3 ms·
In all honesty, I disagree entirely. I see innovative stuff all the time. It strikes me that if you treat everything innovative with cynicism you can state it i
by renewiltord 5y ago
In all honesty, I disagree entirely. I see innovative stuff all the time. It strikes me that if you treat everything innovative with cynicism you can state it in that way:
- antibiotics: just better drugs
- GMO crops or the Green Revolution: just being more deliberate about what people did for thousands of years
- going to space: we can barely go under the sea, this is just that but up
- the Internet: phones, you've invented phones
- phones: talking to people, you've invented talking
- talking: just grunting with more sounds
There is a lot of wonderful stuff going on in the world, but if you filter to stuff you can dismiss, you're just going to see everything as worthless.
This is a common thing a lot of people find really hard to understand. A good critic isn't one who places the bar so high that nothing meets it. A good critic is one who can separate exceptional from mundane. If nothing is exceptional, it is likely the problem is that you're not good at determining whether something is. Just in a Bayesian sense, if your barometer says it's 1 atm literally everywhere, more likely the barometer is broken than that pressure has equalized everywhere in the universe.
- mschuster91 5y ago> - antibiotics: just better drugs We haven't had a single new class of antibiotics discovered for well over 30 years [1]. And now, especially since humanity was dumb enough to use reserve antibiotics in farm animals, we're looking at a disaster. [1]: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-02884-3 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-02884-3
- renewiltord 5y ago"Antibiotics are just the same as the 2000 year old mould remedies employed in Ancient Egypt or India. Mould, you've invented mould." Haha! This is such an entertaining technique. I can see why people talk like this. It's pointlessly dismissive.