3 ms·
I bear responsibility because I happened to be born in the wrong country, OK. Will tell this to my mom if Russia is not disconnected tomorrow and I can still c
by throwaway290 5y ago
I bear responsibility because I happened to be born in the wrong country, OK. Will tell this to my mom if Russia is not disconnected tomorrow and I can still call her.
- jacquesm 5y agoEmotional appeals do not mix well with logic. Yes, you do have a responsibility. Yes, it is sad that you may not be able to reach your mom. But that is as nothing compared to having your home bombarded out from under you. Meanwhile, I take it that you are donating to doctors without borders and the Ukrainian defense forces to make the point that you too disagree with this war?
- throwaway290 5y agoThe sad thing is not the inability for me to reach my mom, but that I have to blame her for giving birth to me on the territory of Russia. I donated $150 to UNHCR's Ukraine emergency the day the invasion started, but I am cautious to do this again because my bank may become unreliable and I should have cash to be able to eat in short term. I do not even have a reason to use a Russian bank, but 2019 sanctions made all pre-paid debit plastic providers quit anyone with a Russian address; meaning I cannot accept money from a non-Russian customer to spend it outside of Russia except via a Russian bank, being a freelancer not rich enough to own property overseas and have a verifiable non-Russian address. Addendum: I am envious of fellow Chinese freelancers, who happened to be born in a country which is not at war now and thus enjoys more favorable attitudes even as they can freely express their support for Xi and deny Tiananmen (and I do not fault them for it, since they were born in a country where they cannot choose what to think).
- jacquesm 5y agoThank you. It is very very hard to surgically hit the Russian elite without also hitting the ordinary Russians. The problem with most of the sanctions is that the Russian elite won't care about them, but ordinary Russians are impacted greatly. This is as far as I can see unsolvable: sanctions are the 'soft' step prior to war, skipping it would be madness, if anything it shows the Russian leaders that the West is serious about this. In the West people typically have no idea what it is like to live under a dictatorship regime. But there are some examples of how even in such countries major change was effected through mass protests. The chances of that materializing are very, very small. My own hope is that Putin's inner circle will decide to throw him under the bus rather than to risk a one way trip to the Hague. Right now they can still claim it was all Putin, if they wait another week their fate is sealed. Russia had a fantastic chance to become a better country in the early 90's, they completely blew that and became a kleptocracy instead. So now we have mobsters with atomic weapons, and this is the predictable result.
- throwaway290 5y agoI support the notion that Putin has to go, violently or not, but when I hear suggestions to start an uprising I can not help but ask: would you suggest the same to people who went on Tiananmen in 1989 and got reduced to a bloody mess? Considering it is A) not your nor your children's lives on the line, and B) your country, presumably, is now just fine transacting with the regime that did the above. As you wrote, emotional appeals do not mix well with logic -- but maybe dry logic is possible only from afar.
- jacquesm 5y agoI'm somewhere in the middle. I've lived through the Solidarnosc uprising in Poland so I know for a fact that it is possible to make a change, at the same time I'm sure that that could have ended in a completely different way as well. It all hinges on how afraid the people are of the dictator, once that fear is gone the dictator is gone. But to get there it can be very, very bloody. Cornered rats will have no other option but to fight. So, while I think the Russian people could have a role I don't think that will materialize.
- throwaway290 5y agoI think part of it was that Poland is more or less ethnically homogenous. Many in Russia are indigenous or semi-indigenous people native to various localities in the very sparsely populated Siberia, and they do not even speak Russian as their first language. They routinely get searched at subway entrances and receive looks if they so much as take a walk on a street in St. Petersburg because they look Asian. Now imagine they were asked to rise together with the people who scorned them all these years in order to protest an invasion waged by a dictator they did not elect against another ethnically Slavic population. So we basically exclude those. Whomever remains needs to rise and risk being imprisoned or beaten either by the police or by brainwashed fellow citizens. Addendum: I would cheer for them, but I do not have enough national pride to quit my job, return to the country and join them.
- 5y ago