3 ms·
"The skin biopsy is especially objective and cannot be explained away as psychosomatic." Just to point out, by definition psychosomatic illnesses result in phy
by giantg2 5y ago
"The skin biopsy is especially objective and cannot be explained away as psychosomatic."
Just to point out, by definition psychosomatic illnesses result in physical (soma) changes that would still be observable in an objective measure. An example would be longterm depression restructuring the brain or suppressing the immune system.
So the change has been objectively observed. The mechanism causing it would still need to be determined to classify it as strictly physical or psychosomatic, although it does rule it out as being strictly psychological.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoI suppose some people will find ways to dismiss anything, but the idea that small fiber neuropathy could objectively occur in multiple patients due to psychosomatic illness when it has never been observed in any other mental health issue should be enough to dismiss the idea entirely.
- giantg2 5y agoShould we also dismiss the idea that longterm depression restructures the brain or suppresses the immune system just because it hasn't been found in other mental health issues? Just because something hasn't been found elsewhere doesn't mean it should be casually linked. We need to see the underlying mechanism.