3 ms·
I agree that the MAX design should have been fully redundant. But the only reason there are pilots at all on an airliner is to deal with the unexpected. I was
by WalterBright 5y ago
I agree that the MAX design should have been fully redundant.
But the only reason there are pilots at all on an airliner is to deal with the unexpected.
I was told about one case where the elevator actuators froze in the slightly nose up position. The pilot called the cabin, and asked everyone to pack themselves into the front. With that he managed to bring enough pitch control to land it safely, but it surely was a terrifying ordeal for everyone on board.
(The actuators froze because of water buildup turning to ice at altitude. Actuators are now heavily designed and tested with freezing water. The stab trim test for this was quite thorough - the motors were very powerful and the ice scrapers on the nut would just peel the ice off. I also enlarged the drain holes in my car doors to Boeing spec so water wouldn't build up in them and rust.)