2 ms·
What do you mean by merit? Meritocracy is not about some kind of moral desert; it's a really, really inconvenient practice we put up with nonetheless (all those
by zozbot234 5y ago
What do you mean by merit? Meritocracy is not about some kind of moral desert; it's a really, really inconvenient practice we put up with nonetheless (all those tests and credentials are no walk in the park!) because we think that higher-levels of responsibility (which are naturally well compensated) should be given to people with the most appropriate level of skills and competence, which are only developed via strenuous effort. One can say that the 2nd kid deserves to be helped just as much as anyone else in a similar social situation, but as a matter of fact they are surely not more competent.
- Miner49er 5y agoThat makes sense in some situations, but when looking for school applicants, wouldn't you want the student with the most promise?
- sokoloff 5y agoFor entrance exams for Thomas Jefferson Magnet High School, my answer is aligned with yours. For college admission? My answer is way more aligned with GP's. At some point theoretical potential must turn into demonstrated competence for it to have value and be rewarded. If that hasn't happened by SAT time, I'm betting against it happening in specifically the next 4 years.