7 ms·
> Hold up, the costs of all these services you mention does NOT come from labor cost. I don't know if that is actually true, but if it is there'd have to be a
by roenxi 5y ago
> Hold up, the costs of all these services you mention does NOT come from labor cost.
I don't know if that is actually true, but if it is there'd have to be a pretty strong "and who's fault is that?" to ask. Housing is capital intensive, but medical care, education & child care can all be provided with basically nothing but labour and a dash of equipment.
Assuming a fairly free market where people are allowed to compete, anyway. If competition is illegal then whoever has the licenses will charge wages + a lot.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThere is tremendous capital expense in medical care. Extremely highly educated and well trained doctors do not materialize out of thin air. The mechanisms of human bodies is extremely complex, and requires ever more capital as society’s expectations of “healthcare” continue to march upward. 1950s level of healthcare is cheap. 2022 level of medicine, machinery, the R&D to be able to see inside of a body, the thousands of hours of training to read and understand statistics, measurements, and imaging, etc is incalculable. All sprinkled with a heavy dose of financial liability for all parties involved. There are similar arguments to be made for childcare and education.
- roenxi 5y agoIn the context of labour costs vs other costs? Most of that comes in as labour costs. It is paying humans money to spend time doing things. The high prices of healthcare aren't because of the expensive machines; the production of that can be outsourced, they're relatively long-lifed and they don't consume a lot of physical inputs.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe lines get blurry on labor vs capital costs when intellectual property comes into play. But I would model a doctor spending hundreds of thousands of dollars on education and 10 years of their life in the capital column. You cannot spin them up and down, and for better or worse, that much investment into a person is basically permanent from a country perspective. The machines also require very highly skilled people to develop, with enormous R&D costs, same as medicines. Maybe instead of capital costs, it would have been more accurate for me to write that the labor being bought and sold in the 1950s is nowhere near the same labor being bought and sold in 2022.
- diordiderot 5y agoWe have tens of thousand of people who have passed med school and could become doctors if supply wasn't artificially constrained. >highly educated and well trained doctors do not materialize out of thin air. Education could be cheaper
- lotsofpulp 5y agoFor sure, the current process is needlessly lengthy and strenuous and needs to reform. But even with improvements, I expect full fledged doctors to require quite an investment in training.
- unglaublich 5y agoHousing is only capital expensive mostly because of land value, which comes from scarcity. Again, more folks will only raise the cost, since land is in extremely low supply due to NIMBY, regulation, and people sitting on their land as an investment. The actual construction costs are fairly low compared to land prices (e.g., 1 part construction to 2 parts land cost, or worse [1]). [1]: https://www.urbanismnext.org/news/land-costs-vs-construction-costs-a-clue-to-overall-project-impacts https://www.urbanismnext.org/news/land-costs-vs-construction...