4 ms·
some people working in the field said it wasn't proven to be graphene (disagreement on methodology basically) and that it wasn't replicated
by agumonkey 5y ago
some people working in the field said it wasn't proven to be graphene (disagreement on methodology basically) and that it wasn't replicated
- AdrianEGraphene 5y agoSpent my PhD on this and can confirm. Tour's brilliant. Part of his brilliance is in leveraging hot topics to secure funding, increase his status as an expert, and ultimately give young minds the chance to push the field of carbon study forward. Academics have to play the game. It is not technically graphene due to the multicrysal + variable layer formation. You can search my user name in google scholar to see my publications.
- agumonkey 5y agothanks for pitching in do you know any good places to read, or sites to follow about graphene research ? I was interested in the flash joule thing to play with conductive ink or insulations..
- MrDunham 5y agoAny chance you have a source or reference to the people who disagreed? Not trying to snark, I’m genuinely interested in seeing the counter arguments. Thanks
- murphyslab 5y agoThere are a few ways that it might not be "graphene". First, it probably isn't monolayer, but rather variable layer numbers, so practically speaking... it's probably graphite. Second, there is likely to be a lot of defects. So you don't get the full strength that you would find with single crystal exfoliated or epitaxially grown graphene. Still, I would imagine that a method like this could be useful, particularly if you were building a colony off-world. You don't need high-quality graphene for making composites for construction.
- agumonkey 5y agoIt was on a graphene subreddit long ago (r/graphene or r/graphene_DIY .. not sure). The guy said something like "the methodology doesn't measure or assess the graphene type produced". I can't find who or what thread it was sorry. He didn't explain in details saying telling more would be intellectual property breach and that a lot of companies are searching for flash joule like techniques and if they were working they'd be in use yesterday.