3 ms·
> "The law of unintended consequences" ... what are they going to do if the target demographic (in this case Asians) start their own merit-based and academic-ba
by shadowgovt 5y ago
> "The law of unintended consequences" ... what are they going to do if the target demographic (in this case Asians) start their own merit-based and academic-based colleges and universities?
You're asking what people would do if those who couldn't get into university address the issue by building a new university, thereby increasing supply?
"Celebrate," I'd assume.
- yardstick 5y agoWould they though? I suspect they would want to apply non-merit/academic based policies to the new institutions too.
- lelanthran 5y ago> You're asking what people would do if those who couldn't get into university address the issue by building a new university, thereby increasing supply? No, I am asking what you would do if the people discriminated against built their own power structures (out of necessity) that, due to merit, was disproportionately made up of members of their community AND produced superior results for their graduates. Right now many people are basically ranting that Asians are performing too well, leading them to succeed well above other $GROUP. What do you think those people will say if the discriminated group sets up structures that further reinforce their success in succeeding generations? Segregation resulting from discriminating against a particular minority to the level that they go ahead and establish their own structures can backfire immensely. I've seen this (and currently living it firsthand) happen, to the point that the minority group is around 1.5% of the population but holds around 10% of executive and corporate positions[1]. And of course, the 90% majority is baying for blood... > "Celebrate," I'd assume. Segregation is never a reason to celebrate. [1] Last I checked, anyway, which was about a decade ago.
- shadowgovt 5y ago> What do you think those people will say if the discriminated group sets up structures that further reinforce their success in succeeding generations? "Congratulations on achieving the American Dream." The NAACP already exists. What you're describing as a nightmare scenario is basically the way this has been done historically in America. It's part of the "rugged individualism" mythology that a group that feels marginalized organizes to take care of itself.
- bitwize 5y agoOne of the reasons why MIT has the reputation it has, is because MIT admitted lots of smart Jewish students who couldn't get into Harvard... because they were Jewish. (Keeping the Jews out was once largely the point behind Harvard's selective admissions process.) If, today, Harvard is keeping Asians out, it means more smart, eager Asian students to be recruited by other universities, which just might rise in status for admitting those students.
- zer0-c00l 5y ago100%. So many people in this thread are out here acting like going to an Ivy League school is a guaranteed right afforded to those who score well on tests. That’s never been the case. These institutions have been discriminatory from the start and IMO more or less historically exist to provide a path to success for privileged, mediocre, old money scions.