5 ms·
Do we have to make this joke every single time anything WebAssembly comes up. We get it Write Once Run Anywhere was done before.
by panick21_ 5y ago
Do we have to make this joke every single time anything WebAssembly comes up. We get it Write Once Run Anywhere was done before.
- pjmlp 5y agoYes, because most WebAssembly advocacy knowingly ignores the past to sell their agenda. It isn't only Java, bytecode as execution format goes all the way back to late 1950's, Gosling quite clearly asserts the work that Java builds upon, contrary to the WebAssembly folks. https://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=1017013 https://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=1017013 "Back when I was a grad student at Carnegie Mellon, I had this problem where I needed to have some kind of an architecture-neutral distribution format. We had a bunch of workstations called PERQ machines. The folks who built them were a bunch of hardware guys who didn’t want to do software. The only compiler that they could get for free was UCSD (University of California San Diego) Pascal. So they made the hardware interpret UCSD Pascal p-codes. My thesis advisor, Raj Reddy, asked me to spend the summer trying to figure out how to get the software from these PERQ machines to run on our VAXs. I started out writing a little hardware emulator, just to understand the p-codes. Then I realized I could actually write a code-generating program that translated from Pascal p-codes to VAX assembly code. So I wrote a hardware emulator for the PERQ machine that did hardware emulation by translating, and I spent a bunch of time trying to figure out why it was that the translation actually worked. One of the things that I noticed was that the code that I was getting at was actually better than the code that was coming out of the C compiler. I was quite floored by how well it worked, and I spent a bunch of time thinking about what it was about p-code that actually made it work, versus trying to do this for some other instruction set. Then fast-forward a bunch of years, when I was trying to do the project that Java came out of. I had to do this architecture-neutral distribution format, and then I just went ka-ching! You know, this p-code translator thing would actually just drop in there." As another example of hidden agenda, most WebAssembly sales also ignore PNaCL and CrossBridge, only mentioning asmjs as previous art.
- hunterb123 5y agoI used Java on web and PNaCL quite heavily, but I also love WASM. Mainly WASM is open, those others not so much. But I don't understand, you make the Java joke because previous attempts aren't recognized enough? There's plenty of blog posts about transitioning from them, Chromium (the only ones who implemented PNaCL) did one, as did others.
- pjmlp 5y agoNot only Java, there are a pool of similar ignored technology all the way back to late 1950's. There are plenty of WebAssembly articles selling it as being the first kind of bytecode to support C like languages.
- hunterb123 5y agoMany articles for many topics are ignorant or plain wrong. That doesn't detract from the technology itself, which is great.
- pjmlp 5y agoGreat at reinventing the wheel.
- hunterb123 5y agoThe other wheels weren't round enough.
- panick21_ 5y agoNobody ever claimed it was new. It wasn't new when Java tried it. And the actual Web-Assembly developers don't ignore that stuff. And even if they did so what? Re-inventing the wheel is common and sometimes something good and new comes out of it.
- pjmlp 5y agoAh but they do claim, that is the big different to the Java authors. Something good like re-inventing EAR files.
- panick21_ 5y agoPlease show me text by actual core developers that claim something is 100% new that isn't. And I'm not talking about some random articles you find with googling. And btw, not mentioning prior art doesn't count.
- pjmlp 5y agoSo it is only valid if it fits your view of the world, won't bother.
- panick21_ 5y agoWhat are you even talking about. I asked you directly to show me evidence of the claims you made, nothing else.
- pjmlp 5y ago"And I'm not talking about some random articles you find with googling. And btw, not mentioning prior art doesn't count." Tainted evidences, you ask. Me no bother.
- panick21_ 5y agoSo really you have no evidece at all, you are just generally angry at everybody who is involved with WebAssembly because they don't site your work and that makes you bitter. Got it.