3 ms·
I think part of it was that Poland is more or less ethnically homogenous. Many in Russia are indigenous or semi-indigenous people native to various localities
by throwaway290 5y ago
I think part of it was that Poland is more or less ethnically homogenous.
Many in Russia are indigenous or semi-indigenous people native to various localities in the very sparsely populated Siberia, and they do not even speak Russian as their first language. They routinely get searched at subway entrances and receive looks if they so much as take a walk on a street in St. Petersburg because they look Asian.
Now imagine they were asked to rise together with the people who scorned them all these years in order to protest an invasion waged by a dictator they did not elect against another ethnically Slavic population.
So we basically exclude those.
Whomever remains needs to rise and risk being imprisoned or beaten either by the police or by brainwashed fellow citizens.
Addendum: I would cheer for them, but I do not have enough national pride to quit my job, return to the country and join them.
- jacquesm 5y agoWell, in a way that is the point here: exactly those people are the ones sent to the frontlines to 'die for mother Russia' when they actually really have zero skin in the game. But it allows the cosmopolitan part of the Russian population to pretend that there are no losses, because as long as it's only 'little Russians' dying it doesn't seem to matter to them. They are as much a victim here, but still they are victims on the very, very wrong side of this war. Some of those kids captured by the Ukrainians are likely not even 18 and are clearly from the far eastern part of Russia. And that is also why I don't think there will be an uprising in Russia: the cosmopolitans will find it easier to believe the propaganda than to rise up because effectively they can make themselves believe this isn't their war. Yet.
- throwaway290 5y agoWas not aware of the fact that many of the conscripts were from that vicinity… I need to reassess. (Edit: you were right, getting similar information from some friends.)
- jacquesm 5y agoThank you for the respectful interchange, much appreciated. I wonder at what level of the military hierarchy you will start to see a 'Western' Russian majority.
- throwaway290 5y agoThank you as well. I don't know, I know exceedingly little about Russian military. I did not serve. Every time I am slightly hopeful, I am again disheartened by how brainwashed people can be. Apparently, among the ethnic minorities sent to Ukraine some do indeed support Putin. My parents grew up in USSR, were aware of repressions and the Tiananmen uprising, and shared this sentiment with me when I was growing up. However, I know some others imbued their kids with nostalgic feelings about the Soviet Union. When and where I went to school, teachers were more or less independent about how history was taught. These days I hear there are military parades and strong ideological side. Some people overcome this, but an average person may not be equipped to live a normal life constantly filtering propaganda and questioning everything they see or hear in the media, maintaining independent thought and internal distrust towards vocally expressed opinions by people of status. Especially someone well-integrated, with a mostly positive childhood and no major trust issues.