so their children got the lions share of attention and programs. Those without parents that helps them (culturally, economically) do poorly. Through no fault of their own (being born to the wrong parents?) Try to help all the children, and the cry of "Reverse racism!" or some such nonsense gets raised every time.
- djanogo 5y ago"..disproportionate share of the public. They've been getting it because helicopter parents are pushy" What degenerate world are we living in, parents wanting their children to succeed and do what they know is causing _you_ to discriminate them for their success?
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoWhat part of the parents' action equates to "should get all the public money"? It's public money - meant for everybody. Ignoring that, whitewashing fairness as discrimination, is exactly my point. Thank you for illustrating this sense of outrage perfectly.
- evocatus 5y agoMy parents fled from active warfare. My father had AK47s pointed at his chest. They came to my current country of residence with very meager means. None of them participated in local politics or were involved with the school board. Because they both experienced poverty, violence, and actual warfare, they understood the value of education - to prevent me from falling into similar circumstances. I suppose, to you, this now constitutes privilege? I always thought this was something reserved for the whites. Or, are you bringing the notion of "white privilege" into question? Otherwise, it seems that you are implying that I am not deserving of preferential treatment based on my race, and that I have not experienced any particular form of persecution.
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoPutting words in my mouth. I suggest re-reading what I posted and thinking hard. I'll not respond to this blackmail.
- evocatus 5y agoThat's OK. Your position is already clear enough.
- 908B64B197 5y agoI love how asians are suddenty white when it's conveinient to do so [0]. Don't like the stats? Simply tweak them untill it serves your true agenda. Google did the same thing, by grouping whites and asians together in their diversity stats. [0] https://www.asian-dawn.com/2020/11/17/school-district-categorizes-asians-as-white-adjacent/ https://www.asian-dawn.com/2020/11/17/school-district-catego...
- User23 5y agoAs I understand it, the scientific consensus among educators is that there are no innate differences in ability between racial groups, which stands to reason since they aren't a meaningful biological category. Thus under-performance by black and non-white hispanic students is caused entirely by white supremacy and racism, either direct or systemic. The question of whether or not white hispanics suffer from racism is cloudy, because the data is rarely broken out. Still, I suppose it tracks pretty well with other whites of similar socioeconomic status. That leaves Asians, who measurably and increasingly outperform all other races both scholastically[1] and economically[2]. This presents something of a challenge to a naive understanding of the consensus theory. After all, why would racist whites be systemically advantaging Asians over themselves? The obvious explanation is something like that Asians are too hard-working to be held back by white racism, but as others have noted it's hard not to take that as implying that blacks and non-white hispanics are inferior to Asians in their work ethic. Lumping whites and Asians together makes all of these difficulties go away. The consensus theory is shored up, and if on the margins some Asians miss out on admissions, they can still be proud that they are helping to rectify an even greater racial injustice while looking forward to the highest average incomes in the country. [1] https://www.insidehighered.com/admissions/article/2018/10/29/sat-scores-are-gaps-remain-significant-among-racial-and-ethnic-groups https://www.insidehighered.com/admissions/article/2018/10/29... [2] https://www.epi.org/blog/racial-disparities-in-income-and-poverty-remain-largely-unchanged-amid-strong-income-growth-in-2019/ https://www.epi.org/blog/racial-disparities-in-income-and-po...
