3 ms·
"or other 2nd-factor" includes another WebAuthn factor. This is one of the things that bothered people about login.gov before, they're like "But I already have
by tialaramex 5y ago
"or other 2nd-factor" includes another WebAuthn factor. This is one of the things that bothered people about login.gov before, they're like "But I already have a Security Key, what other factor can I use?". Another security key is fine, they're each independent factors, it just wants to make you won't lose your only route in to the site.
My login.gov has my two Security Keys plus my phone (a Pixel 2, via WebAuthn) as possible second factors. You can indeed choose TOTP, or use a Government ID (a few million people have Federal jobs with IDs) and if you must yes you can use SMS
So if you need better security, just don't choose the weaker options.
Suddenly that goes from "automated attack launched by a school kid on the far side of an ocean" to "Government black bag job", and it's enough that most people should sleep soundly.
Also, the other benefit of Security Keys as an option is that we can teach users that their Security Key is safe, because it can't be phished. That exercise where you try to train users to check they're on the right domain and realistically you know adversaries will confuse or terrify them into skipping that step? No need with Security Keys, that's the Web Browser's job and the browser isn't confused or terrified, it's just calling memcmp() as it does many times every page load.