4 ms·
Russia doesn't have a big track military track record in recent years, but there's one thing that they have proven to do really well: leveling a city to the gro
by littlestymaar 5y ago
Russia doesn't have a big track military track record in recent years, but there's one thing that they have proven to do really well: leveling a city to the ground while slaughtering the civilians who didn't flee.
Having the Ukrainian legitimate government agree to surrender to save Kiev (or “just” Khariv) from such a fate isn't completely impossible to imagine. And giving infantry weapons isn't going to be enough to stop Putin from doing so if he wanted. I don't know how many FОАВ[1] the Russian air force has at its disposal, but Javelin aren't gonna help against that…
And after this hypothetical surrender from the Ukrainian government, setting up a bloody dictatorship with a special police arresting, torturing and executing whoever is suspected to belong to the insurgency, relying on pro-russian locals to provide intelligence is not an impossible feat unfortunately…
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Father_of_All_Bombs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Father_of_All_Bombs
- simonh 5y agoThat thing is only really useful against static, or near static high value targets. Against insurgents dispersed across the countryside with Javelins the weapon itself is effectively useless while the aircraft delivering it is still vulnerable.
- senko 5y agoI think the implication is it might be used against civilian population in a city.
- littlestymaar 5y ago> That thing is only really useful against static, or near static high value targets. Exactly, like the the capital of your country for instance. Noting that I'm not talking about defeating an insurgency with it, just overthrow the legitimate government and put a pro-russian dictatorship in charge. Exterminating the insurgents would then be the job of the local dictator. Obviously it's not guaranteed, but torture, kidnapping, and assassination have proven an effective mean of counter-insurgency… In real life the bad guy sometimes win…
- simonh 5y agoIm was addressing it's usefulness in the situation suggested. Yes it is useful in other situations, as I pointed out.
- truffdog 5y agoFallujah and Mosul were pretty bad in terms of city levelling. We just don't like to remember them, or think about depleted uranium dust causing birth defects, or what happened to the refugees, or a million other things.
- littlestymaar 5y agoYou can't just compare Fallujah and Grozny. Of course urban warfare is destructive to the city no matter what, but the US and Russian tactics are very different, and so is the destruction. Dropping tons of low precision thermobaric weapons on a city is a Russian thing, unmatched in its destruction. (The is no American equivalent to the TOS-1[1] for instance). That being said, that doesn't mean I approve US invasion of Irak in any way (because I do not), it just feels you're comparing Pearl Harbor with Stalingrad… (Ok, not literally, because there is a two orders of magnitude difference between Pearl Harbor and Stalingrad, but you get the idea). [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TOS-1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TOS-1
- truffdog 5y agoI was thinking about Syria, not Chechnya, since that's a more recent major conflict with city captures that the Russians have participated in.
- eternalban 5y ago> You can't just compare Fallujah and Grozny. That's a fair statement. Depleted Uranium is a gift that keeps on giving. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/us-depleted-uranium-as-ma_b_3812888 https://www.huffpost.com/entry/us-depleted-uranium-as-ma_b_3... https://www.nuclear-risks.org/en/hibakusha-worldwide/fallujah.html https://www.nuclear-risks.org/en/hibakusha-worldwide/falluja... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depleted_uranium#Iraqi_population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depleted_uranium#Iraqi_populat...
- littlestymaar 5y agoThere not discussion that DU has terrible long term impact, of course it has. The US aren't “good guys” who don't hurt civilians, nobody is arguing that! Yet, “in terms of city leveling” Fallujah and Grozny are not comparable. That's it.
- oblio 5y agoThe thing is, once they do that, they'll cross another one of those imaginary lines. And the sanctions Russia is under will be nothing like the ones that will be heaped on top. Europe is highly sensitive about local conflicts, especially after what happened to Srebrenica. Grozny didn't really count since it was: a) an internal war b) at the end of Europe If Putin flattens a major European city (for Europe any city above ~2m or so is major), the outrage in Europe will be huge. Even bigger than it is now.
- gitfan86 5y agoWe have not seen what the Germany Army is capable of since 80 years ago. Does Putin really want to find out what has changed since then?
- oblio 5y agoThe German Army isn't capable of much at the moment. And even if it were, no NATO member will set foot in Ukraine while this war and the following insurgency are happening. What will happen is, depending on how hard Putin pushes, the reaction will be just as strong. More attacks targeting civilians? More weapons sent to Ukraine. Harder sanctions, with actual teeth. I wouldn't be shocked if by next winter 60%+ of the gas supply for Western Europe will be covered from other vendors, more or less bankrupting Russia (a huge percentage of Russian exports are raw materials, primarily oil and gas).
- ghostwriter 5y ago> I wouldn't be shocked if by next winter 60%+ of the gas supply for Western Europe will be covered from other vendors, more or less bankrupting Russia you will be shocked to discover that Russia is going to fuel China's economy instead [1] [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-02-28/gazprom-paves-way-to-new-china-gas-deal-as-sanctions-hit-russia https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-02-28/gazprom-p...
- cmurf 5y ago
- gitfan86 5y agoRussia has claimed that the mission is to liberate Ukraine from Nazis, which is why you see videos of unarmed civilians not being immediately run over by trucks. If the mission changes to kill as many civilians as possible, the army is going to have an even worse morale problem and the international community will come up with a creative solution like giving part of Poland to Ukraine, giving Ukrainian citizenship to anyone within that part of Poland and then launching attacks with all the military resources that just happen to now be in Ukraine.
- littlestymaar 5y ago> Russia has claimed that the mission is to liberate Ukraine from Nazis, which is why you see videos of unarmed civilians not being immediately run over by trucks. > If the mission changes to kill as many civilians as possible, the army is going to have an even worse morale problem I agree. This is indeed one of the biggest challenge the Russian army will face if they decide to do so. > the international community will come up with a creative solution like giving part of Poland to Ukraine, giving Ukrainian citizenship to anyone within that part of Poland and then launching attacks with all the military resources that just happen to now be in Ukraine. This is hilarious, I love it. Never gonna happen, but I love the creativity here. This is “thinking out of the box”.
- brimble 5y agoThe more realistic "creative use of borders" I anticipate is citing historic claims of (mostly) Poland to carve off a big chunk of Ukraine in the West into a new state, and put it under explicit or implied ("just try and see what happens") NATO protection. I don't expect that unless Russia starts having a lot more success, though, and both they and Ukraine start to signal that they might accept a partition of the country to end hostilities. [EDIT] Further caveat that it'd have to be before substantial Russian ground forces reach that part of the country. This is still a low-likelihood scenario, but certainly far more likely than declaring part of Poland to be in Ukraine (?!)
- dantyti 5y ago>why you see videos of unarmed civilians not being immediately run over by trucks. starting to see videos of explosives being lobbed at unarmed people. These do not seem like crowd-control munitions: https://twitter.com/aldin_ww/status/1499059624250646538 https://twitter.com/aldin_ww/status/1499059624250646538 On a more historic note, it took the Soviets a couple of days before they ran over people with tanks during the January Events in Vilnius: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_Events_(Lithuania)#Timeline_of_events https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_Events_(Lithuania)#Tim... note how they also claimed it was acting against a "nationalist" (equivalent to "nazi" in the USSR) government.