- 908B64B197 5y ago> Thus under-performance by black and non-white hispanic students is caused entirely by white supremacy and racism, either direct or systemic. The systemic part is especially interesting. A concept I was exposed to quite late in life by black colleagues and friends was the idea of “Acting White” [0]. Basically, a (black) colleague of mine first introduced me to the term when he recalled how he was ostracized at school for saying out loud he enjoyed trigonometry (something everyone at the table shared seeing as everyone went to CS or engineering). Selective schools like Lowell here in SF must be a heaven for kids stuck with peers that are dragging them down. It’s really sad they want to end it with a lottery and race quota. > The obvious explanation is something like that Asians are too hard-working to be held back by white racism, but as others have noted it's hard not to take that as implying that blacks and non-white hispanics are inferior to Asians in their work ethic. Lumping whites and Asians together makes all of these difficulties go away. That right here is the reasons humanities are considered a joke and politely ignored. > The question of whether or not white hispanics suffer from racism is cloudy, because the data is rarely broken out. This story came from an acquaintance, so I have no way of verifying it’s true. But at their daughter’s school several years ago the college counselor basically told a girl with a Spanish sounding name to claim she was Hispanic. Her parents were white, and her dad was from Europe (came to the bay for a PhD at a certain local university and then worked for an early internet company with a colorful logo). She got into a few pretty good universities despite having worse grades than her (self-declared) white friends who coincidently didn’t make the cut. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acting_white https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acting_white
- zozbot234 5y agoThese days, anti-racist is a code word for anti-Asian. I suppose that's progress compared to singling out whites only, and if history is any guide conservative-leaning Hispanic and Latinx folks (who are achieving better social and educational outcomes, largely by aligning to the mainstream norms that are sometimes decried as 'Whiteness') can expect to be next in line for the 'anti-racist' hate.
- drekk 5y agoI don't think this conclusion is well supported by the piece or discussion. If you think being against racism is just code for being anti-white there's not much I can say to change that, but when people are used to special treatment equality can feel unfair. I'd certainly be happy to change our admissions process such that it's purely meritocratic (but then remove legacy admissions, which mostly benefit white students). However, this idea that minorities need to "assimilate" into US culture is exactly the kind of racist nonsense that makes us decry the norms as whiteness. A lot of immigrants to the US face direct and indirect violence for things as simple as wearing a hijab. Having to present ourselves in a way that's comfortable for you all to not view us as a stereotype is taxing, especially when these efforts are aggregated as "anti white and anti asian hate" Like what even is anti-white hate when less than a century ago Italians were considered nonwhite? "White" as a social construct only exists to contrast with ethnicities we view as lesser. We should not collapse 300 million Americans into 5 groups (none of which cover those from the middle east) and then base decisions off of such a subjective classification. It's obviously going to cause issues
- zozbot234 5y agoLook, I don't like assimilation either, but it's hard to deny its effectiveness in small, narrowly targeted doses. Aligning with the most critically important values from mainstream society (such as being law-abiding, and focusing on education and public-minded social development) is a recipe for very real success; the opposite values are a recipe for failure. This is not a fact about 'Whiteness'; it's simply about how the social world works.
- tyjen 5y ago
- Gorbzel 5y agoYeah, the author is definitely racially problematic: all her references to Indian/Asian students claim their success is due to merit, hard work and the like (“diligence and ambition”) whereas Hispanic and Black students aren’t suited for “rigorous training in Maths and Science” and are doomed to be dropouts. One only need look at the source publication (a magazine of stories deemed “unheard” by a British oligarch). Skimming Wikipedia, this bit made me laugh: “a magazine publishing people who are generally unheard because people edge away from them at parties." Exactly the case here, except the author felt her oh so privileged voice was silenced because she wasn’t heard at a school boarding meeting…2800 miles away from where she lives. Also, if 70% of the school shares characteristics with you, maybe introducing some diversity isn’t the worst thing in the world. Anecdotally, as a former internship director, I’ve taught many of the students from high schools named in these articles. Ultimately, every student is unique and needs to be considered on a case by case basis. But many of the students who struggle are those with helicopter parents like the author. Through early hard work and ambition they have book smarts or can study, but have never encountered any real setbacks and expect everything to just go their way, which obviously doesn’t happen in the real world. It’s those students who have to struggle, the one the author otherizes in her article and doesn’t want to see in the same school as her kids, that go the farthest.
- zozbot234 5y ago> ...whereas Hispanic and Black students aren’t suited for “rigorous training in Maths and Science” and are doomed to be dropouts. Author says the very opposite: "It also insults and demeans the achievements of black and Hispanic students who get into schools like Lowell and TJ through sacrifice and achievement. The message is clear: stop trying so hard." Where "It" is the new race-biased admissions policy. Please do not make misleading and outrageous claims.
- commandlinefan 5y ago> every student is unique and needs to be considered on a case by case basis But isn't that exactly the opposite of what affirmative action programs demand?
