3 ms·
This is the “lump of labor fallacy”. You can’t just talk about supply and demand with labor because people are customers and generate their own demand. And it
by astrange 5y ago
This is the “lump of labor fallacy”. You can’t just talk about supply and demand with labor because people are customers and generate their own demand.
And it certainly does come from labor costs; services like healthcare naturally get relatively even more expensive as everything else becomes more productive, because you have to pay the healthcare workers more to stop them from leaving for more productive industries. (Baumol’s cost disease)
- rightbyte 5y agoI worked a short while on a Esta -- not allowed really but the tax office didn't complain -- in SF making more money as a new grad (6k USD/month + housing) than I will ever make where I live. Later I realized I was acctually wage dumping ... Make no mistake what would happen if there was a free flow of programmers to the US. "We" will undercut the locals.
- astrange 5y agoYes, I would make even more money than I already do because I’d sell goods and services to them, and I could address unmet demand from our existing customers. Surely even under the immigration is bad model, it wouldn’t apply to programmers who can do their work remotely. Our having a Beijing team hasn’t made me less employed.
- rightbyte 5y agoSure, I don't really understand how there can be such a pay discrepancy even inside the US for such a remote friendly occupation as programming. So I am not pretending to understand the dynamics. Entry level jobs would be swamped though. Like for local kids in London when UK was part of the EU. Like half the kids in the union could speak english good enough and many thought it would be cool to work in London. Good luck raising a family on a normal job when compeeting with people that happely live packed in an apartment for some years before bailing the city for raising families themself in their home countries. I know like half a dozen friends who did that.
- astrange 5y agoYou wouldn't be living five to an apartment or wishing you weren't if London had sensible housing policy like Tokyo does. Doesn't every single building in the UK need individual planning approval? Also, London is expensive but the rest of the UK isn't, which by the cheap immigrant logic should mean the rural areas would outcompete them for everything, surely?
- rightbyte 5y agoAs I wrote earlier I have no clue =) However, I feel like it is way easier to get a job in e.g. London or SF since it is unsubstainable to live there for most people so there is a big churn. In smaller UK villages you can probably live a good life working at Subway doing sandwiches. Not so much in London. So you wont get the small village Subway job becouse the current holder does not quit. E.g. when I lived in Palo Alto I noticed a big lack of children so I assume you need to be rich to afford living there with them. So newcommers get the newly made parents jobs and so on.
- unglaublich 5y agoBaumol's cost disease does not apply if there is oversupply of labor. See again low-skilled workers. Where are the 'rises in pay' for those working at fast-food, supermarket chains, warehouses, etc.? Also, labor over-supply will only increase since not only immigration, but also automation will compete with workers. Automation and immigration can be good things, but only if we provide everyone with a basic income to put them in a position where they actually have a choice to work or not.
- astrange 5y ago> Baumol's cost disease does not apply if there is oversupply of labor. More or less purely a symptom of bad monetary policy the US stopped doing around 2018. > See again low-skilled workers. Where are the 'rises in pay' for those working at fast-food, supermarket chains, warehouses, etc.? They have increased significantly above inflation in the last year because we're in a full employment economy. (While other classes may have had pay losses depending on how much they spend on gas/used cars, the lowest quartile definitely hasn't.) > Also, labor over-supply will only increase since not only immigration, but also automation will compete with workers. If you noticed, Andrew Yang lost the election. His automation platform was a myth, caused by our previous non-full-employment economy - there is no actual situation where it can destroy jobs. Either it requires inputs, so there is work to do there, or it doesn't, so it's a perpetual motion machine. (You can tell "rich people fire everyone and replace them with robots" can't actually happen because it's basically the plot of The Fountainhead.) Another interesting theory about the myth is that it's an accounting artifact caused by Moore's law - if we report computer production in units of computation speed, that means each factory worker is producing a zillion 70s computers a second, which makes it look like they've been automated out of a job. Countries with less immigration and worse age demographics (Russia, China, Japan) may need to develop automation though, since they'll need someone to take care of all of our old people. We will hopefully continue allowing immigration from Africa, soon to be the only region still producing young people.
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoAustralia's point system assures that you don't just let any useless immigrant in but only the ones with qualifications. In a highly advanced economy even a basic nurse has 4 years of training- and speak the language. We don't just need warm bodies.