6 ms·
Basically, every growth figure of the language shows otherwise. Oracle is ain’t saints, but the amount of needless bashing it gets here is astonishing. Regardl
by kaba0 5y ago
Basically, every growth figure of the language shows otherwise. Oracle is ain’t saints, but the amount of needless bashing it gets here is astonishing.
Regardless of what its other branches are doing, Oracle managed to do one of the smoothest language takeovers where the (stellar) core team is virtually unchanged, the language became completely open sourced and it underwent tremendous changes which resulted in huge growths after the slowdown at the end of the Sun era.
Note: I am not working at Oracle and never have.
- tomrod 5y agoI feel like it's warranted. The calculus seems to be evaluation of positive impact on the world as a whole versus success of transition/acquisition.
- scarmig 5y agoPeople always love to invent mythic narratives about a golden age that was betrayed by its lesser descendents. It can be the Greeks mythologizing their ancestors, Marxists bemoaning how Stalin betrayed Lenin's legacy, or Java/Solaris partisans hating on Oracle. The fact that the acquisition cast off a bunch of brilliant, distinguished, charismatic engineers who have every reason to further the mythmaking also plays into why we hear so much of it. But to give credit where it's due, it's given us this esteemable gem of a rant: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zRN7XLCRhc&t=33m https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zRN7XLCRhc&t=33m
- ModernMech 5y agoOh my God that was epic. Ellison as lawnmower is spot on.
- ModernMech 5y ago> but the amount of needless bashing it gets here is astonishing I don't think it's needless. I'll bash Java as long as it's the language for AP computer science. Imagine a budding young programmer, bright eyed and bushy tailed, eager to get into computer science. They get to class and greet the teacher "Welcome class, let's learn about Java. There's a wide world of computers out there, but your perception of computing will be that Computing <-> Java until maybe the sophomore year of college. Have fun!" Students come to me their sophomore year of college completely awestruck. "I had not idea! I thought programming was all Java!" they tell me. Imagine that. Close your eyes and picture a world where all of programming is Java programming. How quick did you open them and splash water on your face to wake rid yourself from that nightmare? Java is singlehandedly responsible for snuffing the dream of so many young programmers. I've seen it in my own research, where kids in elemntary and middle school describe programming as fun, interesting, and challenging. That's because at this age they're using fun languages like Blockly, and they spend their time programming making and playing games. Then they get to AP computer science and they are introduced to Java. Perceptions of programming fall through the floor, with more students calling it difficult, frustrating, and scary. It's tragic what Java is doing to young people. Like, I understand we want students to have skills they will use in business, but we can't present programming to them as if all of programming is OOP enterprise development in Java. It's a crying shame.
- hulitu 5y agoTell that to Google.
- baud147258 5y ago> "I thought programming was all Java!" If students get this preconception, I think it's more an issue how they are taught, not an issue with Java itself. I mean the first language I learned and most of my classes were in Java, but that didn't prevent me from knowing there other existing languages and learning about them.
- baud147258 5y agothough, on retrospect, I can admit that Java might not be the best language to learn programming
- mahesh-hegde 5y agoTeaching Java in abstract, useless lessons about OOP and inheritance is definitely bad. But I would say Java is as good a first language as python is. The purpose of first programming language is teaching concepts - functions, structs / classes, abstraction, data structures (importantly lists and maps); And how to solve problems using that. Python does well in intuitive syntax for lists/maps, handy standard library functions, and having an REPL; But it gives an illusion that types are redundant. The programmer picking up C++ or Java after python sees only ceremony. You can also learn the modern java without all the OOP shoved in: Basic programs, functions, data types, arrays, using classes to create custom types, using HashMap, ArrayList, HashSet from standard library; then interfaces, inheritance / subtyping, lambda functions. Use jshell to try small snippets; The problem with teachers teaching java is that they focus too much on inheritance, with mostly superficial examples like "dog extends animal" instead of something in real world. Inheritance is mostly about subtyping, and any CS student with enough math background should not struggle to understand that.
- blarg1 5y agoI still have nightmares from back then.
- 5y ago