- ryan93 5y ago
- jpgvm 5y agoPeople shouldn't get butt-hurt over this unless they are willing to put the same time and effort in. Asian parents for the most part aren't spending money to guarantee their kids entry into schools like this (though some are), the vast majority are just doing a better job of parenting because they don't have any other option if they want their kids to have a better life than what they came from. I spend a lot of time in Asia so I have come to know many people that have saved up and made the move to Australia or the US in the hopes of giving their kids a better chance in life. They make every sacrifice to this end. Upending their lives, moving away from their social support network (often leaving grandparents behind which is a massive deal for Asian culture). When you understand this it makes much more sense why there is so much pressure on the kids to do well and for the most part they accept that and most come to appreciate it once they are old enough to understand what it cost to get them where they are. It's easy for a bunch of rich white folk to look at a nerdy Asian kid and think they have an unfair advantage but in reality an entire family worth of resources is likely behind that kid, trying to make them the best they can be. Maybe instead of being racist dicks we can learn something from Asian culture here, atleast understand the tradeoffs and don't pretend it's not hard work and time that is powering these results.
- mrcrumb1 5y agoYour comment (and the article) seems to imply that Asian Americans try harder than other immigrant groups and Black people in the United States. Do you think that is a foregone conclusion?
- jimmygrapes 5y agoI'm taking the bait and saying yes, this is absolutely a factor. I will gladly discuss more about why I say this and the underlying issues. Society had spent far too many years dancing around or burying the cultural aspects for fear of stoking "racism" and such. The "ignore it and it will go away" tactic isn't working.
- sniperjoe360 5y agoHi Mr. Crumb, why beat the strawman? He didn't say that and the article didn't either. All he is saying is that Asians try really hard, not that Blacks or other groups are not trying.
- thelock85 5y agoThe author would have a much stronger point if they could point to some failure in these experiments. Historically all non-White children (and many, many poor children regardless of race) were simply barred from great public schools. It took radical experiments like desegregation to open up those doors (admittedly, as a Black man, I’m on the fence about those policies because they led to a massive reduction of the Black teacher workforce). I applaud her taking a stance, but when your best evidence requires you to characterize 8 dropouts as academically-unprepared, despite having zero knowledge on those students situation, then it just comes off as fear. The author suggests as much in the very last sentence. Sadly, fear of what’s potentially lost has always and will continue to keep us from establishing any significant parity in our public education system.
- zozbot234 5y agoDesegregation was not an 'experiment', it was a simple legally-mandated fix for a broken situation. These days we have basically re-segregated our schools along income lines by forbidding school choice and enforcing the educational monopoly of the school district. And when people try to fix this by starting better-run charter and/or magnet schools, these efforts are basically sabotaged by the public education establishment as seen in this very article.
- drekk 5y agoCharter schools were used to get out of legally mandated de-segregation. If we want a better education system there's no shortcut. You need a well funded, equitable public education system. We're the outliers in the industrial world here. Look at school lunches as just a baseline comparison of what fuel we give our children and then imagine all of the lacking supplies we force teachers and parents to purchase. The issue is we determine funding for them based on zip code. Poor schools get less funding. Isn't that ass-backwards? All the elites get to enjoy wonderful districts or private options they can afford and the public gets stuck with textbooks from the 50s.
- zozbot234 5y ago
- mesozoic 5y ago
- joeman1000 5y agoIt’s all racism in the end, whether it’s positive or negative racism. Admissions should be completely unaware of applicant race. The only truly fair admission should be based on academic merit alone. Asians being discriminated against? Welcome to the ‘white’ club, enjoy your painful stay. Honestly, what else could happen? To boost one cohort you must cut another down. I assume they can’t reject any more white people, so Asian people are next in line for higher admissions standards. The whole thing is shit and truly unbiased admissions are the only way forward. No-one should be promoted or demoted based on race.
- tcyrus 5y agoI've heard that a lot of parents don't like the current principal of the school (TJHSST) for a multitude of reasons. I wouldn't be surprised if those quotes are accurate. As for everything else, I feel like things aren't as clear cut as the post portrays it as.