2 ms·
login.gov does allow you to have FIDO2 setup without a phone number — my account currently only has hardware tokens — but I think you want to look backwards fro
by acdha 5y ago
login.gov does allow you to have FIDO2 setup without a phone number — my account currently only has hardware tokens — but I think you want to look backwards from the challenges of supporting a service like this. If you're serving the general public, people reliably lose their tokens and you can't require them in general since multiple $20 tokens is a complete non-starter so there's a lot of appeal to things like SMS which don't require additional purchases.
The other question I'd ask is how bad SMS really is: it's definitely not great from a security perspective but for the average person it seems unlikely that they're worse off from having it. Maybe we can start phasing that out now that common clients have integrated WebAuthn support (e.g. Apple's FaceID/TouchID for the web) but if you have to support the general public you probably have a different threat model than a more targeted audience.